jc86035's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 36909596 | almost 10 years ago | Please stop retagging trunk roads as highway=motorway. If a road doesn't have the green highway signs then it should be tagged as highway=trunk (or highway=trunk_link for ramps/slip roads and Penny's Bay Highway), and if it doesn't have a route number then it should be tagged as highway=primary (except Sha Lek Road and Penny's Bay Highway). |
| 36893223 | almost 10 years ago | Why did you delete these? |
| 36883268 | almost 10 years ago | The Airport Express is separate from the rest of the MTR system in fare system and high speed, and is therefore tagged as a main line (railway=rail). The Tung Chung Line tracks, on the other hand, are tagged as a metro line (railway=subway). |
| 36882537 | almost 10 years ago | Only the parts which are marked by signage as tunnel areas should be tagged as highway=motorway. |
| 36875877 | almost 10 years ago | This road is not even part of the route system (i.e. routes 1–5 and 7–10) and should not be tagged as a motorway. |
| 36875408 | almost 10 years ago | Like Prince Edward Road East, even if a road is constructed similarly to a highway, it should not be tagged as "highway=motorway" unless it is part of the route system and has green signage (except for Sha Lek Road). |
| 36875572 | almost 10 years ago | Like Prince Edward Road East, even if a road is constructed similarly to a highway, it should not be tagged as "highway=motorway" unless it is part of the route system and has green signage (except for Sha Lek Road). |
| 36839404 | almost 10 years ago | Like Prince Edward Road East, even if a road is constructed similarly to a highway, it should not be tagged as "highway=motorway" unless it is part of the route system and has green signage (except for Sha Lek Road). Airport Road is not part of Route 8 and does not have green expressway signage. |
| 36838327 | almost 10 years ago | Like Prince Edward Road East, even if a road is constructed similarly to a highway, it should not be tagged as "highway=motorway" unless it is part of the route system and has green signage (except for Sha Lek Road). Ma On Shan Road is not part of Route 2 and should therefore be tagged as a primary road (highway=primary). |
| 36909448 | almost 10 years ago | The East Rail Line is, like the West Rail Line, a metro line (railway=subway). The Intercity services, on the other hand, are main line trains (railway=rail). Since the spur line is not served by main line trains it is tagged as railway=subway. |
| 36882104 | almost 10 years ago | Ching Cheung Road, while part of Route 7, is not classified as an expressway/motorway (highway=motorway) and should be tagged as a trunk road (highway=trunk), like Princess Margaret Road. |
| 30739051 | over 10 years ago | osm.wiki/HK:Hong_Kong_tagging#.E8.A1.97.E9.81.93.E5.88.86.E9.A1.9E_Classifications_of_streets |
| 30739051 | over 10 years ago | (Tunnels and tunnel areas are also tagged as highway=motorway.) |
| 30739051 | over 10 years ago | There is a difference. Tag roads with highway=motorway and highway=motorway_link only where the highway signs are green.
|
| 30739051 | over 10 years ago | Stop it. 停止。
|
| 30566953 | over 10 years ago | Your changes to this map can be seen by everyone. Don't add things that definitely don't exist. |
| 29800260 | over 10 years ago | The previous tagging was correct. In future can you please only do large-scale tag changes like these with community consensus? Thank you |
| 28009009 | almost 11 years ago | I notice you tagged the Airport Express tracks as service=siding... They're actually the fast line tracks. Will fix now |
| 27817594 | almost 11 years ago | Aren't government maps copyrighted? |
| 27817594 | almost 11 years ago | The Sheung Wan part of Des Voeux Road Central needs to be fixed up (preferably with a graphical editor) since the placement is quite off. |