OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
135024778 over 2 years ago

Hello! Please do not add multilingual names in the name tag. Please refer to osm.wiki/India#Naming_in_different_scripts_and_languages

Marathi should go in name:mr, Hindi should go into name:hi and so on. While I do understand that Marathi is the primary language in Pune, and in Maharashtra, correctly tagging names helps a lot to take osm data and make multilingual maps. I have corrected Pune University according to these norms, but please do take care to add data in designated multilingual tags.

Also, thank you for the multilingual data! We need more Marathi names to be added in Pune :)

134958776 over 2 years ago

Your edits covered my area of interest, along with several other points on the other side of the world, meaning that they were not targeted towards a specific geography. The first place I turned to in order to understand what changed, was the changeset comment, which did not mention explain what was the reason which warranted Multi-continent level changes. Hence the question, and hence my conclusion that the changes did not have a pattern to them, and were therefore, random. If that implies that I am opinionated, then so be it. I have no interest in getting into a pedantic argument with a stranger on the internet, so this will be my last comment on this changeset. We are all part of the same community and it’s important that we be transparent about what we’re doing so that others, especially local mappers, understand what is being changed in their surroundings.

134958776 over 2 years ago

Since you’ve not specified what you’ve done, I have every right to make my own conclusions.

134736287 over 2 years ago

Thanks a lot for these edits! It feels fantastic to have these little things mapped out that seem insignificant in the larger scope of things but are so important to local communities.

134951271 over 2 years ago

Hello! Welcome to OSM. Please keep your changesets limited to smaller geographical areas, and refer to proper changeset etiquette: osm.wiki/Changeset

134958776 over 2 years ago

Hello! What have you fixed, and why have you made such random changes across multiple countries?

134970209 over 2 years ago

Hello! Please keep your changesets limited to a smaller geographical area.

135009522 over 2 years ago

Hello, and welcome to OSM! Thanks for your great edits, a few suggestions though:
1. Since you've requested a review, please keep your changesets geographically smaller. Here, it would have been better if you edited trailes in vetal tedki separately, and taljai separately.
2. Pay attention to the warnings and errors. RIght now, it shows warnings:disconnected_way:highway 4 -> these will show up when you commit your changeset. Please try and resolve these before committing.

If you've got any questions, please feel free to ask on the OSM India Telegram: https://t.me/OSMIndia

134927634 over 2 years ago

Hello! Please try and keep your changes limited to smaller geographic areas. Thanks.

134820102 over 2 years ago

Hello! Could you please explain what you fixed exactly?

134736287 over 2 years ago

Hello! Thanks for adding details like these to OSM. From whatever I know of the area, all these playgrounds are actually equipments along the footpath. If you have in-depth knowledge of the place, would you be able to also add what equipments these are? playground=*

It would be an amazing thing to have mapped!

134740202 over 2 years ago

Welcome to OSM. Thanks for adding data. However, please be more specific about the changes that you are making in the changeset comments. Being a community project, it is assumed that you have local knowledge of the area. It is important to state what you've changed exactly.

Please read through osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments#:~:text=A%20good%20changeset%20comment%20should,have%20edited%20on%20the%20map. and happy mapping!

134692921 over 2 years ago

JM road is split into multiple ways to accommodate change restrictions, it seems. The road will still be visible - but this changeset may not be the right place to discuss this. Could you send me a message on my osm id?

134674894 over 2 years ago

Thanks for checking, though I can still see the building tag as building=yes.

134528661 over 2 years ago

Please reply to comments. You've made further edits after this one so it would be great if you could reply to these questions?

134691195 over 2 years ago

Thanks for your edits to OSM. Please add building shapes correctly. Since you are using the iD editor, it is very easy to square off buildings. Please read and correct your edits: https://learnosm.org/en/hot-tips/tracing-rectangular-buildings/

134692921 over 2 years ago

Ah, ok. I misunderstood what you edited. Thanks for the clarification!

134674894 over 2 years ago

Why have you changed building=apartments to building=yes? The original tag was clearly correct.

134677443 over 2 years ago

Please use amenity=school to tag schools. osm.wiki/Education_features

134677617 over 2 years ago

Welcome to OSM. Why have you added a building on top of an existing building? Please correct.