Vincent de Phily's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 34416216 | about 10 years ago | Sorry, I don't agree with that change (healthcare:speciality -> health:speciality). The heathcare:speciality tag is the documented one and used 7613 times, vs 6 times for health:speciality. Please revert that change, unless you have a very convincing argument to transition obkects to the health:speciality tag. |
| 34011114 | over 10 years ago | Reverted in changeset/34044594 |
| 34011114 | over 10 years ago | Please do not contribute private or fictional data. Names of private individual property owners are not recorded in OSM, at most we record the housename when it has one. Unless you can show that the house is indeed named like this (ideally by puting a photo of the house's nameplate on Mapillary), this changeset will get reverted. |
| 26892848 | over 10 years ago | Are you sure about the Archer's Island place=locality ? Isn't it a duplicate of the place=island of the same name 150m east ?
|
| 33780784 | over 10 years ago | Welcome to OSM, good to see you're taking care of your shop's map data :) Have a look at shop=bicycle you might want to add service:bicycle tags to your shop. Also, it'd be good to move the POI inside the building. If Outdoor Escape occupies the whole building, you can even put the tags on the building rather than on a stand-alone node. To do that in iD, select both objects at the same time using shift, and click the "+" (merge) icon. Happy mapping. |
| 33500805 | over 10 years ago | Reverted along with changeset/33646862 |
| 33646862 | over 10 years ago | Sorry, but given the road layout and your past behavior, I don't belive this. Reverted. Upload a Mapillary photo of the streetsign if you contest this. Please stop wasting people's time (including your own) with vandalism. If you want to edit OSM there are endless constructive ways to do so. Please communicate : answer changeset discussions, fill in changeset comments, send PMs, go on IRC or the forums, etc. |
| 33600543 | over 10 years ago | Welcome to OSM, changes look good :) Is there really an archaeological site separate from the castle itself ? If not, there should be only one OSM object. Have a look at osm.wiki/Castle and start_date=* for more details to add to the castle building. Oh, and resolve the note you opened if the problem is fixed. Cheers. |
| 33500805 | over 10 years ago | According to my memory and http://www.mapillary.com/map/im/zDcF2czkoXHqbJStZ72Ejg/photo (which I took in April), you can go straight on here. That no_straight_through restriction also doesn't make sense from a traffic flow POV. Can you point at your source ? Otherwise I'll remove that restriction. Please include detailed comments and source in your future changesets. |
| 19666197 | over 10 years ago | Can you give more details about Bog Bridge ? When I spoted that "bridge" I first thought it was a mishap. Add a surface tag and a note. Would embankment=yes be better than bridge=yes ? Maybe add paths leading to/from it and give it some Bing alignment love ? |
| 33152447 | over 10 years ago | jokes are supposed to be funny, this is just vandalism wasting everybody's time. I've reverted this and your other recent vandalism changesets. You've been a productive contributor before as far as I can see. Please be that again, and find constructive ways to entertain yourself. |
| 32582533 | over 10 years ago | Comment for the original changeset: IE, Kilkenny - Add guestimated city boundary, remove superfluous addr:city and GNS tags, move admin_center to a more central, less cluttered location. Currently all tags from the old node are duplicated on the relation, not sure if that's necessary. |
| 32582533 | over 10 years ago | Bleh - they were supposed to be two distinct changesets but network connection was bad, the first (less trivial) changeset was not closed, and then merged with this one, overwriting its comment. |
| 32566645 | over 10 years ago | I'd much rather create a polygon for the city boundary than add addr:city to all the addresses in there... |
| 32232259 | over 10 years ago | |
| 32228292 | over 10 years ago | Welcome to OSM, good first changeset :) Two small nitpicks to improve things later on:
Check amenity=school for other tips. Some tags that I always try to add for schools is school=primary/secondary, religion/denomination, and male/female. Enjoy your mapping :) |
| 32187756 | over 10 years ago | Hi, welcome to OSM :) I reverted this changeset because the golf course was already mapped, as an area rather than a node. Go ahead and give it another shot :) Maybe you know the golf course's name, or you could fix the geometry/position of some of these ways that were traced using old badly-aligned imagery, or you could trace other details of the golf course ? Don't hesitate to ask if you have questions.
|
| 27599099 | over 10 years ago | 1:25K GSGS 3906 gives "Fallavallgh" instead of "Fallavagh" as the alt_name for lough Ahusey. Was the name misread from GSGS, or is it yet another alternative name ? |
| 31897964 | over 10 years ago | Also, is Ce na Mara a different feature completely, or part of the hotel ? |
| 31868396 | over 10 years ago | Welcome to OSM :) You might want to chime in to the discussion at changeset/31897964 |