CurlingMan13's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 131781228 | almost 3 years ago | As mentioned in the other changesets in this area, This railway, specifically the section over by Toms River does not exist. It has not existed in a very long time and has no remnants remaining to meet the definition of "abandoned railway" in regards to the OSM wiki. Please do not map things that do not exist on OSM. If it is for historical purposes, please use the appropriate avenue, which would be OpenHistoricalMaps (OHM). Please remove the railway that does not exist. |
| 131673420 | almost 3 years ago | This railway, specifically the section over by Toms River does not exist. It has not existed in a very long time and has no remnants remaining to meet the definition of "abandoned railway" in regards to the OSM wiki. Please do not map things that do not exist on OSM. If it is for historical purposes, please use the appropriate avenue, which would be OpenHistoricalMaps (OHM). Please remove the railway that does not exist. |
| 131781855 | almost 3 years ago | Most of the segments along this way do not meet the definition of an "abandoned Railway" in accordance with the OSM wiki, which states "where the rails have been removed but the route is still visible with ties/sleepers, signals or other railroad right of way signs or infrastructure." Additionally, "Expect anything mapped for historical purposes to be removed at a later date. See Open Historical Map for opportunities to map history." Therefore, it is probably better to just add this to Open Historical Maps (OHM). A number of these areas have been completely overbuilt by houses and other buildings with no presence remainging. I recommend reverting this changeset to only have what is physically on the ground, and instead mapping things purely for "historical" reasons only on OHM with the appropriate tags. Source:
|
| 19523148 | almost 3 years ago | How is that multipolygon update going? |
| 131893295 | almost 3 years ago | But what is weird is they show up under TIGER 2021. So I am not sure if construction is just planned and hasn't started yet?
|
| 131927996 | almost 3 years ago | You added a cartpath over a railroad track which does not exist. Please do not map and destroy the map for your little video game. |
| 131794702 | almost 3 years ago | Reviewed - Looks Good!
|
| 131825366 | almost 3 years ago | This feature does not exist and has been removed accordingly. Also, please be more descriptive in your changeset comments.
|
| 131878667 | almost 3 years ago | I have reviewed your edit as requested. Edits look good and are already active on the map. :D
|
| 131864326 | almost 3 years ago | This isn't a tunnel the entire length of the way. Please correct to only have it tagged as a tunnel for the sections that are actually a tunnel.
|
| 131861381 | almost 3 years ago | Add of the country tag looks correct!
|
| 131872799 | almost 3 years ago | Changeset looks good. Cleaned up a couple tags to make them show up correctly on other apps.
|
| 131887694 | almost 3 years ago | Did a couple adjustments to make sure tags were correct and removed the personal info in the operator field. Changeset looks good!
|
| 131886637 | almost 3 years ago | Did a couple adjustments to make sure tags were correct and removed the personal info in the operator field. Changeset looks good!
|
| 131887641 | almost 3 years ago | Did a couple adjustments to make sure tags were correct and removed the personal info in the operator field. Changeset looks good!
|
| 131886684 | almost 3 years ago | Did a couple adjustments to make sure tags were correct and removed the personal info in the operator field. Changeset looks good!
|
| 131886684 | almost 3 years ago | Did a couple adjustments to make sure tags were correct and removed the personal info in the operator field. Changeset looks good!
|
| 131889638 | almost 3 years ago | I concur. I have been working to remove "abandoned" and "disused" railways that have long since been removed and built over. The wiki says something along the lines of "abandoned" railways are those with rails, signals or railbeds present. In this case, what you removed has no trace.
|
| 131896163 | almost 3 years ago | Edit looks good! (adjusted hours to be in the correct format). Thanks for learning how to edit OSM and adding it yourself. :D
|
| 94597279 | almost 3 years ago | Please use more descriptive changeset comments. |