Ich glaube, dass die große Rel relation/2075151 falsch ist, da die noch nicht einmal einen amtlichen Gemeindeschlüssel hat.
Werde das heute Abend zurücksetzen und dabei auf eventuelle Lücken achten.

Gruss
walter

Hi Michael, das ist über ein Jahr her.
Ich meine - auch wegen des CS-Kommentares - dass ich nur die AL8 gesetzt aber die Überlappung nicht bemerkt habe.

watt nu?

Gruss
walter

Hi, can you tell us WHY you removed the admin tags? i think, OSM is loosing a lot of good information.
btw: we in germany are happy about any AL9 (suburb of a town), because that is very helpfull i.g. for using nominatim.

walter

no, hi did not re-add Kecamatan Tawaeli.

fixed by me: changeset/63211088

walter/germany

done
changeset/63070212

Hi Pier,

usually i'm able to revert totally deleted relation by josm, but this time it did not work because of an internal josm error.

ok, i'll delete "my" boundaries to get a clean area.

walter

Hi Pier,

some day ago you wrote me that i did not fix senegal - but i did! ok, by adding new boundaries, because i was not able to recover

now you are adding this boundaries a second time. therefore a lot of boundaries are duplicated.

that ain't good.

walter

hi, any reason why you removed the admin data?

and if you think that is ok, you should remove the admin tags from the boundary way too.

regard
walter

why did you delete the admin boundary of Al Jawf Region?

never ever delete objects, you don't know about.

will be reverted right now.

walter/germany

No idea, andy.

i usually don't change WAY attributes exept admin_level & sometimes boundary=administrative.

But I know "snapp" from the IRAN, because snapp is currently causing big problems there. if you need more infos pls. contact me via mail.

walter

Hi Mory,

thanks for working on onśm.
but yesterday you DELETED the boundaries of Senegal, Saint Louis and some more areas. That is nooo good.

please never ever delete relations, especially no boundary releations.

tryind to fix that, burt it's a lot of work.

Please be more carefully.

Regards
walter/germany

see: https://wambachers-osm.website/index.php/10-osm-reports/1351-countries-compare-2018-09-13

Wenn ich den Eingang der Firma kenne und dieser nur von denen verwendet wird, klebe ich die Tags schon mal an den Eingang mit entrance=main. Gibt es in den Haus noch einen weiteren Eingang für Bewohner, bekommt dieser entrance=main und der Firmeneingang entrance=yes. Sobald dort mehrere Firmen sind, mache ich freischwebende POI. Oder wenn ich die Eingänge nicht kenne.

you removed boundary=administrative and type=boundary from this relation. and that was wrong.

walter

Hi "Sam",

never ever remove boundary tags from existing boundaries. You have "killed" a whole country.

wambacher

Ich möchte dich bitten, diesen Vandalismus zu unterlassen.

reverted.

Und nein, ich gehöre diesem Verein nicht an.

hi, war mir neu (wiki ist nichi so meine Sache). Dachte immer, das gibt es nur für richtig große Gebiete.

ok, ich kann meine kleine Auswertung entsprechend anpassen.

walluf = municipality? Ist das dein Ernst?

Gruss
walter

Hi, kibira

"z" is NOT the changeset commentar we are expecting. Please add comments which describe what you have done.

if not, you may get blocked by the Data Working Group.

Hi,
don't yet know what was going on (3 month ago) but you are right: usually i never delete boundaries but try to fix them.

may be i find the reason.

regards
walter, Germany

Great.

may be you don't know this document (i didn't)

https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/w/images/d/d8/DisputedTerritoriesInformation.pdf

it's from 2013 therefore i asked osmfoundation - it is still ok.

Regards

Walter