OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
43803363 about 9 years ago

railway=tram_stop is probably a bad idea for the stop positions, causes rendering mess. Maybe better just to use railway=stop

43799241 about 9 years ago

Is this section of the road bus/taxi only?

43788826 about 9 years ago

route=railway might be better for this because it doesn't map an operating service but a railway (group of tracks related to each other).

43740992 about 9 years ago

I'm not sure where you got the data from, but Chinese Wikipedia says the runway is actually 1905 metres long and 37 metres wide.

43740853 about 9 years ago

The road classifications were fine before and you should change them consistently if you really think that they're wrong for some reason. It's not particularly helpful to add "horse=no" on a highway, because that's assumed normally.

43757720 about 9 years ago

Also, the curve in Castle Peak Road does not exist there (Bing/Mapbox satellite imagery).

43757720 about 9 years ago

– Variable speed limits are tagged according to maxspeed=*. Hyphen, unfortunately, isn't allowed because it's not very useful when read by an app
– These roads had the right classification before
– The surface tag isn't really meant for beaches; it's usually for roads.

43741136 about 9 years ago

Why did you retag this as a tram line? "Light rail" is literally right there in the name.

43753802 about 9 years ago

Hi Xavier, removed some of the tags for now because I don't think they should be displayed as stations until the line is actually open.

43552256 about 9 years ago

What the hell are you doing? This is a publicly-viewable map updated in real time, not your own personal play area where you can mess with stuff as you please.

43438401 about 9 years ago

I'll be reverting you again, not because I don't care of your opinion about this but because it's inconsistent to only modify the names of some of the stations.

43438401 about 9 years ago

See https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/52852/railway-stationmetro-station-naming

43438401 about 9 years ago

Not entirely relevant; as an example, this way/194259723 has station signage "OXFORD CIRCUS STATION", but is still marked on the Tube map and in OSM as "Oxford Circus".

43438401 about 9 years ago

Usually railway stations don't contain "station" in their name; this information is already in the "railway=station" tag (see tagging example of railway=station).

42655407 about 9 years ago

I also just picked this changeset to comment on because it was the most recent one when I noticed that he'd made a lot of changesets.

42655407 about 9 years ago

@SomeoneElse I've messaged HelioFelix informing him of the help.osm.org thread, but he hasn't replied yet. Looking at the Cycle layer, 9.8m seems plausible given that Fanling new town is situated in a largely-flat valley.

42635683 about 9 years ago

I've asked the wider community for clarification: https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/52388/lots-of-peaks-close-together

42635683 about 9 years ago

Yeah, it does look a bit weird… they are all technically peaks, though. I guess you could prevent them from rendering by just deleting natural=peak (without removing the data)?

42635683 about 9 years ago

I will be reverting the 15 of your changesets, where you (for some reason I don't know) removed elevation data from peaks and troughs, at some point

42655407 about 9 years ago

Where did you get the idea that this was an invalid tag?