Hi :)

nice to see someone working on my old prowling ground in Höchst.

Still there's the question what this is supposed to be:
node/13097765705

(and next time try to keep it local ;)

cheers
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/171010287

Hello robram2004,

thank you for replying.

it's not about absolutely not mapping things with strava. It's about being very careful with the sources you use and the places you use them in.

If there's only a hint of trails someplace and no other evidence and you haven't been there personally it's not a good idea to map a path. It's also never a good idea to map a "highway=footway" somewhere in the forest where you haven't been.

If you've been someplace and you have seen a path going somewhere it's ok to use strava to map the path and even make it longer beyond where you saw it. It's a good guess.

I hope you understand what I'm trying to say?

Also, please consult the wiki on all things "highway" before you continue.

You wouldn't wish to think that there's a well trodden path someplace because our data says so and when you get there there's just jungle or desert, right?

safe travels
silversurfer83

Alles klar. Dann passts.

Falls du irgendwann mal am anderen Ende vorbei kommst wäre es interessant zu wissen, was dort steht.

Hi :)

danke für die Anpassung. Wenn hier jedoch, so wie du sagst, *kein* Zusatzschild "Radfahrer frei" und auch keine lokale Radroute ausgeschildert ist, dann dürfen wir hier kein "bicycle=yes" setzen, da es rein rechtlich einfach nicht erlaubt ist.

Dass es wirklich unglaublich häufig vorkommt, dass die Verwaltung nur an den motorisierten Verkehr denkt, wenn sie Schilder aufstellen lässt ändert leider nichts daran.

Ggf. mal ne Mail an die Verwaltung. Manchmal werden dann bessere Schilder aufgestellt.

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170994204

Hi Rob,

to rephrase what ilias_ said:

please do not work at three places around the whole globe in one changeset. Make separate changes for each location.

Also: You added "highway=footway" somewhere in the South American forest. If there really is something, it probably is a highway=path.

People have said before that it is not advisable to map by Strava alone. There should be at least a second reason to add something to the map besides Strava data.

happy mapping
silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170993478

Hi :)

auch wenn es technisch gut möglich ist eine Adresse aus dem Umriss auf den POI zu berechnen ist es trotzdem ok und nicht unüblich einem POI die volle Adresse aus Str., HsNr, PLZ und Ort zu geben. Auch wenn das dazu führt, dass eine Adresse in der Suche mehrfach auftaucht, so ist es doch für viele Anwendungen wesentlich einfacher.

Happy mapping
silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170990084

Hello Marius,

It is not advisable to edit an active war zone with *clearly* outdated aerial imagery. Please refrain from doing so in the future.

I have reverted this in full in changeset/170979391
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170975927

Hello there :)

this track way/1424694822 should have triggered a warning before you saved this edit. It crosses another track without connection at its' SW end. Maybe you can try and fix this and please watch out for warnings from the editor software in the future. Thank you

silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170950291

Bitte im Forum melden:

https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/unklare-quellenlage-bei-nio-power-swap-stationen/134752

Hi :)

check mal bitte
bollard=*
und setz bei deinen neuen Pollern hier ggf. passendere Werte. Danke
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170927249

Thanks for the quick response.

I haven't looked at the english wiki for tennis courts recently but the parts you quoted sound like they need discussion in the community and an update because I dislike having to very different "top level" tags (barrier=fence + landuse=*) on the same OSM-object.

Interesting workflow. Dropping the nodes so the MR-challenge will pick them up.

happy mapping

Hi :)

I think it's ok to remove the pitch from the fence but then only adding a node for each pitch is a bit cheap, don't you think?

Also, I don't think the landuse is needed here. Just keep the fence and add each pitch individually

way/502190271

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170935520

Danke
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170940886

Hi :)

ich sehe, dass du hier vor ein paar Jahre den node von cellar_entrance zu historic building geändert hast. Damit bin ich nicht ganz einverstanden, da es für mich so aussieht als hätte Jo_Cassel damals ganz korrekt den Eingang zum Keller kartiert und mehr stellt dieser node auch nicht dar. Daher sollten building:levels:underground und historic=building wieder entfernt werden und wieder ein Kellereingang aus dem node gemacht werden, oder?

Grüße
silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170937689

Thank you for replying.

I'm talking about the rather specific details you added to all the stations in this and adjacent changesets. I don' t think you got it all from the press, did you?

Danke für die schnelle Rückmeldung.

Das hilft schonmal. Optimal wäre zu wissen, wie die Beschilderung aus der anderen Richtung aussieht (das ist leider oft nicht einheitlich und macht es uns schwerer).

Bis wir das wissen wäre folgender Satz Eigenschaften ab der Schranke am Weg korrekt:

highway=track
tracktype=grade1
surface=(was auch immer der genaue Belag ist)
vehicle=agricultural

Wie du siehst habe ich nur eine Beschränkung aufgeschrieben. Mehr ist nicht nötig.

Als Einstieg dazu empfehle ich:
osm.wiki/DE:Key:access

Bei Fragen immer raus damit
silversurfer83

Hi :)

die Zugangsberechtigungen hinter der Schranke sehen etwas komisch aus. way/47349106

Kannst du die genaue Verkehrszeichenkombination nennen, die hier den Zugang regelt? Wer darf unter welchen Umständen durch die Schranke?

Grüße
silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170846974

Hello again

could you please explain where you sourced all the info (not only the locations which are visible from above but also everything else) you added in this CS?

Hello fullsoul,

thank you for contributing to HOT and thus to OSM.

There are two things I'd like you to improve in your work:

- please do not delete and then redraw objekts that only need moving. The rule here is called "Keep the history" [1]

- please keep to the area of the project you started. Don't jump all over the globe in one changeset. [2]

Thank you for your time

[1] osm.wiki/Keep_the_history

[2] osm.wiki/Changeset#Geographical_size_of_changesets
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170830055

Hello rbtosm,

what fellow mapper ilias_ possibly wishes to say is:

It does look like you forgot to upload your quests before moving to another place to survey using StreetComplete. This created a rather large bbox which then showed up in the QA-feeds of many people not interested in your edits.

Don't worry too much, it happens to the best.

Just keep in mind to upload when you're done with your survey in one place. That's all.

happy mapping and safe travels

silversurfer83

osm.wiki/Changeset#Geographical_size_of_changesets
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/170800157