OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

The Long Trek to Fixing Florida

Posted by floridaeditor on 20 June 2020 in English.

Just 6 months ago, Florida was absolutely littered with incorrectly tagged trunk roads (i.e. US and state highways tagged as trunk rather than primary). The rendering of Florida looked like a bloodshot eye, and correctly tagged trunk roads (i.e. Pineda Causeway, US 27 in Everglades) were mixed with incorrect ones. The problem was made even worse by an editor who mainly edited the California area, by tagging correct primary roads as incorrect trunk roads[a].

To standardize the tagging of trunk roads in a general ‘east’ location[b], a general ‘trunk road in the East US guidelines’ was agreed upon:

  • Road must have very few to no at-grade intersections (about 5 per county/parish);
  • Road may or may not be divided (contrary to motorway);
  • Road may be any speed;
  • Road may have any designation;
  • Road may or may not allow foot traffic, cycle traffic, etc.

Following the agreement of these guidelines, I set off to change Florida’s trunk route scheme. First I started with US 192/CR 15 (now tagged as primary/secondary) and just kept going, until finally Florida was clean[c]!

But it wasn’t done.

No, sir, we need a general tagging scheme in place for county, state, and non-designated streets. Putting guidelines in place (mainly following California’s with tweaks), I set off with Brevard and Orange counties in mind to fix. I am currently working on those projects.

Of course, this is not the only thing I do. If I go geocaching, I might add some park features at the park it was in. I might improve waterways[d], other businesses, etc. But my main focus continues to be on CR/SR/non-designated roads.

  • [a] Standards differ between California and Florida.
  • [b] TODO: east of Mississippi or straight down the center?
  • [c] Fixing such a large state wasn’t easy, but it took about 3 months.
  • [d] One of such edits turned out to be controversial, but it was cleared up.
Location: Oak Ridge, Orange County, Florida, 38209, United States
Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Discussion

Comment from Richard on 21 June 2020 at 13:10

we need a general tagging scheme in place for county, state, and non-designated

Please make sure that you make sure that unpaved roads/tracks are clearly distinguishable as such. (In other words, highway=residential/unclassified/etc. should always have a surface tag if they’re not paved.) Florida is currently one of the best states for this and it would be a shame to lose that.

Comment from GinaroZ on 22 June 2020 at 15:25

I’m not really familiar with the US road system but from UK experience I would expect to see a coherent motorway and trunk network.

Just looking at Florida I found a few examples where trunk roads are orphaned from other trunk or motorways, from: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/VlC

way/83775365 way/53738099 way/555069787

There’s also a few leftover trunk_link roads which you can find via http://osmose.openstreetmap.fr/en/map/?#zoom=10&lat=28.343&lon=-81.277&item=1110&level=1%2C2%2C3&tags=&fixable=

Comment from floridaeditor on 23 June 2020 at 12:20

@GinaroZ the trunks are orphaned on purpose, since primarys randomly change, but thanks for the trunk_link update.

Comment from GinaroZ on 23 June 2020 at 16:36

Sorry, not sure I understand - what do you mean “since primarys randomly change”?

The trunk road in my first link has the same tags as the primary road either side of it and also looks the same on Bing. So I’m wondering why it would be trunk - especially as I’d say the whole point is to create a motorway-trunk-primary hierarchy in the road network.

Comment from floridaeditor on 24 June 2020 at 12:34

@GinaroZ Oh, I misunderstood! Yes, okay, the link won’t load properly for me, but now I understand, thank you.

Log in to leave a comment