OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
151824643 over 1 year ago

Hi, good detailing, but please don't remove ways inside parking lots. It allows to use routing software.

151520379 over 1 year ago

Nice.

If you're in the area, could you please check what kind of sign/road marking is here at the beginning of the "Peedu kergliiklustee"? The name suggests that bicycles should be allowed there, but access tags on it are confusing with only foot=designated

note/4230929

151368777 over 1 year ago

Yes, it's subjective. There is a oneway:bicycle=no, to account for direction, but I've noticed that wiki suggests using cycleway:right:oneway=no which is probably not supported by many apps. So, to avoid confusion, maybe it's better as a separate way.

151368777 over 1 year ago

Hi, cycleway:right=track was put in with a goal to show that it's directly adjacent to the carriageway and not protected from the cars. I'm not really against something mapped your way, but in OSM it's better not to break things for each other or we'll have edit wars.

But there is an actual problem here too. You shouldn't have added bicycle=use_sidepath. Access tags are about the law and there is nothing prohibiting cyclists from using the carriageway (sõidutee). In Estonia, bicycle=use_sidepath is not applicable, please remove it.

148138779 over 1 year ago

Hi, please don't change bicycle-pedestrian paths to footways. More information on mapping cycling infrastructure:
https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/mapping-cycleways-in-estonia/104894

150947171 over 1 year ago

Hi, I've removed the duplicate building you've created.

150915111 over 1 year ago

Hi and welcome!

You don't have to add names to everything. Paths usually don't have names. Mostly, we try to keep things more or less in sync with Maa-amet (land board) and road registry in Estonia.

With exceptions when there are signs on the ground which specify the name of a path or a forest path having a distinct name from being a known trail for training or being advertised with such name. I guess Peedu kergliiklustee along the tracks nearby is one of such cases.

Consider removing Tuletõrje and Oja names from paths.

116075221 over 1 year ago

Yes, you can remove them

116075221 over 1 year ago

Hi, you can check address history in Maa-amet
https://xgis.maaamet.ee/adsavalik/ads?ads_oid=ME03789343

it does show that previously it had a lot of addresses

Harju maakond, Tallinn, Lasnamäe linnaosa, Kesk-Sõjamäe tn 10a // Lennujaama tee 4 // 6 // 10 // 11 // 12 // 14 // Tartu mnt 101 // 103 // Väike-Sõjamäe tn 1a // 2 // 12 // 12a

but now it's just
Harju maakond, Tallinn, Lasnamäe linnaosa, Väike-Sõjamäe tn 22b

148055008 over 1 year ago

Hi, it makes little sense to have these two
way/1256031933
relation/11737303
as separate features.

150656832 over 1 year ago

Hi, when using conditional tags, you should specify the default value too, so that the data consumers would know what it is when the condition does not apply.

In this case
access=no
access:conditional=yes @ (May-Sep)

you may also want to reverse this condition so that data consumers who don't know about conditional suffixes would parse just access=yes.

150615188 over 1 year ago

Hi,
1) highway links should be of the highest type of highway. So a link of a residential road with a highway=secondary will always be highway=secondary_link
2) there is no such thing as a highway=residential_link in OSM

139838574 over 1 year ago

osm.org/edit#map=20/59.36898/24.64031
bicycle=yes on the way and bicycle=dismount on cycle barriers contradict each other.

If cycling is forbidden, then it's not only at barriers. If it's just hard, but not forbidden, then barrier by itself is enough, not need for access tags on it.

149363650 almost 2 years ago

Hi and welcome, you probably wanted to use ditches instead of canals

142226833 almost 2 years ago

There is no need to add all those access tags to footways. They allow only pedestrians by default. I'll remove them so that they don't confuse osm standard renderer

149183674 almost 2 years ago

Hi, it's better to tag dirt roads as paths. Some data consumers don't read the surface tag. It also allows bicycle routing on these paths.

149315961 almost 2 years ago

I'm really surprised you do this in iD. JOSM has some plugins to display lanes in the editor and also edit them not as a text.

149029808 almost 2 years ago

There are actually 11 spaces, fixed it.

148746552 almost 2 years ago

Hi,
if the place is closed forever either delete it or add a lifecycle prefix
osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix
for example:
was:shop=cannabis
was:amenity=restaurant

148387820 almost 2 years ago

Hi, it's better to use highway=path or highway=cycleway when it's bicycle=designated (then need foot=designated too).

footways are usually for pedestrians only