OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
120996467 over 3 years ago

continuing from last comment, if unhappy please discuss at talk-au

119224223 over 3 years ago

See Changeset #120996467

120140719 over 3 years ago

see Changeset #120996442

120382941 over 3 years ago

see Changeset #120996238

120996238 over 3 years ago

see discussion at Changeset: 120382941 if you are unhappy with the change, please discuss on talk-au

120404702 over 3 years ago

see Changeset #120995852, way: 326012697 restored to previous state

120963296 over 3 years ago

Hi. access=no, not even prison guards? What is your information source?

120140719 over 3 years ago

There is shared path signage at OShea and Riviera.

120382941 over 3 years ago

This is possibly the busiest cycleway in Melbourne. You are required to walk your bike over the MacRobertson Bridge see the mark on the path https://www.mapillary.com/app/user/tonyf1?lat=-37.829741666667&lng=145.01292222222&z=17&pKey=320855036181735&focus=photo&x=0.46570260562484334&y=0.5773553235026632&zoom=0.8864569083447333 removing the tagging permitting bicycles makes no sense at all.

120404702 over 3 years ago

Hi Way: 326012697. There is a sign. https://www.mapillary.com/app/user/tonyf1?lat=-38.113213611726&lng=145.29940143715&z=17&pKey=1003221370565611&focus=photo&x=0.26573635477691526&y=0.720188367558698&zoom=1.7729138166894665 end shared path which implies that some or all of the path north is shared

120621671 over 3 years ago

Thanks HighRouleur. I agree with Vadmium, the road crossings at Jells Rd appear to be "pedestrian crossings". The section from the substation to Sir Kenneth Luke Bvd could be footway or shared.

120621671 over 3 years ago

Hi, there is a lot of shared path signage. At Garnett Rd, Wetlands Golf N games, Kevin Wood Bridge to name 3. Please revert this change.

119224223 almost 4 years ago

Further to point (2) in previous comment, https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-37.93692468504&lng=145.19257639337&z=17&pKey=1146728119134333&x=0.3784046784323634&y=0.5438261010626115&zoom=1.5

a WATCH FOR BICYCLES sign provides some indication that a shared path or cycleway may cross the freeway on ramp

119224223 almost 4 years ago

Hi, what evidence do you have that it is a footway south of Elllis Park Ave, anything other than a lack of signage? That has three problems, (1) the last sign just south of Ellis Pk is an end shared path sign (to cross Ellis Pk Av) which implies a shared path was in force for at least some of that path south, (2) there may be bicycle signage further south (3) OSM consensus does not allow lack of signage as a sole reason for retagging.

119223528 almost 4 years ago

Hi Sebastian, its asking a bit much for you to comment when you can't yet view the Mapillary tracks in map view. There are 19 photos in the Springvale Rd set and 9 in the Jackson Rd set. Please let me know when you have worked out which photos are where and then we can continue the discussion

119223528 almost 4 years ago

The map view cache in Mapillary may be old. You can still step through the photo sequence.

119223528 almost 4 years ago

The photo sequence I supplied shows shared path signage at least as far as 651 Springvale Rd, near Caravan Court.

119224223 almost 4 years ago

The photo sequence I supplied shows shared path signage to at least just south of Ellis Park Avenue, that's about 300m further south of what you are saying. I see no need to split the path.

119223528 almost 4 years ago

https://www.mapillary.com/app/user/tonyf1?lat=-37.982454967277&lng=145.14651540801&z=17&pKey=3146850278920298&focus=photo sign and path markings looking north
https://www.mapillary.com/app/user/tonyf1?lat=-37.97877859999999&lng=145.1471173&z=18.56392192351324&pKey=135256952382880&focus=photo sign looking back south

119223362 almost 4 years ago

shared path sign https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-37.987075950296&lng=145.15444414202&z=17&pKey=481297156525035&focus=photo&x=0.43087651002785543&y=0.47421908728879897&zoom=0.8864569083447333

If I don't hear from you, I will revert