gurglypipe's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 163608671 | 9 months ago | If there’s a speed limit on these newly constructed residential roads, does that mean construction is now complete? |
| 163742302 | 9 months ago | Super, let me know if you have any questions. One other thing which comes to mind if you’re going to be adding significant amounts of geometry (like this) is that you probably want to enable the OSMUK Cadastral Parcels overlay (in the Background Settings on the right) and ensure the aerial imagery is aligned to it before starting to add stuff, using the Imagery Offset settings further down that panel. It looks like the alignment offset for Bing imagery here is 0,0, which is handy. But in other areas of the northwest it can be out by 1-2m. The offset of the aerial imagery changes every few years it’s updated, and it varies between different areas (even between neighbouring villages). The OSMUK Cadastral Parcels come from the Land Registry and are a source of ground truth for alignment (and also help with property boundaries where aerial imagery is unclear). Hope that makes sense :) |
| 163742302 | 9 months ago | Heya, thanks for adding detail to the farmland here. From the aerial imagery, it looks like a lot of this is unimproved grazing land (and I’d expect that of the area) — if so, it could be more specifically tagged as landuse=meadow meadow=pasture. See osm.wiki/User:Gurglypipe/landuse for the current consensus on farmland tagging in NW England. Hope that helps, happy to answer questions about if it it’s not clear, or if you have improvements to recommend. |
| 163700799 | 9 months ago | @Harveeymaps I’d just like to say thanks for taking the time to update the map for things which you helped build, it’s fantastic to have this kind of local knowledge put on the map straight from the source :) |
| 163692683 | 9 months ago | Hiya, thanks for your edits around the northern Lakes recently! When editing footpaths/bridleways, please be careful to retain the existing access, designation and prow_ref tagging, which someone else has taken the time to add. This tagging is what records whether a footpath/bridleway is actually a legal right of way, and is used by route finding apps. See osm.wiki/Access_provisions_in_the_United_Kingdom#Public_bridleways I’ve re-added the missing tagging here in changeset/163723157 Happy editing :) |
| 163616816 | 10 months ago | Hiya, thanks for your edits to improve bike hire round the Lakes :) Do you know exactly which building Marra are in now they’re in Nether Wasdale? It would be useful to position the node for them on the right building so people can go to the right place. Either edit the map to tweak its location, or let me know which building’s right, if you know. Thanks! |
| 163572295 | 10 months ago | This changeset includes modifications to the cooling towers of Didcot power station, in addition to all the edits on the Isle of Man. The changes in Didcot would have been better as a separate changeset so this one doesn’t span half of England — see osm.wiki/Changeset#Geographical_size_of_changesets Thanks! :) |
| 163298621 | 10 months ago | I see from changeset/163444093 that you’ve now removed this NatWest (and kept the one on Market Square). Thanks for fixing that — I assume it’s based on a survey or local knowledge? You can list the sources for your edits in the entry just below the changeset comment, when saving an edit. It helps other mappers know where data has come from and how up to date it is, which helps inform future edits. You can also reply to changeset discussions (like this one) to answer questions or expand on your changeset comments. Thanks again :) |
| 163343895 | 10 months ago | Did you survey this? |
| 163298621 | 10 months ago | Heya, thanks for all your edits recently. I’ve tidied this up a bit in changeset/163304089, since there were some duplicate bank nodes and ATMs here on King Street. However, there’s also a NatWest on Market Square (way/427303001), and that’s the only NatWest branch listed on their website (https://www.natwest.com/search-results/locator/branch.html?sortcode=601621&name=Penrith). Are there really two branches of NatWest in the centre of Penrith at the moment? Or have they recently moved? Or something else? I’ve not been in the centre of Penrith for a few months, so can’t remember myself. Thanks :) |
| 163213279 | 10 months ago | I don’t think you did. The speed limit and access around South Lodge and The Greaves were wrong. I surveyed them today and made changeset/163253770 Armchair mapping is fine for adding certain details on the map, but speed limits are not one of them. Please provide sources for your edits and stop armchair adding speed limits. |
| 163213279 | 10 months ago | Have you surveyed this? |
| 163012850 | 10 months ago | Hi, I’ve reverted this change (as changeset/163033751) because your ‘fix’ looks incorrect. The map previously had a bypass gate next to a cattle grid, which is a common rural road layout in this area. The gate allows horse-drawn traffic to bypass the cattle grid. I’m not sure what maproulette issue you were trying to fix (it’s not mentioned in the changeset comment) but I don’t think this was the right fix. Have you surveyed this area in person? |
| 162871267 | 10 months ago | Yeah, agreed, I think it's been moved from the skate park a while back |
| 162877236 | 10 months ago | Thanks for double-checking :) |
| 162547596 | 10 months ago | I’ve gone with area:highway=forecourt in changeset/162887146, which I made up from scratch. I couldn’t find any examples of other people specifically tagging these areas, which is a bit odd. The best I found are various versions of service=forecourt, but those are only used on petrol station forecourt ways (https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1ZiF). |
| 162877236 | 10 months ago | Hiya, thanks for trying to improve the one-way system in Lancaster, but I think motor_vehicle=permit is the most appropriate tagging, according to the wiki (access=*#List_of_possible_values). motor_vehicle=no means access by motor vehicles is physically impossible (e.g. due to the road being too narrow) or completely illegal (e.g. no entry signs). motor_vehicle=destination means that any vehicle is allowed as long as it’s going to a destination on that road. Typically this is signed in the UK as “except for access”. The signage here says “authorised vehicles only”, which implies motor_vehicle=permit to me. |
| 162716882 | 10 months ago | If you remove all the tags from the area (so it turns into a way) before splitting it, ID will allow you to split it without it turning into a multipolygon. You can then extend the newly split lines to close them, and re-add the tags to each new house. Still a bit fiddly to do, but might be easier than learning JOSM. :) |
| 162716902 | 10 months ago | Pete has changed those roads to something more plausible (20mph) in changeset/162719195, but again without providing any information about the source of the data (or giving the courtesy of replying to me here). |
| 162716882 | 10 months ago | I took the liberty of converting the multi-polygon terrace to normal ways in changeset/162719039, because multi-polygons are a nightmare to maintain in the long term. They’re easy to break and don’t work well with a lot of tools. Hope that’s OK. :) |