Making the best use of our mapping time
Posted by itsamap! on 1 May 2019 in English. Last updated on 2 May 2019.In this blog I will talk about what data we are using, how we are processing the data, then importing it into OSM. Some things are not considered imports at all since they’re more of a stare and compare, but I will cover them as well since we are using data others collected and have made available to us for use in OSM. Even analyzing data that is already in OSM to improve data quality. All that and more! :-)
First off, I understand many people do not like using others’ data for OSM for a couple of different reasons.
-
The data could be low quality. I once talked to a mapper when I saw that they removed an imported move theater from the middle of a corn field, due to someone blind importing. …Ouch!
-
Imports require a lot of technical knowledge of OSM and that excludes a lot of mappers.
-
Making sure the data is not copyrighted in a way that prevents it from being used in OSM. (I’ll touch on that in another post) There might be more, but these are the ones that I have heard so far.
In this blog I hope to address these concerns by demonstrating how we can set things up in a community-oriented way that streamlines the process and also keeps quality high. We have so many tools to at our disposal that I keep stumbling across them and finding new ways to use them for different projects! I hope to gain working knowledge and demonstrate how they can all work.
Also, I will be talking about how I got access to data for our local area and tips on how you might be able to do the same. That can be half the battle!
So far using data from other sources has enabled our small local community to begin to get the map to the point in our area where it is becoming a more preferable map to more and more people, which we have seen is starting to drive interest from prospective new mappers. As I have seen there are a lot more people who are willing to add to a map that already basically meets their needs than are willing to get the map to the point where it would be useful to them. I have even seen this among people who understand the value of open source and want a map that they can use without being tracked, but just don’t have the time or inclination to become mappers themselves. If I cannot get these kinds of people on board that makes me nervous!
So, all that being said, I think getting and working with data is the answer. I do not think we will, or should ever stop in-person mapping or armchair mapping. But in a place where there is a small mapping community getting organized and using, not repeating work that has already been done by others will make OSM the best it can be.
Also by aggregating data from more and more places we will ensure OSM is the standard for Geo-Spatial data. I would like to see companies and governments in our area be invested into OSM as a platform.
I am in upstate South Carolina, USA so everything I do will be with our area, and I doubt that will change as I understand that other places do things differently and I really am only an expert on where I live. But I hope you can use, adapt, improve and get inspired on how to improve the map in your area.
Because hey that’s what open source is all about: sharing ideas.
Discussion
Comment from Hjart on 1 May 2019 at 21:06
The most important reason why we “don’t like using other’s data for OSM” is, it could be copyrighted! We are basically a giant international hobbyproject, which apart from, some donations now and then, doesn’t make any money. This is one reason why we want to (legally) stay “whiter than white”. We just don’t want to risk anyone sending their lawyers after us.
Also before you even consider an import, make sure you read and understand osm.wiki/Import
Comment from itsamap! on 2 May 2019 at 03:25
That is true I did not touch on vetting the data for legal ability to use it in OSM. That is part of it I will edit to post to include that. We have vetted that data that we are using and have written permission.
And I know you need to follow instructions on the Wiki for any import project. But the purpose of the post is not to restate what documented procedure there is. But to share my options on why I think its a good idea, that more people should be doing. Documenting our progress. So that other people can learn from our success or if we fail they can learn what not to do in that way. It is a trend that more government agency’s are opening there data. most of our local county’s now have a open data policy now. I want to take advantage to build a map and minimize duplicating work.
But I do disagree with you on “ basically a giant international hobbyproject”. OSM is a big part of organizations like Lyft, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon logistics, Facebook. And who knows how many small company’s. I see OSM data all over the place! I talk to people who are employed to work with OSM data almost everyday. It is also a hobby project for a lot of people. But OSM was started to solve a problem for Steve Cost, and I work on it today so we can have a map to use that is more privacy-centric and free. I can point to a lot of different articles on how OSM is solving real problems everyday.