Hi,

The roles 'inner' and 'outer' are mixed up in relation/15406000 - 'outer' should be the outside of the building ..

Same thing in a different changeset of yours on relation/15405981 - water ... roles mixed up. See relation/15405981

Hi,
The 'Clover Hill Road' appears on the DCS Base Map. Yet the western ends are unnamed on the DCS Base Map but you have them named. Can you confirm that there are on the ground signs with the name?
Present press reports call it 'Clover Hill Trail'... probably reflecting the state of the road.

Hi,
Welcome to OSM!

There is a problem with relation/15452881 - meadow. It 'only' has inners - no outer way. See relation/15452881.
Always best to keep it simple? If these 'inners' are actually the meadows then delete the relation and place tags on these ways... ???

The DCS base map has two 'park' names to the west ... it is not very good at separating them... but it does define the 'park' or what ever the area is .. and those boundaries can be taken as the legal boundaries. Rock, trees and grass don't indicate legal boundaries, so I'd not use them when the DCS base map is available.

Note that the sea ward side is the hi tide mark for the coast .. don't move it, leave it alone and make new ways for stuff.

The Tanks could be place=islet for any bits above the hi tide .. that way they should render above the sea.

Yer.. I'd not worry about a relation for the rock areas. Just map each rock area with the name=The Tanks .. and maybe a website link to https://barringtoncoast.com.au/directory/the-tanks
...
I'd not be worried about the swimming aspect ... possibly dangerous at certain tides?

Hi,

Thanks for adding this detail into OSM.

However the area is also covered by Way: 135196663 .. so the rocks with be covered by tree symbols.. See way/135196663 Note that it is also tagged 'landuse=conservation' .. but I think it is more park than conservation. In any case the OSM guide is 'one feature=one OSM entry' so the trees should be split from the other feature (whatever it is). I take it your local so may know if it is signed as a park?

Hi,

What are 'The Tanks'???
It is not clear from imagery .. and 'swimming pool' does not look appropriate?

The relation .. has no outer way .. so that does not work. Think both ways should be 'outer' .. but the tags still do not explain what they are...

Humm web search suggest these are rock formations .. so 'natural=bear_rock' ... then tag the sea between them and the shore with a node 'leisure=swimming_pool' ???

Hi,

The National Park looks like it incorporated parts of a state forests?? Does the National Park coexist with the state forest or has the state forest beed reduced by the National Park taking some of it away???
way/686125986#map=15/-34.4407/116.2668

Yer .. found rugby in the local press .. so I added that and cricket..
Thanks for the reply.

\Hi,

Note these are not personal criticisms but information about OSM tagging and mapping to help improve your mapping.

Hi,

What kind of 'football' is played here?

The 'Catherine Field Baseball Park' ... looks to be named 'Les Tegal Oval' on the DCS Base map???

I have removed the name 'Catherine Field Park Cricket Nets' and corrected the sport tag to sport=cricket_nets'.

Hi,
The 'name' tag is for names only - not 'descriptions' such as tennis court etc.

Hi,
notes are used to alert other mappers to problems ... not to describe the feature.
These 'notes' have all been changed to 'description'...

Hi
This one changeset has heath and bear rock in the one location, it cannot be both ... see
way/1136351103#map=19/-35.60373/149.11648
way/1136351104

In another changeset that is also another conflict see
way/1136351105

Hi,
This edit has caused way 877757159 (park) to cross itself...
see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=116.01023&lat=-31.97233&zoom=19&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=duplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways%2Cduplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways

Hi
way/1136484941 is in error... you do repeat this error from time to time.. why?

See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=115.86166&lat=-32.01328&zoom=19&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=duplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways%2Cduplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways

This looks like 4 separate houses - look at the entry ways.

Hi,

The name tag is for names only, not descriptions. See osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

Hi,

The DCS Base Map (should be available with your editor) has the present day boundaries ... they include the boundary for the road... take a look.

The DCS base map says no wet land in this area at all.
Additionally there are several areas that are not grass that are within the relation but not members... meaning there is some work to do on the relation.