mueschel's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 86602559 | over 4 years ago | hi,
|
| 110436738 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110438393 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110480827 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110551002 | over 4 years ago | Please check your edits, there are many tags with spelling mistakes. |
| 110495368 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
document number
|
| 110552764 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
In the process you also deleted many already existing trees with more valid tags than the new ones. Where can we find the mandatory discussion and documentation of this import? |
| 110570361 | over 4 years ago | Something went very wrong here. There are hundreds of objects with only foreign tags like this way:
Before importing any foreign data, please make sure to follow the OSM import guidelines!
|
| 110174305 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110361556 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110400278 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110235721 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110268132 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
feature_type=man_made
|
| 109763885 | over 4 years ago | Ist das "zuständig" im Sinne von "nach dem Rechten schauen"? Das könnte dann in das häufige "operator" oder in das eher seltene und bisher nicht dokumentierte "maintainer". |
| 109974961 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 109951208 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110266954 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110009130 | over 4 years ago | Hi,
|
| 110141850 | over 4 years ago | Sure, there should be a documentation in the Wiki for each tag. But, a generic scheme helps:
If I see your tag, I have no idea what it might be. I see '911' and 'address' - so is it some kind of emergency contact? So the value might be a phone number? Oh, it says 'id' at the very end, so it might be some reference number. You also have to take into account that these tags will be seen by everybody using OSM. Say, someone creating a map of power infrastructure needs to decide which information to include and which to drop. They might decide to take every 'ref:...' tag and show this in a separate section but they would need a dedicated look-up table whether to include your custom tag or not. Please, use a 'ref' prefix for any reference number. It makes the life of every data consumer so much easier. |
| 110141850 | over 4 years ago | Yeah, we're missing some handy documentation on how to create new tags. The scheme I propose would be inline with e.g. ref:linz:building_id
There's also the approach to add a country code into the tag, to be able to disentangle local ref numbers from each other in case somewhere else a similar abbreviation is used, like in ref:GB:uprn.
I think it's very helpful to have all kind of reference numbers in one common namespace, prefixed with 'ref:' and a region code.
|