OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
163183029 10 months ago

What is the meaning of tags gpx:name and gpxx:DisplayColor?

162751182 10 months ago

Jbensman,
I realize this discussion has been one-on-one so far, but what Hufkratzer says does reflect community-wide consensus. While there is no OSM police, moderators absolutely do ensure OSM principles are applied by correcting data such as that which you have mapped.

Edit-measuring contests are childish, and don't work in your favor anyhow, as Hufkratzer has contributed to the OSM wiki and various code repositories. What you are doing is called "tagging for the renderer", which you can read about on said wiki. The basic principle is to not break OSM just to fix some map. Using the wrong tag might make sense for your use, but it confuses everyone else.

Hufkratzer has very nicely offered several solutions that don't go against the principles of the site. No one is trying to make themselves "feel important", we're just trying to improve the correctness of the map. Your map is no more valuable than anyone else's. Keep that in mind when deciding whether it's a big deal to "break" it for everyone else for your own needs.

163140742 10 months ago

You replaced the website with the street address

162874857 10 months ago

While trying to connect a road to many crosswalks, sometimes the suggested fixes move positions and I end up clicking the wrong one. Oops.

162627123 10 months ago

Feature already exists with correct tags, please revert way/64357548

162700566 10 months ago

This is a shared asphalt driveway, not a residential road.

162410444 11 months ago

addr:city should contain the postal city, in this case "Holladay", rather than "City Of Holladay"

162333593 11 months ago

Deleting your own contributions is a form of vandalism.

162295430 11 months ago

Please check the location. 801 Everett Street should be four blocks away.

162257062 11 months ago

Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thank you for your edit! As requested, here's a review of your changeset.

The opening hour syntax is tricky to get right, but you have it down perfectly!

The phone number just needs a slight tweak. It should be in +<country code>-<area code>-<local number> format, in this case +1-208-373-0020.

I hadn't heard about the name change. Good to know!

161977458 11 months ago

Do not engage in further edit warring. I have already explained the issue with your edits. Any more edits of this nature will be reported to the Data Working Group.

161968106 11 months ago

Welcome to OpenStreetMap! Unfortunately, I have to revert your edits, because this is not the proper way to map a shopping center. In addition to the geometry being very inaccurate, this is a single building. If you have a floor plan that indicates the dimensions of each shop, you could map them as areas and add the address information. This geometry, however, is incorrect.

161936393 11 months ago

I have already explained the issue with partitioning the building in this way. Please do not map the shopping center like this again. Thank you.

161890149 11 months ago

This was constructed as a single building, so these subdivisions aren't really appropriate. Furthermore, the angles are not properly aligned.

I suggest mapping the individual shops as areas instead. They can be merged with the addresses to similar effect.

161867142 11 months ago

I don't think the peak is named in GNIS, but it looks like a local name in use: https://www.peakbagger.com/peak.aspx?pid=17030

161732624 11 months ago

Do not use the description for spam

image is used for pictures of the feature only, not company logos

161731052 11 months ago

Thank you for the additional info. The existing tags do not describe the feature, so I have updated them.

161731052 11 months ago

Cannot verify location

160134132 12 months ago

ChatGPT aside, you absolutely *can* learn how to maintain PT relations so that you avoid breaking them. I would argue that it is your duty to fix issues caused by you once you become aware of them.

There are plenty of ways to contribute to the map that don't require knowledge of route relations. You should stick to those if you're not willing to learn.

161364757 12 months ago

OpenStreetMap is a live database. Any consumers accessing a version of the data after you submit changes will see them reflected.