OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
162386653 10 months ago

Hi,
you added about 30 tags that are not used in any other place - this is (in general) too much for a simple shop.

Usually we don't map all the different services and products of a shop in detail - that is just too much information for a geo-database like OSM.

For some other tags, check the wiki for

min_age
surveillance
contact:instagram
language:*

162403271 10 months ago

Hi,
ich habe ein paar "authentification" Tags korrigiert - korrekt heißt es "authentication".

162236409 10 months ago

Seems fine to me. I think we should have it documented on the Street_Parking wiki page.

162236409 10 months ago

Hi,
you started to use the tag
parking:both:ticket:zone

I'm aware the Wiki lags a way to distinguish ticket and resident zones.

There's already
parking:both:zone:residents in use.
I therefore suggest to use the same order in the key here:

parking:both:zone:ticket

162353352 11 months ago

I reverted these changes.

162301051 11 months ago

If only residents have access using an QR code, you can tag this as

authentication:qrcode=yes
access = residents

I would not add a payment tag, because there is no way to pay for the containers directly.

162301051 11 months ago

Hi,
could you check the waste amenities added here?

- a "waste_transfer_station" is usually a larger industrial complex, but not containers in a residential area
- the different things collected are usually tagged as 'recycling:*', not with the 'waste' tag
- what does "payment:tax" mean? This tag is not used in other places.

Regarding the containers, see
amenity=recycling

162353352 11 months ago

Something went wrong here - there are 55000 new objects without any proper tag.

162345884 11 months ago

Hi,
you added a strange "sharko" tag to thousands of objects. Was this added by mistake?

162304683 11 months ago

Hi,
there are a couple of tags here that are not in use up to now. Could you point us to a definition of them? Numeric "level" values are always quite difficult to understand without a proper definition.

noise_level = 3
safety_level = 4
security_level = 4
soundproof_level = 3

162237478 11 months ago

The phone numbers are *from* different countries, but not *for* different countries. Both have a country prefix and are reachable from anywhere in the world.
The phone:XX tags with country suffixes are used for local phone numbers (often toll-free or special numbers) that are only usable within one country.

161972973 11 months ago

It's hard to judge what the best solution is. If the codes refer to different parts of the station, I would map them as such. If the station just has two codes, I'd add them in the main tag as a list.

Nevertheless, could you decide for one spelling of the suffix?
E.g. there are:
network:wikidata:Elizabeth_Line
network:wikidata:Elizabeth_line
network:wikidata:Elizabeth line

162165653 11 months ago

Hi Robert,
I see that you started to use a properly namespaced version of cqc location ids. Could you also have a look to the 100 existing

cqc:location:id
cqc:location_id

and check if they can be updated as well?

162089326 11 months ago

Please check the tags you added on all these gas stations.

You claim the source is "Official Ukrnafta data" - is this data available under a license that is compatible with ODbL and OSM?

These are not common addr tags:
addr:ISO3166-2-lvl4
addr:house_number
addr:municipality
addr:road

There's no need to have two phone tags:
contact:phone
contact:phone:UA
The number with international prefix should be in 'contact:phone' and nothing in a :UA tag.

162082147 11 months ago

Thanks! I just changed the conditional accordingly

162081859 11 months ago

Da habe ich auch keine gute Idee.

Ich hatte den Weg nur editiert weil er außerdem noch ein anderes Tag hatte, das da nicht hingehört:

"iD_validator_skip_to_allow_upload=yes"

162041979 11 months ago

Hi,
please watch out for the correct spelling of tags. Neither
Highway = residential
nor
hihgway = residential

are proper tags for streets in OSM. The only correct form is
highway = residential

162017278 11 months ago

If there is a consensus to add tags this way, it might be helpful. If only you use these tags its not: Others searching for this event will look for "Chido" in the value of a "damage:event" tag, which doesn't exist on these buildings.

162017278 11 months ago

Hi,
you added "Chido" to your damage* keys. That's not common for other events - usually the plain tags damage:event and damage:date are used. Could you check and maybe change the tagging?

161972973 11 months ago

Hi,
naptan tags with a suffix for station parts are not in use up to now. Would it be possible to add them to different objects instead? The main node could get both values as a list as well.