OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
62998069 over 6 years ago

#WhatInGrabsNameIsThis?

A "driveway" lining parallel to the south side of CentralWorld as mapped here is very misleading:

- It shown that driveway's entrance was its east side, which was completely wrong; it is an exit- an access-forbidden "exit" to be precise.
- Its real entrance and exit are not mapped.
- This is actually a _one-way_ cab-hailing lane (with taxi stop), with opposite traffic direction from what the thing you mapped implies.

These made what you mapped useless for navigation. If I had to guess, I think you just mapped a light-gray sidewalk next to the actual cab lane, because that is the only part that is not obscured by trees.

This part of the edit is now reverted in changeset/69634787 <changeset/69634787>.

What you mapped: <https://u.cubeupload.com/xwindows/Q8pWFP.png>
What it really is: <http://u.cubeupload.com/xwindows/IkwVE6.png>

62658038 over 6 years ago

This edit is now partially reverted further via changeset/69633902 <changeset/69633902> along the Samsen road.

Reasons:

- You added stairs to crossing in front of Saint Gabriel school that lead directly into the road- which are utterly false.
- You disfigured the east entrance driveway of Suan Suanandha university.
- You broke consistency of ordering between Musical Association of Thailand's entrance driveway and Samsen 9 drive.

63272497 over 6 years ago

This edit is now entirely reverted via changeset/69633902 <changeset/69633902>.

See discussions on changeset <changeset/62658038> (twelfth comment) if you need further explanation.

67133468 over 6 years ago

A "Seven eleven" _supermarket_ POI on Musical Association of Thailand building <node/5156586979> added by this changeset is a duplicate of the one already mapped as 7-Eleven *convenience store* there <node/5156586979>.

This duplicate is removed via changeset/69633169 <changeset/69633169>.

69022215 over 6 years ago

A "restaurant" named "Sensens" on Saint Gabriel school ground <node/6391901310> is actually a ice cream palour Swensens.

This POI is fixed on changeset/69597011 <changeset/69597011>

64998619 over 6 years ago

#WhatInGrabsNameIsThis? This edit is now partially reverted in changeset/69591628 <changeset/69591628>, around Scala theater in Siam Square area.

Reason: You are basically editing ground-contributed OSM data to allow falsehood introduced by your team to pass JOSM validation.

See the second comment on changeset/62997737's discussion <changeset/62997737> if you need further explanation.

62997737 over 6 years ago

#WhatInGrabsNameIsThis? A residential street between Scala theater and UFM bakery?

<way/628737821>

A really *dangerous* kind of falsehood here; and second one in this changeset now, I must say.

What you mapped as a "branch" of Siam Square driveway 1 is actually the Scala food court- with narrow path in the middle, just enough to accommodate pedestrians, the rest are long row of food stands and tables full of dining customers; no vehicle allowed.

- This is what you mapped: <https://u.cubeupload.com/xwindows/NK9M8w.png>
- This is what it really is: <https://u.cubeupload.com/xwindows/syaPrn.png>

Imagine what would happen if someone mistakenly thrust their car in there because of a false map you just written?

False map kills.

This part of the edit, along with corresponding part of changeset/64998619 <changeset/64998619>; are now reverted in changeset/69591628 <changeset/69591628>.

62932784 over 6 years ago

#WhatInGrabsNameIsThis? A driveway connecting the front of Phitsanulok House and Mission Hospital!?

This is utterly false; it is a large sidewalk of the main road, even people on a passing bus could easily see it as such.

This falsehood is now reverted in changeset/69589672 <changeset/69589672>.

69022215 over 6 years ago

And other things:

1. If you are adding POIs, make sure to *add at least their name*, or else they wouldn't be very useful (nor verifiable) to other contributors.
2. If you just described the place (probably because you can't type the Thai name), please do so in the _description_ field <description=*>, not the name field. Also see the next point.
3. I'm quite sure that Chao Pho Suea shrine (at where Tanao road meets Mahannop road) is not named "Chinese tempel" [sic]:

- The POI you mapped: <node/6391904586>
- Wikipedia article about the shrine: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Chao_Pho_Suea_Phra_Nakhon>
- The "religion" field should be assigned as "Chinese folk religion" (`chinese_folk`).

69022215 over 6 years ago

I have reverted parts of this upload in changeset/69107411 <changeset/69107411>.

Reason: This upload introduces several unnamed POIs in Bang Khun Phrom/Thewet area that I could verify as duplicates. From north to south:

- (unnamed shoes shop) <node/6391901332> is a duplicate of Pensri shoes shop <way/673302261>.
- (unnamed restuarant) <node/6391901333> is a duplicate of Supharp noodle joint <way/673302254>.
- (unnamed "gift" shop) <node/6391901508> is a duplicate of "Basket of Handweaven Fabric" botique <way/673291201>.

To other contributors: This changeset is very large, there might be other duplicate POIs that are not yet spotted. If anyone can identify duplicates, please do- and also comment here.

65124082 over 6 years ago

I have went through other Grab-related edits on this area, and found that this is a second shoddy attempt to fix a _nested_ mess caused by Grab team themselves. Another instance that Grab team rope _unpaid_ contributors to re-survey and fix them, by hand.

This edit is now _fully reverted_ by changeset/68883346 <changeset/68883346>.

65066999 over 6 years ago

I have went through other Grab-related edits on this area, and found that this is a shoddy attempt to fix a mess caused by Grab team themselves- by replacing it with even more mess; adding even more burden to unpaid contributors who have to craft hand-reverts through stack of them.

This edit is now _fully reverted_ by changeset/68883346 <changeset/68883346>.

62994668 over 6 years ago

This edit is also adding excessive nodes to a roadway behind The Market Bangkok, despite the real road being straight.

The corresponding part is now reverted via changeset/68883346 <changeset/68883346>.

68948521 over 6 years ago

My bad, the above comment was intended for changeset <changeset/63001055> which this changeset reverts. Please disregard.

63001055 over 6 years ago

This edit has been partially reverted via changeset/68948521 <changeset/68948521> on the part which a driveway cut through the back of Arnoma hotel.

Reasons:

1. The driveway as mapped here has a false geometry, it does not go between north and south of Arnoma hotel- details in the next point.

2. The driveway as mapped here has a false connection to driveway at the south side of Big C. The real thing connects to Ratchadamri road at the north-west of the hotel, runs along hotel's north side, turn to south, and ends at a closed gate.

3. The driveway as mapped here attempts to connect to a driveway at the south of Arnoma hotel through an access-forbidden gate, without being marked accordingly.

68948521 over 6 years ago

This edit has been partially reverted via changeset/68948521 <changeset/68948521> on the part which a driveway cut through the back of Arnoma hotel.

Reasons:

1. The driveway as mapped here has a false geometry, it does not go between north and south of Arnoma hotel- details in the next point.

2. The driveway as mapped here has a false connection to driveway at the south side of Big C. The real thing connects to Ratchadamri road at the north-west of the hotel, runs along hotel's north side, turn to south, and ends at a closed gate.

3. The driveway as mapped here attempts to connect to a driveway at the south of Arnoma hotel through an access-forbidden gate, without being marked accordingly.

68910846 over 6 years ago

This edit was fully reverted in changeset/68951350 <changeset/68951350>.

Reason: The Market Bangkok is already mapped in detail as way/539806478 <way/539806478>. The submitted POI is a duplicate- your MAPS.ME data is outdated in this case.

68951350 over 6 years ago

Note that this is effectively a reversion of changeset/68910846 <changeset/68910846>.

62964007 over 6 years ago

This edit has been partially reverted in changeset/68865929 <changeset/68865929> and changeset/68869424 <changeset/68869424>.

68865929 over 6 years ago

Thanks for actually coming back to clean up at least some of #WhatInGrabsNameIsThis mess.

But would like to let you know that you forgot to remove:

- node/5933239844 <node/5933239844>
- node/5933239854 <node/5933239854>

I have cleaned this up for you in changeset/68869424 <changeset/68869424>.