Hallo RuckRunnerGRT,

Thanks for your contributions to OSM. I noticed your name when I was recovering damage caused by the Humanoid's earlier manifestation.

Is this user personally known to you? I am going to assume yes, in which case I will purposely turn a blind eye to the normally-taboo tone of your comment, as in general we like to treat co-mappers and cow-orkers with respect, regardless of whether it is earned or not.

When they turn to the dark side and deliberately damage the map, then I see no need to adhere strictly to these not-yet-set-in-stone guidelines, although so far this particular user seems to be behaving, locally, so overall it is a Win all around.

Carry on.

no worries, my revert can be reverted to make things broken again.

i lumped this together with a few other reverts where the user had thrown in the towel and asked for a revert as they were in over their head with relation issues.

that was my intent here, given that relations are not a simple concept to grok, to return this, like the others, to a clean slate and give the user a second chance, unburdened by whatever might have happened here.

your description of what went wrong does not read so much as a simple mistake, but more of a horror story of something somehow went t*tsup that should not have happened in the first place to a newbie.

of late, i have been attempting to repair broken relations, partly caused by bugs in the iD editor, and secondly where i have had to use iD and in half a dozen aborted edits, i have seen it automatically forces an edit upon me where i did not make one, do not want one, and ultimately it is *wrong* and luckily i noticed the number-of-edits counter increased when it should not have.

it is with this background that i assume any severe relation damage from an iD edit may well be an unreported bug, of which the user is unaware, or may be presented to the user without a `here be dragons' notice, after which the user may say, i don't know what i did but i didn't want to do that...

anyway, the user has a clean slate now and you are welcome to restore it as earlier, in the hope that an explanation as to what went wrong is forthcoming. or not, if it is a bug.

cheers, and sorry for this pointless rambling

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65288696 where the changeset comment is: restore erroneously deleted 3D building part, in an attempt to keep the culprit from learning how to do the same :-) #IgnoranceIsBliss #HashtagDelight

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65288512 where the changeset comment is: revert SEO edit that added a spammy description= field and broke a multipolygon relation

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65276172 where the changeset comment is: Why yes, it can, and with this, it has been. At your request. For Reasons[tm] unknown to me, but looks reasonable. Biddesehr...

Hallo,

this changeset seems to have drained the lake by dropping way/367395988
at the north as one of the outers.

did you intend do do this?

i am trying to identify iD editor bugs in handling relations.

thanks...

Hi,

you might want to try to quadrilateralise the house outlines with the `q' key.

i know that when you have more than about 6 or 8 nodes, the Potlatch version of the function becomes somewhat a hit-or-miss think.

also, i see here you have adjusted the geometry of two existing buildings from user YouRockBeastBoy, but the remaining three you have deleted, losing her/his contributions, to draw them new. in general we prefer the former where possible in order to give credit and preserve the history. unless these are houses you drew in an earlier incarnation.

also, i hope you are using the best possible imagery to trace these, which may be ESRI in some parts of florida.

happy to see some constructive contributions here now.

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65209827 where the changeset comment is: The name is not an acronym, nor are the letters expected to be spoken separately, therefore SHOUTY ALL CAPS is inappropriate for osm. Otherwise, please expand the acronym.

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65207553 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me Whatever, spammed as private residence

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206943 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me alpine hut in the tropics

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206702 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me castle loaded with personal private info which never should be added to OSM

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206555 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me castle

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206377 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me alpine hut in the tropics

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206299 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me castle

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206237 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me Whatever, spammed as private residence

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206169 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me Whatever, spammed as private residence

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206108 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me Whatever, spammed as private residence

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65206038 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me castle

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65205851 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me castle

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset/65205639 where the changeset comment is: delete Yet Another bogus maps.me alpine hut in the tropics