OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
170263003 4 months ago

Please be careful. You have drawn the sidewalk right across the building. That is wrong: either it should go beside the building, or in case it goes as a covered passage through the ground floor of the building (and only in such a case), the sidewalk should be separated into several parts that have common points with the walls of the building, and the middle part should be tagged as covered=yes or covered=colonnade and so on.

170196095 4 months ago

Well... If they are still there and are useful for navigation, I would say that's aerialway=cable_car+disused=yes. Or why have you used such tagging for Tsinsopeli cable car?

(I meant the paired cable cars საბაგირო ავტოგზა - საფარა + საბაგირო ავტოგზა - მღვიმევი.)

170196095 4 months ago

The last time I saw them (a year ago), the cable cars Itkvisi - Darkveti, Tsopi - Avarioni and Sapara/Mgvimevi were still there, with cabins hanging from the cables. Has anything changed? Have they been cut down?

144157360 4 months ago

mostly reverted by now

169876206 5 months ago

Then you can use, for example, https://revert.monicz.dev/ to revert a part of the changeset. The filter should be like this: node(id:1195252791)

169876206 5 months ago

Was relocating node/1195252791 intentional or not?

168998152 5 months ago

"According to Georgian low bus lines can access specific type of taxes and mopeds as well."
Yes, this is precisely why bus lanes in Georgia should be mapped not as highway=busway, but as highway=service with access=no + bus=designated + psv=designated + taxi=designated + bicycle=designated/yes

168998152 5 months ago

Hi! highway=busway should be used for roads that are *only* accessible to buses, that is, there are inaccessible for any other mean of transport? including taxis and bikes. As far as I know, there are no such roads in Georgia. So I reverted the change of the type; but also I've added access=no tag. Apparently access:lanes is not enough for some software...

168945181 5 months ago

I reverted these edits because they included deletion of existing objects which cause some issues in iD velifator. This revertion is approved by local Geogian community

changeset/169821860

168916978 5 months ago

Actually, you've deleted not a duplicated road, but an overground pipeline, likely for natural gas. But I can't confirm that it really exists

168598878 5 months ago

thkx, @evgenykatyshev! Yes, the address had been mapped from the ground

168482729 5 months ago

mostly reverted changeset/169818013 : it has been agreed that road leading to apartment buildings cannot be called driveways; the entrance is not to some staircase, but a main entrance to the building

109105658 5 months ago

rv for way(id:51067848), already reverted for way(id:51067846)

changeset/169362469

168958296 5 months ago

👍

168292400 6 months ago

Hi! The previous version was actually more correct. Even though the signs often call such parks as "Square" in English, this is incorrect; English "square" is equivalent to Georgian მოედანი, while Georgian სკვერი is best rendered as "park" in English. In OSM a standardised translation is preferred, even though a physical sign may present a different translation.

165648532 6 months ago

"Memorial" tag is always "historic" (from wiki) — yes, but that's only because the only tag for mapping a memorial is "historic=memorial". The tag "memorial=obelisk" doesn't map anything by itself, it only specifies the type of a memorial; but "historic=memorial" still is required, otherwise the object won't be shown on maps (which is why added the present object in the first place — there wasn't anything showing on the map).

Also, I suggest that you add "name:ru=Бойцам героической рабоче-крестьянской Красной армии" (and preferably in other languages also) to the older object so that it can be identified using those maps that do not process the inscription tag (most do not).

168191542 6 months ago

I have restored some older ways, replacing their properties and nodes with those from your ways: changeset/168198990

168191542 6 months ago

Hi! Please try to preserve existing objects as much as possible (per osm.wiki/Keep_the_history ). You have deleted way/581211163/history and created way/1410092052 instead; it would have been far better to edit the existing object, updating its geometry and properties.

Also, with respect to way/1410092051 and way/818085401 , note that the combination area=yes+barrier=wall means that the whole of the area is a very thick solid wall, not an area surrounded by a wall. If you need the latter, just use barrier=wall.

165648532 6 months ago

hmm, the other object lacks historic=memorial tag. So the two objects should be merged

167815285 6 months ago

Have you checked this one in particular?