OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
90964145 over 5 years ago

auch erledigt: changeset/90993919

66056343 almost 7 years ago

I agree and I also thought a lot about that in the beginning, because this is exactly what ref: is for and would be the consistent way having is globally done.
Anyways there were/are bigger import projects from INEGI being done already by other teams, see
osm.wiki/Mexico's_Administrative_Divisions_Import_Project
here INEGI:MUNID was defined

osm.wiki/Mexico_Road_Name_Import_Project
here INEGI:roadkey is defined

Since I am only manually and regional importing data (incl. manual review), my impact is not that big.

Nevertheless I still agree with you, but the bigger import projects should consider that in first place.

Another issue I am facing currently is: MUNID = CVE_ENT + CVE_MUN
LOCID = CVE_ENT + CVE_MUN + CVE_LOC
but I don't know a convinient way to concenate tags in JOSM.

It makes sense to have for place (localidad) only: ref:MX:INEGI:LOCID
instead of
INEGI:CVE_ENT, INEGI:CVE_MUN, INEGI:CVE_LOC

66056343 almost 7 years ago

Hi Jan,
thanks for your feedback and apologies for my delayed response.

In the meantime I expanded the overview page about INEGI in the wiki with more details about datasets, links and tag infos.
osm.wiki/INEGI
It's not complete, yet and somehow I hope it gives a better overview of what data is available from INEGI and more people make use of.

While writing the docs, I realized that some of the tags are being used in multiple dataset and also in an index file about all places (localidades) like: cve_edo / cve_mun / cve_loc.

Others might not be used across different datasets, so I am going to remove them from the places, where I added them, like:
carta, identifica, objectid

Hope the wiki explains a bit, let me know your thoughts.

Cheers,
Tommy

63995579 about 7 years ago

which hospital should this be ? or is it only a first aid station? I am not aware of any hospital in parque tangamanga

63130668 over 7 years ago

Hi Fernando,
nice that you've made changes to SLP the last days. Not 100% sure but, for most of those areas you tagged as park might be better tagges as landuse = grass, wouldn't it?

please see following for more iinfos:

osm.wiki/ES:Tag:landuse%3Dgrass

What I don't find currently is the documentation about how to add those areas, but actually they should not be snapped to the streets,to allow easier maintaining the other ways etc..
Only this one, but it is related to buildings:
https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/35795/map-buildings-connecting-the-road-or-not

56638918 almost 8 years ago

Da der Eintrag über die App StreetComplete erfolgte habe ich keinen direkten Einfluss auf die verwendeten Tags. Daher bei Verbesserungsvorschlägen ggf an den app Autor wenden.