OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
44350832 about 9 years ago

OK. Fue lo que pusiste...

Decime en criollo que días y horario abre así lo agrego.

44350523 about 9 years ago

No. No son cuatro amenity=school ni estan ubicadas como las mapeaste.

Mira como quedo ahora, con los cambios changeset/44397114 y changeset/44397034

Los tres elementos con su respectivo limite, edificios y entrada. Eso es lo que hay que hacer. Mapear datos reales que puedan tener para multiples aplicaciones.

44350832 about 9 years ago

Mario, ¿es solo consultorio odontologico, no?

¿Abris sabados y domingos de 10 a 19?

44294465 about 9 years ago

If you follow the principle of "One feature One element", you should map the three schools, not one polygon. Each school are independent entities, with different attributes. As you now draw it, there are 4 amenity=schools there which is not true.

For example, If i want a school list, (extract from OSM date a list of name, address and phone) for example, the "4th school" is an artifact with no correspondent in the real world.

Why is better to have an artifact so an app can warn somebody (or take any other , than to have the real data?

If you need data that support that kind of tools, you sholud be able to collaborate data that doesn't break other uses of the same data.

Also, for example, in a school (or in other buildings or places), it's also important (or more important) to guide you to the entrance (almost always a point), not to any point of the polygon near to a street, it has to be the entrance.

44094229 about 9 years ago

Yes, fixing changes that you and others made that broke multipolygons.

way/70521186 has no name.

44294465 about 9 years ago

It's not a matter of "feeling" or "not feeling".

The node, locating the node inside the feature, allows mapping a feature when you dont have much information about it, like it's this case. A polygon is for when you know without doubt what is inside and outside ot this polygon.

Did yoy consider professional a method if it introduces bad data where good data exists previously? If you can't improve existing data, just dont broke it.

Please explain why you find my methods unprofessional.

43883626 about 9 years ago

Not automated, because some "ine" streets are names adopted by the neighbours. To add or remove a "ine" name a detailed survey is needed (probably talking with people living there), or if KG actually surveyed street signs with that name that's ok.

44288278 about 9 years ago

Cambio revertido. La escuela no es todo lo que se dibujo. Corresponde nodo y no via si no esta de forma precisa.

44294465 about 9 years ago

Lo unico bueno que marquen el source con KG 2016 es para buscar las cosas que dejan mal...

44294465 about 9 years ago

Esto way/458735146 NO es como lo dibujaste.

Lo que ya esta para cambiarlo tenes que tener la seguridad de hacerlo bien, no basta con la intencion, hay que estar 100% seguro y chequear muy bien las fuentes para no romper nada como hicistre con esta escuela.
¿De donde sacaste que es toda ese poligono y no lo que estaba?
¿No pensaste que si estaba mapeada de otra forma por algo seria?

44294465 about 9 years ago

"source" es atributo del changeset.
¿Que sentido tiene repetirlo en cada elemento?
No aporta nada y solo incrementa el espacio usado por los datos.

44288124 about 9 years ago

Anzani y Caracas no estan conectadas. Hay un pequeño kerb en el medio de Rivera.

Si queres unir Rivera y dejar una sola via (que es discutible), tenes que agregar las respectivas restricciones que los vehiculos tienen que respetar.

29864557 about 9 years ago

Gracias Pablo por la confirmacion. Quedaron corregidas.

44193133 about 9 years ago

No, I hadn't check all changesets.
I just raise a warning flag to try to improve the changes based on this KG 2016 survey.

41518865 about 9 years ago

No estuve. :-( Reverti un cambio por malas geometrias que hacia pelota varias calles de la zona, pero creo que no es ese que mencionas. sino
changeset/41512686 (obviamente no me acuerdo pero es lo que parece por la historia http://osmhv.openstreetmap.de/changeset.jsp?id=41512686 )

Lo que no entiendo es porque ese detalle de la calle que mencionas quedo mal.

44121449 about 9 years ago

"Anglo" brand (if used with the lion icon) refers to a english teaching services, http://www.anglo.edu.uy/
and the list of sites here http://www.anglo.edu.uy/instituto-centros/anglo-centros-por-departamento/montevideo

The building you map as "Anglo" has a shop and a travel agency in the street level, and the "Anglo" is upstairs
So it should be mapped only as a building, and three nodes, one for "Anglo", one for the shop and another for the travel agency.

44129385 about 9 years ago

The image is right. The building is there and it's not closed, it is in working condition and it is operated by "Banco Republica" (i think for their internal use like archiving documents), but no financial services are offered there. They offer services in sites listed here https://www.portal.brou.com.uy/web/guest/institucional/red-fisica/montevideo

44121449 about 9 years ago

"Santeria" is probably "shop=religion"

44125512 about 9 years ago

"Stadium" (in the context of shops) is shop=shoes

44125512 about 9 years ago

"Cash" and "Pronto!" are shop=money_lender
There are others but dont remember now.