OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
160518845 about 1 year ago

This park is already mapped so this seems to be a duplicate.
Next time please provide a better change set comment, for more info see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

160376823 about 1 year ago

at TPA

160316090 about 1 year ago

If you know their wrong then you should be able to determine the correct values so please add the correct ones. It is really unfortunate to have taxiways that don't have a ref in OSM since that is basically required information for any potential data consumers.

160224236 about 1 year ago

please respond to the questions about the additions in Miami Dade County, I would really like to know what the source for those is and in general an answer to my other questions about this commit posted above.

160224236 about 1 year ago

a few notes here, first of all next time please try to keep the geographic size of your commits down.
second I doubt that there is a community center in the middle of the FIU parking lots. third, the guest houses you added in Doral are definitely positioned incorrectly as they are bunched together way to much and some of their names sound somewhat suspicious since a name like "home" or "home sleep" sound incorrect. so I would like to kn ow what the sources for this commit are.

160155237 about 1 year ago

whats the source for this?

160012546 about 1 year ago

did you add this purely based on the aerial imagery (armchair mapping) or have you recently been through here (since late July of this year which is when I last was at MIA) recently because otherwise this parking lot no longer exists. the construction isn't on any of the latest imagery but it was clear that they were building a multistory parking garage (it was labeled as such) and that isn't what you mapped. so either this needs tagging and geometry fixes or no longer exists.

159962304 about 1 year ago

first of all I doubt that Expedia and booking.com are license compliant with OSM so I doubt that they can be used as sources for OSM commits. second non of those sources mention who gave the hotel 4 stars they just call it 4 star, the whole point is that the star rating is supposed to come from a verifiable source, something official. quoting the wiki:
"To comply with the verifiability requirement, only stars that are awarded by recognised tourism boards, based on objective criteria, or based on association memberships, should be mapped. That excludes values from rating platforms that collect subjective opinions. "
and:
"The US has no standard hotel/restaurant rating system, as such, all star ratings in the US are a form of advertising. So the use of the stars tag in the US is discouraged. "

160041934 about 1 year ago

next time please split your commit into multiple geographically smaller changes instead of on that is this large. in the case of this commit, based on what I could see in OSMCha this should have been two, one in Puerto Rico and another in Indiantown.

160012782 about 1 year ago

way/786346226

Before you add something please check that someone hasn’t already mapped the building, you may need to change a few tags but adding a new building one top of the existing building is incorrect unless your using building:part=* , this is the kind you of thing we (the OSM community) have tools like osmose and osmi to find along with many others since we don’t want overlapping buildings.

160012546 about 1 year ago

If it is done then it is a parking garage (the imagery isn’t up to date) and it is likely called Parking Garage 6 because that is what the signs on the fences surrounding the construction said when it was under construction. I can attest to it being a parking garage as I flew out and into MIA in July and saw them building it from the other parking garages and the departures road at that point.

160012782 about 1 year ago

this seems to have added a duplicate object

160012546 about 1 year ago

does this mean that the construction there is complete in that area.

159980140 about 1 year ago

are you sure because in the official databases put out by Miami Dade County the address is listed as 17117 Southwest 82nd Court.

159977154 about 1 year ago

next time you add a building please check that your not adding a duplicate, the gas station was already mapped just not tagged as a building.

159962304 about 1 year ago

were did you get the star=* value from, I ask because for that tag we cant just add things from the website unless we know what agency its fro and that the rating that agency puts out is verifiable, for more info see stars=*.

159266749 about 1 year ago

please stop rounding of the ramps, there is nothing on the imagery that suggests that they are rounded like that

159312555 about 1 year ago

please stop rounding of the exit ramps there is nothing on the available imagery that shows them being rounded.

159334992 about 1 year ago

typo, meant to type:
"Add ref numbers to elevator rooms."

159269420 about 1 year ago

Also please stop mapping turn:lane tagging as geometry.