This and another change set has resulted in duplication of bus stops ... 3 of them at each location so far.

Please use, when available, already existing OSM features rather than recreating them.

A relation is not required for the school - just tag the outer way.

The tag 'building=yes' says the whole site is one building .. not the case.

The DCS Base Map gives better boundaries for objects like schools, parks etc.

I have changed this, see what you think.

Hi,
You have quite a few bus relations that don't meet PTv2 requirements.

Before you enter more of them, how about fixing the ones you have entered? Hopefully learning how to get them correct before uploading them to OSM?

See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=pubtrans_routes&lon=151.29722&lat=-33.82313&zoom=9&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=ptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes%2Cptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes

Repaired bus route terminal transfer to your ways .. I have noted that imagery does not support these changes (as yet).

Hi,
highway=stop_position must be on the way where the bus/train stops. highway=bus_stop is adjacent to the way - where the passengers wait to get on - thus not on the way.

The correct tag to use with highway=bus_stop is public_transport=platform.

?????
This looks to have made open roads back to construction ... see Way: Sydney Gateway (39749554)

And possibly deleted roads in existence?

Hi,
'highway=bus_stop' are not 'public_transport=stop_position' as they are not on the road way but along side it where passengers wait. What they are is 'public_transport=platform'.

I have corrected this one.

This 'de ordered' the ways of relation/10627407 bus route 633 to Pennant Hills. Leave you to fix this one?

The area here is desert.... water is mostly intermittent.

Bus stop added to end of bus route relation 'Epping - City (King Street Wharf) via Macquarie Centre & Pacific Highway (4174340, v100)'
It should be added somewhere at the front - sequence with the other bus stops.

bus stop is at end of relation - should be somewhere up the front with the other bus stops..

Bus stop error ... empty role .. and it is a duplicate of already entered stop ... suggest that it is no sequential...

Hi,
Welcome to OSM!

This changeset removed some 'wetland' areas sourced for the DCS Base Map. They may be better tagged as 'intermittent=yes' ... possibly only 'wet' during floods? What do you think? Past mappers may probably only be using the data from that Base Map thus missing the 'only during floods' aspect?

Some of these are not PTv2 compliant...

Relations 15631643, 3552678, 3386431, 15631643, 5985178, 3738476, 2509188
and 3552679 ... not PTv2 compliant.

5 relations with gaps..

I have attempted some corrections... however someone has made some changes during my changes - so I have taken them in preference to my own.

Bus stops added to PTv2 must have tags "public_transport=platform" and "bus=yes"... those added to bus route 290 'Epping - City' don't have these tag - thus fail PTv2.

See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=pubtrans_routes&lon=151.23855&lat=-33.76979&zoom=11&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=ptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes%2Cptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes

Bus route 166 (to) Frenches Forest. What I have done....

Placed the ways into the correct sequence, they run from start to finish.

Stops placed into the correct sequence - from start to finish. All stops placed at the beginning of the relation.

If you don't know how to do this .. find out. I don't used Id, I did use it once or twice when I first started with OSM, but was told that if I wanted to do complex stuff I was better off using JOSM. I have been using JOSM since then.
Please examine the relation/10624943 and see how it is organized ... both the stops (platforms) and ways ...

Moved bus stop in relation for 166 route to correct position in the relation.

In PTv2 ALL bus stops are placed before the ways. All of them. None of them go after the ways.

Existing bus stops already in OSM probably meet the PTv1 requirements. For PTv2 you have to add tags "public_transport=platform" and probably "bus=yes". The real headache is getting the dam things in sequential order.
Good luck.

A 'bus stop' is beside the road.

A bus 'stop_position' is on the road - where the bus actually stops.

For PTv2 a "bus stop" must be tagged as "public_transport=platform"

Node: Santa Maria del Monte, The Boulevarde (2877493994) changed back to "public_transport"="platform"

Out of sequence bus stops without roles in the route relation removed from the relation.

Step 1) place them in sequential order
step 2 ) add the role 'platform' in the relation.