Hi ke9tv,

relation/174474

after this edit this boundary has now a double place value "hamlet;CDP". Could you check it out?

To be honest I don't think the boundary should be mapped as place=* at all since this tag is already mapped on the label node: osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element

so I would leave the node element for the place feature and the relation element for the boundary feature.

Also now both boundary and node are tagged as "hamlet" but the wiki says it's a census-designate place, which is a value used already 139 times in the OSM database: https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/place=census-designated
Maybe it should be a better value?

I leave the considerations to you since you seem to have local knowledge (which I don't have).

Happy mapping!

Hi rimugu,

node/9780253336

I changed this place value to "hamlet", if it's not the correct fix feel free to edit it again, good mapping!

Hi bbgg,

"fixme=There is only one route and is always north of the Po river"

sorry, I don't understand what is to be fixed here.

Hi Chuppyy,

welcome to OSM. I don't know georgian, so I need you to help me. You are writing "Name of this building" but then you are not adding a name=* tag but editing the already existing "addr:housenumber", which should contain the number of the house. Here the housenumber was 5 and you changed it with "5კვარტალი 5 კორპუსი", what does it mean?

Ciao Gianfranco,

scusate se mi intrometto. Se la fonte è la Regione Veneto andrebbe messa quella nella source, e non "knowledge". Inoltre sei sicuro la licenza sia compatibile? Puoi fornire un link puntuale dei dati originali utilizzati?

Hi Utiashvili,

here you added several highway that cross water=river areas or waterway=river ways, eg: way/974477542/history

How does it work? Are they fords?

The only safety island I see from aerial imagery is here: way/901254253/history
not on the secondary highway.

Mapping this way seems like the waste disposal is right in the middle of the road. If there's a safety island the road should be splitted in that point. Anyway I doubt someone would put a waste disposal in the island in the middle of the road instead of at one border of it, but if you say so.

Here for example I doubt there's a safety island with a waste disposal in it, in such a narrow street: node/4212843059/history

Hi Beqa080,

again, please be careful, you dragged a node here: node/9782504126/history
iD even tried to warn you (warnings:crossing_ways:highway-highway) but you ignored it.

Also what's the source of the boundary edit?

Hi Zurab055,

what's the source of this edit? Seems like you added the chechen name in the russian name tag?

Hi Valther,

I don't understand why adding the waste disposal node as part of the highway. Is there a reason?

https://wiki.openstreetmap.orgdata flags rivers as missing wikidata, this is not true, the wikidata is already tagged in the waterway relation, I can't see the point in duplicate it in ONE of it's members.

Also what you are doing seems like an automated edit, I doubt you cheked every item individually also because you would need local knowlege, see: osm.wiki/Automated_edits

I also noticed that this wrong name is also used in Google Maps, could it be that you are copying data from Google Maps? Sources should be verified (in this case "ჯოყოლოს კვირაცხოვლის ეკლესია" is the ruin of a church that is now correctly mapped after asking the locals and going for a survey), but even so Google data cannot be used in any case.

Since no reply was given, I restored the previous version.

A hint tho:

the addr:street value should match the street name value.

The name:en is "Tina Iosebidze Street", the "addr:street:en" that you added is "Tina Iosebidze street", should be with the capital S in street as well to match the street name.

Good mapping :)

Hi Seandebasti,

why did you change a landuse=residential with a generic place=yes?

way/922588289/history

Ciao bertovp,

way/1063289497/history

questo landuse=farmland che hai creato si sovrappone a un landuse farmland già esistente, inoltre comprende un edificio, magari volevi usare landuse=farmyard?

This is not a building, please be careful while mapping. You made a lot of incorrect edits in Pankisi (I didn't checked elsewhere...). You can use landuse=religious in these cases.

I see that the building:part are already being drawn, you could add the name to them, it's not gonna ruin the 3d rendering

You could move the already exhisting node instead of deleting it and re-creating it. Also you recreated adding solely the name tag, all this previously added data got lost:
ele=580
name:en=Kutsakhta
name:os=Къуцъахта
name:ru=Куцахта
place=village
population=103
wikidata=Q3650096
wikipedia=ka:კუწახტა

I fixed it, but please be careful while editing, I'm seeing many errors and many loss of information

Why did you delete "Saint George Church"? Is called this way by Nazy Dakishvili, the president of the "Pankisi Valley Tourism and Development Association".

Isn't it this one? https://nazysguesthouse.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/St-George-Church-in-Jokolo.jpg