OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
103021064 over 4 years ago

> Until rendering is possible, we should wait until changing it to highway=busway.

This suggestion goes against best practices; how something renders in Carto should not determine which tags are used.

For more information, please consult the following wiki page:

osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer

103108838 over 4 years ago

If you would like, I'll revert the changesets.

103108838 over 4 years ago

I apologize.

Basically, a proposal I wrote got accepted, and I sort of jumped the gun on updating every tag everywhere before adequately notifying developers of the change. Here is the wiki page for the tag:

highway=busway

In hindsight, I should have at-least put this in the weeklyOSM.

103021064 over 4 years ago

I admit that the manner in which I went about these edits was a careless, irresponsible, and perhaps even inconsiderate, and that I should have instead waited for local editors to make such changes instead.

However, I would like to point out that just because it does not yet render in OSM Carto does not mean that it is wrong. Here is the feature page for highway=busway:

highway=busway

103215409 over 4 years ago

1. I will work on that at a later time if no one does so before me.

2. I think it does, but I'm not sure how it impacts buses.

103215409 over 4 years ago

This change set includes the addition of different features, such as tree rows and bus platforms.

103215409 over 4 years ago

If the person reviewing this wants to revert this changeset, I ask that they do so without using any scripts.

103080197 over 4 years ago

This conversation has been referenced here:

changeset/103064361

103064361 over 4 years ago

I will next be working on undoing the change sets for Buenos Aires.

103064361 over 4 years ago

The list of cities includes:

- Buenos Aires
- Santiago
- Lima
- Guayaquil
- Quito
- Bucaramanga
- Port of Spain
- Bogotá
- Cartagena
- Barranquilla
- Caracas
- Ciudad de Guatemala
- Ciudad de México
- Puebla
- Léon
- Querétaro
- Guadalajara
- Monterry

103064361 over 4 years ago

Good, but the same needs to happen in other Latin American cities that I messed up.

103064361 over 4 years ago

Additional conversation is in the following changeset;

changeset/103080197

103064361 over 4 years ago

Well, I did something *incredibly* idiotic, and I did it over and over again.

I wanted to unilaterally make `highway=busway` a de facto tag, without contacting local tagging groups, *without it even being translated into Spanish.*

Today, I will be unilaterally trying to undo the changes I made.

103080197 over 4 years ago

The following is a list of changesets I was going to reverse:

changeset/103079524
changeset/103079910
changeset/103079869
changeset/103080117
changeset/103079656
changeset/103080197
changeset/103080458
changeset/103080401
changeset/103080369
changeset/103080692

103080197 over 4 years ago

I was just about to put a list of my own changesets into http://revert.osmz.ru/, but then I realized that I would be making the same mistake again. I would be rashly performing mass edits.

103080197 over 4 years ago

I actually made these edits manually, so I did not think to read through the Automated Edits Code of Conduct.

103010541 over 4 years ago

I accidentally fucked everything up with this changeset.

103080197 over 4 years ago

Should I reverse the change set?

103080197 over 4 years ago

Okay, I will now stop attempting such mass edits.

102149599 over 4 years ago

Please fix this for me.