OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
128407496 about 3 years ago

Hello again.
In osm.org/user_blocks/6496 I asked you to try and talk to other mappers more so that everyone can understand what everyone else wants to do here. Unfortunately this is just a "revert without comment" - none of the changesets that create, delete and recreate way/951838450/history have any comment on them.
Please do try and talk to people in order to break the "revert cycle" that will surely happen if you fail to do that.
Best Regards,
Andy

127891348 about 3 years ago

In order to find communities of mappers in various places I'd suggest using https://openstreetmap.community/ . Of the links there, at least https://t.me/osmUA is fairly active (the others may be too).
Your comment "of which I have no sign of existance!" above comes across at best as tin-eared, and at worst as very rude indeed.

126927595 about 3 years ago

@VLD165 Looking at the area around
node/1022949816/history :

The water area is an nmixter import (on which any QA was likely very limited or non-existant)

Given that, if you want to add the water area in properly, starting from that import doesn't really help, because water moves around.

Essentially, I think that Asamant1 was correct to delete it. If you want to see a wider view on what people think about these imports have a look through talk-us or Slack convesations of the years.

I'm sure that everyone would be grateful if you (and FB) could commit time to mapping it properly - looking at recent imagery, figuring out which bits are likely to be intermittent and which not, and also mapping any post-imagery changes (likely to be tricky as I suspect that quite a lot of this area isn't very accessible)

Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

128395365 about 3 years ago

Hello,
Just for info, I've joined up the Wicklow Mountains National Park in changeset/128458176 . I've no idea if the bit of land on the northwest should also join - see e.g. osm.org/#map=19/53.15443/-6.49964 .
Best Regards,
Andy

128148581 about 3 years ago

With regard to way/1107572466/history#map=17/54.17017/-4.51272 it doesn't look like it matches the underlying imagery very well at all.

127902140 about 3 years ago

The park that was removed can be seen in red at https://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=127972855 . It's clearly not a park

127474250 about 3 years ago

Hello,
Although the changeset comment is "Update deprecated tags", can you explain what tags you actually changed on what objects here? At least some changes (e.g. https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/59338112 ) seem unrelated to tag changes at all.
Best Regards,
Andy

125365563 about 3 years ago

Danke Rüdiger,
Ich habe gestern bei Tageslicht nachgeschaut. Jetzt gibt es dort definitiv keinen Spielplatz mehr, und das Gestrüpp unter den Bäumen lässt darauf schließen, dass es seit ein paar Jahren keinen mehr gibt.
Ich werde es entfernen.
Mit freundlichen Grüßen,
Andy

125365563 about 3 years ago

Thanks Rüdiger,
I had a look in the daylight yesterday. There's definitely no playground there now, and the undergrowth under the trees suggest that there hasn't been one for a few years.
I'll remove it.
Best Regards,
Andy

128194800 about 3 years ago

This filled in a gap in "Hadrian's Wall Path (38791)".

128194782 about 3 years ago

This filled in a gap in "Lôn Las Cymru (South) (5487293)" and also (because I forgot to close the changeset) "Hadrian's Wall Path (38791)".

128194311 about 3 years ago

The comment here would be better with "Filled in gap in..." and resulted in a reduction in the number of pieces:

Change in relation components for Airedale_Way 5297531
3c3
< 7
---
> 3
relation/5297531
http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeRelation?relationId=5297531
http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=5297531

128191246 about 3 years ago

Hello,
Are you perhaps performing edits on behalf of Expedia? If so, in line with https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Organised_Editing_Guidelines ("A user’s profile page should also include links to the wiki pages of the organised edits and organisations they participate in on an ongoing basis."), could you please update you profile?
Best Regards.
Andy Townsend (from OSM's Data Working Group)

128194585 about 3 years ago

Er no - per comment on relation/11783851 this was wrong and I've removed it.

127802386 about 3 years ago

Echoing some comments to another mapper involved here at osm.org/user_blocks/6496 ;

Can everyone interested in editing in this area please try and find a suitable location for discussion and discuss what to do together there?”

Maybe the talk-us mailing list would work, or the new Community Forum, or OSM-US’s Slack instance.

I don't mind where but it's important for discussion to happen somewhere otherwise this continual "mapping and unmapping" cycle will continue.

Best Regards,
Andy (from the Data Working Group)

128150006 about 3 years ago

Also includes Strensall Common from survey 26/10/2022, tr9338a, and Earswick, New Earswick and Huntington from survey 27/10/2022, tr9342b.

125365563 about 3 years ago

Hello,
Does way/1089096345 actually exist? I walked past the other night and although it was a bit dark I couldn't see anything here.
Best Regards,
Andy

127968144 about 3 years ago

Hello obyrnegps,
Your edit to way/745960830/history makes no sense here. You seem to be suggesting that that road is connected to the footpath, but not to Heatherview Close. How do people get from one to the other - in one of Northern Ireland's famous flying DeLoreans?
Best Regards,
Andy

127967210 about 3 years ago

سلام طاها6831.
لطفاً از نظرات تغییراتی استفاده کنید که کار شما را توضیح می دهد، نه فقط "..."
با احترام،
اندی

127967210 about 3 years ago

Hello Taha6831.
Please use changeset comments that explain what you did, not just ".... "
Best Regards,
Andy