OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
152807559 over 1 year ago

Hello VLD300,
While the previous name:en for https://osm.mapki.com/history/node/4027452036 was an unlikely one it's a bit of a stretch to say that an important place doesn't have an English name at all.
What was the reason that you removed it?
I'd be interested to know what your sources for current status and name is. It's actually probably worth discussing over at the forum. Two communities claim this region as "theirs"; following a war one is currently in control. There will no doubt be be argument on the forum about who _ought_ to control and name this area; but information about the on-the-ground status may be harder to come by.
Best Regards,
Andy

143614355 over 1 year ago

Hello Binnette,
You appear to be trying to import data from wikidata into OpenStreetMap without checking the licence of the data collected in wikidata or checking that OSM does not already have better data.
When importing data, or asking other people to import data, you must follow osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines .
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend from OSM's Data Working Group

152762589 over 1 year ago

Thanks! You beat be to reverting that by a minute!

152700850 over 1 year ago

Thanks - if you spot any others please let me know!

152700112 over 1 year ago

please do not revert these piecemeal

152699747 over 1 year ago

please don't revert these piecemeal

152621058 over 1 year ago

Hello,
Please don't use simple tools like osm-revert on complicated reverts like this. See the links in the forum at https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/the-osm-standard-tile-layer-looks-wrong-white-lines-abusive-comments-etc/111583/277 and elsewhere.
Best Regards,
Andy

152625506 over 1 year ago

It looks like node/1227778538/history has already been deleted and restored once. What investigation did you do to make sure that it really should be deleted, and not added to some way or relation, or left for future mapping?

152586086 over 1 year ago

This is entirely unrelated to the Little Ale House (which is in Harrogate!). I wrote a long detailed changeset comment which seems to have been lost.
What this was actually about was a reconciliation of road and PRoW status based on various sources - survey (and imperfect signage), and PRoW status and road status from https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#15/53.7787/-1.0390/2/P (toggle the PRoW layer and zoom in to see OS OpenMap Local road status.
A Microsoft mapper contacted me because the previous state (a mixture of unclassified and track) was clearly rubbish.

152537016 over 1 year ago

Thanks!

152537016 over 1 year ago

After theis change there are now two new big gaps - is that correct? See http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=12812573 .

152616823 over 1 year ago

Thanks for trying to help, but please don't try and revert these one at a time. They will need to be done together.

152617548 over 1 year ago

Thanks for teying to help but please do not try and revert these changesets piecemeal. There are maby of them and they need to be reverted together.

152215623 over 1 year ago

Even when doing "I used this sources to verify information, not to copy any data", I suspect that you'd still need to understand the licence on that site and the terms on which you might be able to use it.
We're not going to have a full discussion about this in a changeset comment - you need to discuss it in the forum.

152215623 over 1 year ago

Nur zur Bestätigung: Unter welcher Lizenz werden die Daten auf diesen Sites bereitgestellt?

152215623 over 1 year ago

Just to confirm, under what licence is that data made available from those sites?

152451710 over 1 year ago

Thanks! I'd already blocked that user.

152422436 over 1 year ago

You quite possibly didn't change anything - I just noticed that the number of elements in the line in the database had changed, and that you were the last editor. Quite often, those two things aren't related at all - an edit to the geometry of a way that wouldn't show up in relation history might also "break" a relation, or (because I only check relations every now and again) it might have been an earlier change.

152433586 over 1 year ago

I believe that "Purple Street" etc. are from some learnosm / teachosm test data. I've reverted the changeset in changeset/152499193 .

@GbiriJoe somehow you've managed to combine the training data ("Red Street" etc.) with actual new things that you want to add. If you try again, but don't go near the training data, all should be OK.
Any questions, please don't hesitate to ask!

152422436 over 1 year ago

Hello,
There's a bit of a gap in the England Coast Path now: http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=11738490
I'm guessing it now goes to the east?
Best Regards,
Andy