OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
77849397 about 6 years ago

s/Traffic/Drive

77752436 about 6 years ago

Machine translation to Russian is as follows:

Источник названий улиц, пожалуйста?

Вы добавили много названий улиц в штате Келантан Малайзии. Не могли бы вы предоставить свой источник для этого?

Заранее спасибо.

77752436 about 6 years ago

Where did you get the street names please?

73990842 over 6 years ago

Many thanks for your response. Anyway, just curious, are you any way related to Maxim, the ride sharing company?

73990842 over 6 years ago

Could you please state from where you get all street names please?

73991886 over 6 years ago

Source of street names please?

73951347 over 6 years ago

Hello, regarding to your edit around this area (refer changeset/73951347#map=16/6.2788/100.4259), may I know what is your source to determine the route reference number?

50037237 over 6 years ago

Unclassified highways:

way/368483382 (way/368483382/) leads to some residential and a row of shops adjacent to it. I cannot see why it should be downgraded to a residential highway. On top of that, it was surveyed by me a few years ago. (way/368483382/)

way/505084044 (way/505084044) may well be downgraded to a residential highway. There was probably no better imagery available when I mapped it.

way/255520065 (way/255520065/history) was mapped by a cyclist passing by this highway, so therefore, it's coming from ground truth.

way/391065168 (way/391065168) probably is best downgraded as a residential highway too.

50037237 over 6 years ago

Tracks:

way/619486495 (way/619486495) could be mapped as highway=service + service=driveway from the adjacent primary road up until node/6639966921 (node/6639966921)

way/255520054 (way/255520054/) is clearly mapped by a cyclist who went through the track 5 years ago (changeset/19841040). I believe it remains a track, and not even a suitable highway to be traversed by cars.

way/484975143 (way/484975143) was surveyed by me, back in 2017 (changeset/47483083)

72536419 over 6 years ago

Salam, bukan orang KL. Boleh tahu Kementah (way/706536788/history) ni tempat yang macam mana?

72537140 over 6 years ago

Hello, some feedback on your edits:

This particular way (way/706542305) was readded in this edit. Source: https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=72537140

Please take a look on these pictures: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blocks_placed_to_block_a_road.jpg and https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Blocked_U_turn.jpg which represents the ground truth of this particular way.

The highway is blocked, so therefore I don't map it as an existing highway.

65078491 over 6 years ago

Alright, fair justification. Please make appropriate changes for these highways.

35198311 over 6 years ago

I surveyed this highway myself and collected the GPS track for it. In addition, between 2003 and 2007, I used to pass this highway as well. So, that's why I justified this highway as a highway=unclassified rather than highway=residential.

21582790 over 6 years ago

Hi. Fair enough, please adjust accordingly.

43302185 over 6 years ago

As the one who mapped these highways from collecting my own GPS tracks: best if they are left as they were

22954983 over 6 years ago

Second comment:

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-Zw4uMecbsV8/XTbPQc5-6_I/AAAAAAAAAaY/uosKw8UJKv4C9VUL1XBh5HAs6a01SHWEQCK8BGAs/s0/2019-07-23.png

those two links should be left as they are: they connect to the adjacent highway=trunk. And they are links connecting to the adjacent highway going in/out of the residential area.

Sorry for the delay getting in touch with the team.

22954983 over 6 years ago

First comment: assuming you are pointing on this way (way/288251491). Please make suitable change to the higher classification (highway=unclassified) between these nodes: node/2918121022 and node/5921176441. Beyond the latter node, the highway should be splitted up as a highway=residential.

72759685 over 6 years ago

This issue might also affect every potential highways which have been mapped as highway=unclassified or highway=residential.

Please, hopefully your team's edits are re-reviewed.

72759685 over 6 years ago

I would like to draw attention to your mapping team: be extra careful to map potential highways in this area with paddy fields surrounding it.

For example, this highway (way/708427243) was mapped as an unclassified highway.

I drive around this area a few times a month. Usually highways adjacent to canals are merely dirt track for agricultural purposes. It may appear quite prominent, e.g. http://osmz.ru/imagery/#17/5.87901/100.44482/mp (from the imagery) but please, please take extra care.

I hope your team would begin fix this issue. Please let me know when it's completed.

18758847 over 6 years ago

Go ahead and fine tune these ways (way/245017827, way/245017847)