Westmeath Field Names Recording Project (Ireland)
Posted by b-unicycling on 11 July 2020 in English.I finally got in contact with the person responsible for the Westmeath Field Names Recording Project (Aengus Finnegan) last week. I asked him whether it would be possible to use the data collected by them and to add them to OSM and he saw no problem saying they were published on logainm under Creative Commons license. So I have started transfering the data, but it is slow going, because I don’t have a list of townlands covered by the project, they don’t have one on the website. Also, they didn’t mark the fields as areas, but just with markers, so it is tricky to know where one field ends and the next one starts.
I believe they used the Ordnance Survey 25’’ map which was finished/ published in 1913. Of course, field boundaries have changed since then, i.e. fields have been merged into bigger ones.
But with all the complaining, it is great to have them available for OSM!
Discussion
Comment from lyx on 11 July 2020 at 22:18
That sounds like interesting data to have. However, you might want to double check the license before adding that data to OSM. The logainm website says “Data © Government of Ireland”. I could not find any hint that a creative commons license was used, but even if it were it could be a problem, because most CC licenses are problematic for import in OSM. The two main problems with CC licenses here are “-nc” licenses, because OSM makes its database available also for commercial use, and “-by” because data sources can only be mentioned on the contributors page in the wiki, and downstream users of the OSM database are only required to list OSM as a source. Best is to get a written confirmation by the copyright holder that they are ok with the import of their data to OSM.
Comment from amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️⚧️ on 12 July 2020 at 11:12
We’ve imported some Logainm data into OSM before. There are ways to get the licence clear. Don’t worry, there would be people like me who know this area working on such an import.