OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
155077463 over 1 year ago

Hello,
I'm adding this comment to each of changeset/155077463 , changeset/155077906 , changeset/155077446 , changeset/155077894 .

Accusing each other of vandalism and reverting changes without discussion won't get us anywhere. Please discuss these changes on the forum together. Tags already exist there for https://community.openstreetmap.org/tag/armenia and https://community.openstreetmap.org/tag/azerbaijan .

Best Regards,

Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group

155257381 over 1 year ago

I'd suggest discussing these changes at https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/undiscussed-changes-to-designation-in-england-and-wales/117463 .

107904649 over 1 year ago

Clearly UCR here is not a name, it is a designation ("unclassified_county_road") . See https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1PLS .
"designation=unclassified_highway" is used in other places to mean the same thing, but people normally tag what is signed and verifiable locally.

155255810 over 1 year ago

What was the source of the change to way/226989350/history here? Does the signage really say "unclassified_highway" rather than "unclassified_country_road"? In some areas the latter signage is pretty common?

155257381 over 1 year ago

You've said "Correcting designation to sign erected in 2022" but can we have a link to the sign?
You've changed way/35030994/history from a UCR to a BOAT (both valid designations, though the tagging of the former varies). If this really was a BOAT I'd expect it to be light red at https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#17/53.13297/-1.80330/H/P , but it isn't. Has the status been changed recently?

155256151 over 1 year ago

Hello,
What was the source of the change here? On-site survey? Something else?
Best Regards,
Andy

155255687 over 1 year ago

This edit moves horses from the sidewalk onto the road. That's consistent with the current OSM tagging, but it's possible that there is special off-road provision for horses here. If that's the case, it's likely that there's access from node/332211284#map=20/51.99956/-0.19350&layers=H to the sidewalk as well.

155236325 over 1 year ago

Your changeset comment here is "fantasy".
Can you explain what you mean by that?

155239586 over 1 year ago

Hello,
What is the source and licence of this data?
Best Regards,
Andy

155143045 over 1 year ago

(source is local_knowledge)

154996123 over 1 year ago

Thanks for updating this!

154845011 over 1 year ago

Oops - wrong account - should have been "SomeoneElse2" used for this.

154954447 over 1 year ago

Opinions differ about future status.
Local press has "owners on holiday but will not reopen", another has "long term closed", and a rumour in another York pub is that another (well known) local landlord is likely to take it on.
None of which contradicts that it's currently shut...

142319238 over 1 year ago

I've also taken the liberty of adding a changeset discussion comment that explained what happened a little better than "update area" :)

154927584 over 1 year ago

For info, the change here updated a number of railway stop positions from "railway=halt" (which they weren't) to "public_transport=stop_position" (which is what they seem to be.
The history of node/283481300/history shows what happened. See also changeset/142319238 .

142319238 over 1 year ago

Yes - I'm sure that is what the original mapper meant.

154756773 over 1 year ago

Must have given the commuters of Kirkstall Forge a shock!

154756773 over 1 year ago

Is a direct route from Forster Square to King's Cross even a thing?

154656143 over 1 year ago

@Nordpfeil wurde diese mechanische Bearbeitung irgendwo besprochen?

154656143 over 1 year ago

@Nordpfeil was this mechanical edit discussed anywhere?