OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
140384576 over 2 years ago

Hi Nathaniel
Probably not removed but the tagging should be correct.

I am not sure of the tagging however you will get advice from the mailing list.

Cheers Phil

140384576 over 2 years ago

Hello, welcome to OSM and thank you for your edits however I am concerned that the tagging of these paths may cause problems for some map users.

The name Craig Pennant Scramble implies that a walker may need to use their hands, which is not the general understanding of a path.

The wiki page at highway=path?uselang=en suggests additional tags you can add, such as sac_scale to make the nature of the route clearer.

OSM has had concerns raised in the path where walkers following their smartphone app get into difficulties because it is not the walk along a clearly defined path they were expecting.

You may want to discuss this type of edit with the UK community who are very knowledgable, https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Cheers Phil

140310173 over 2 years ago

Thank you however you shouldn't be looking at Google maps when mapping in OSM, it is against their terms of use.

We do not normally map short term closures such as this because many data consumers only take OSM data very rarely and the closure can persist on maps long after it has been reopened. It is also likely to be missed in OSM and be spotted years later.

Cheers Phil

140317282 over 2 years ago

Exactly, from looking at the sabre wiki which says that the A6 was routed this way in 2014, not that the road opened in 2014.

These edits need to be reverted.

140327004 over 2 years ago

Sabre roads isn't an acceptable source for OSM.

It doesn't make clear what license it is released under and contains no information as to where the information was obtained from.

140317282 over 2 years ago

Again what is the source of these dates?

Whilst Jubilee Way could well have opened in 2014, Barrow Street has existed forever.

To what ends are you making these edits?

Cheers Phil

140310173 over 2 years ago

Hi, this looks a little odd. What legal signage is there here?

It looks like it is intended to access properties.

Cheers Phil

140298176 over 2 years ago

Hi, what is the source of all of the opening dates you are adding. They are all over the country which suggests something other than local knowledge?

Also are you sure Crusader Island opened 8 years after it was mapped?

Cheers Phil

140268641 over 2 years ago

Hi Chris
Please keep your changes to sensible areas, this has created a massive change boundary making it difficult for local mappers to see your changes.

This changeset should have been split between the changes in Staffordshire and those made in Powis. Please save before moving to another area.

Cheers Phil

118317384 over 2 years ago

way/1039032029#map=18/52.71145/-2.51578 is the link I am questioning. Am 100% sure there is no link to the primary.

118317384 over 2 years ago

What was the driver driving?

Cheers Phil

139705263 over 2 years ago

Is there any valid reason that Kingwood School should have name:be/ru/uk beyond Kings Wood can be translated into any number of languages. I could translate it into name:fr and name:cy but that doesn't mean I should as there is no actual usage.

I have seen silly English names added in OSM which no native English speaker ever uses, Triumphal Arch and Under the Linden's for example.

101321883 over 2 years ago

Wrong bridge, read the description.

Cheers Phil

140057949 over 2 years ago

Are sure about this?

This is a modern footbridge, built when the A55 was built. The historic bridge was demolished in 2000.

The references to CADW on the wikipedia page do not exist suggest the wikidata page is outdated/fictional.

A listed structure crossing a modern expressway really should have had alarmbells ringing and been checked more thoughtfully.

Cheers Phil

140123136 over 2 years ago

Please don't do that. The park certainly doesn't end at the centreline of the path.
It either stops where it did, or should have been extended to end the other side of that path.

Glueing landuse to the centreline of highways just makes editing more difficult for other mappers.

Cheers Phil

138677492 over 2 years ago

Personal note, reverted

138679828 over 2 years ago

Reverted

140049267 over 2 years ago

Museum already tagged with fee=yes. Name should be an acual name, not a price. We do not tag these in OSM.

Reverted

140010498 over 2 years ago

Please don't make edits such as this. The Bishops Palace is already tagged with fee=yes and I am sure there is no ticket office here called 5 pounds.

139799982 over 2 years ago

Why is St Georges Tower way/89674881 included?

Cheers Phil