Hi. Can you please give your reasoning for tagging Seaford Foreshore Walking Track (41938008) bicycle=yes, its relevant to later changeset discussion.

Hi. Thanks for your reply here and your other replies tonight. Tony

Hi. I presume your tagging is based on the absence of any signage concerning bikes? Thanks.

Hi. I presume your tagging is based on the absence of any signage concerning bikes? Thanks.

Hi. The name "Seaford Foreshore Walking Track" clearly indicates the primary function but I couldn't find any signage or publication that actually prohibits bicycles. Do you know of any?

Hi. I assume your reason for changing 1007542000, v2 and
1007541999, v2 from cycleway to footway is because there is no signage about bicycles? Thanks.

Hi, please excuse this question from Australia, and sorry if I am not familiar with US tagging. Are you Mike Landis in Wandrer.earth? Your tagging though sufficient for Wandrer.earth might be improved for OSM. bicycle=no is used for transport mode specific things (at least in Australia), I am guessing that Charles Street (11592169, v4) might be better tagged with access=no or access=private because access restrictions are not limited to bicycles.
Thanks, Tony, Melbourne Australia

Hi Sebastian. I understand that you have already given your reasoning for similar changes. I have picked this one out for two reasons. Firstly because it has the feel of a cycleway or shared path in the absence of any signage that I can see, it runs between factories and a creek. Secondly the history of way/860898496. philam48 1 year ago tagged it as a cycleway. You changed it to a footway, then a cycleway then a footway. On October 4 2021, the DWG ruled that it would "proceed to roll back your changes because it's evident it goes against the community wishes here and the bulk changes have brought in these errors". I, acting for the DWG reverted it back to philam48's original cycleway refering back to the DWG decision https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-au/2021-October/015093.html
Please stop undoing the reversions of your work. Please comply with community tagging standards. Thanks, Tony

thats good but you didnt remove the bicycle=no

Hi
This is not my understanding, your edits were referred to the DWG and they made a ruling that did not support your position.

Hi, I looked at one, Way: 179900928, good call to make it private but can you please remove unnecessary bicycle=no, on all these. Hanson may or may not allow their employees to ride bicycles

Hi, the absence of signage indicating that bicycles are allowed is insufficient reason to to change it to a footway. What evidence do you have that its primary purpose is pedestrian?

Hi
what is your source of information that this is private?

Hi Guy, welcome to OSM. Through no fault of your own you have landed in a very controversial place. Please join in the talk-au discussion at https://lists.openstreetmap.org
Its a difficult discussion but I think worth the effort for both Parks services and OSM.

Ahoj. Můžete prosím poskytnout více informací o vašich changesets
Hi. Can you please provide more information on your changesets "line,arc,areas" doesn't tell us much. osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Thanks, Tony

Hi thank you for your contributions to Open Street Map. Can you please contact us or if you are editing under someone else's supervision, for example a school teacher, can you please ask them to contact us here or by email to https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au thanks

Hi thank you for your contributions to Open Street Map. Can you please contact us or if you are editing under someone else's supervision, for example a school teacher, can you please ask them to contact us here or by email to https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au thanks

Hi thank you for your contributions to Open Street Map. Can you please contact us or if you are editing under someone else's supervision, for example a school teacher, can you please ask them to contact us here or by email to https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au thanks

Hi, thank you for your contributions to Open Street Map. Can you please contact us or if you are editing under someone else's supervision, for example a school teacher, can you please ask them to contact us here or by email to https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au thanks

Only a few hours too soon, opens 11am Sunday 21 November according to the government web site