Hi, i commented on one of your earlier changesets (changeset/125568505), asking to stick to mappings of the required features.

Now i notice you mapped here tracks, waterways, barriers. These are not required in this project.

You mapped them quite well, that is not the problem. But all these extra objects will complicate the validation of the project and therefor slow down the completion of it.

This is hurting the humanitarian efforts and thus the vulnerable people on the ground.

Remember, this is urgent disaster mapping.

Please wait with mapping these extra features until the project is finished.

Thanks for your cooperation and regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125728026

You requested a review of your mappings.

Thanks for contributing.

You mapped most of the buildings quite well.

In a few cases however you mapped an area surrounded by walls as a building. In that case look for the shadows inside the rectangle of the structure. It indicates it is a wall or fence that looks like a building from above.

Thanks and regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125729400

Hi, i am reviewing the mappings in this project.

Thanks for contributing. Unfortunately there are is an issues here.

You mapped tracks here. However, they are not required in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions.

Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

Please take this into account in your future mappings.

Thanks and regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125730694

Hi, i am reviewing the mappings in this project.

Thanks for contributing. Unfortunately there are a few issues here.

1. You mapped several buildings as one building. Every building though must be traced separately. Zoom in as close as possible to see the outline of the buildings, hit each corner of the building carefully. Look for shadows, open ground, changes in roof color and vegetation to differentiate buildings. See also the example images in the project chat. And please do not forget to square your buildings after tagging them by pressing ‘q’ on your keyboard.

2. You surrounded settlements with a polygon and tagged it as scrub. I think you are confused by the instructions, this should instead be landuse=residential.

3. When you map a building partly over another building your editor incorrectly suggests to add a layer. You did that, but instead you should reshape or move the building.

Please take this into account in your future mappings.

Thanks and regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator.

I am reviewing the mappings in this project. Welcome to HOT.

Your mappings look good, thanks.

Please keep mapping.

Regards, Martien, Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125699348

I am reviewing the mappings in this project. Welcome to HOT.

Your mappings look very good, thanks.

Please keep mapping.

Regards, Martien, Global Validator
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125699629

I am reviewing the mappings in this project. Welcome to HOT.

Your mappings look very good, thanks.

Please keep mapping.

Regards, Martien, Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125699629

Hi, while reviewing this project i noticed that you mapped also waterways.

Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions. Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

It is ok to map other features though. But please upload these without the HOTOSM hashtag.

Btw, although i see a few instances where you mapped multiple buildings as one, your buildings look good. Thanks.

Regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator

Hi, while reviewing this project i noticed that you mapped also waterways.

Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions. Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

It is ok to map other features though. But please upload these without the HOTOSM hashtag.

Btw, your buildings look good, thanks.

Regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125683926

Hi, while reviewing this project i noticed that you mapped also waterways.

Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions. Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

It is ok to map other features. But please upload these without the HOTOSM hashtag.

Btw, your buildings look good, thanks.

Regards,

Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125688066

Hi Angelica, i notice you are using imagery Bing here. Please use Maxar instead, as per the project instructions. Just hit the B keyboard key to switch imagery.

Also, please square your buildings after tagging them by pressing ‘q’ on your keyboard.

Thanks and kind regards,

Martien, Global HOT Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125612642

Hi, you mapped a powerline here. Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions. Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

It is ok to map other features, but please upload them without the hotosm hashtag.

Thanks for your cooperation.

Regards Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125568505

Hi, you mapped a pond here. Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions.Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

And also please do not save one feature in one changeset. Saving lets say 5 to 10 features (this is based on gut feeling) will save you time. It also makes judging the quality of mappings easier for validators.

Thanks and please keep mapping.

Regards Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125556257

Hi, i noticed you mapped several highway=track here. Fyi, just a moment ago the project instructions changed and tracks are not required anymore (as are paths).

Also you mapped other objects than buildings and roads. Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions.Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

And please keep an eye on the squareness of the buildings. Square your buildings after tagging them by pressing ‘q’ on your keyboard.

Thanks and please keep mapping.

Regards Martien, HOT Global Validator
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125559165

Hi, i noticed you mapped several highway=track here. Fyi, just a moment ago the project instructions changed and tracks are not required anymore (as are paths).

Also you mapped farmland. Remember that we are only mapping buildings and roads in this project. This is detailed in the project instructions.

Humanitarian organizations set the features to be mapped based on their priorities - any time spent mapping other features might slow down the completion of their projects.

Thanks and please keep mapping.

Regards Martien, HOT Global Validator

Hi, i noticed you mapped several highway=track here. Fyi, just a moment ago the project instructions changed and tracks are not required anymore (as are paths).

Thanks and please keep mapping.

Regards Martien, HOT Global Validator

Reason for reversion: too many unjustified deleted objects

Reverted changeset/125272730
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125284197

Sorry, i reverted this changeset: too many feature were deleted that imo shouldn't had to be deleted.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125273828

Hi, i am a HOT validator. I noticed you deleted features several times. These features existed, and maybe could be better mapped. But there was no reason to delete.

Please only delete features if they do not exist anymore. Violating this rule could be considered at least as unpolite to the original mapper, and ultimately as vandalism.

Thanks.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/125270958