OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
141931434 over 2 years ago

Hello Orkhan17,
Rather than editing this a small piece at a time can you please join the discussion at https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/edit-warring-over-nagorno-karabakh-region-republic/57413/14 ?
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

141692468 over 2 years ago

Thanks for filling in the gap here. There are quite a few more that you can see at http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=85775 . I'm guessing that they predate your editing of it; I'm just mention it here because I bet you can fill in some of the other gaps!

141697670 over 2 years ago

For waymarks see image links from node/11216196019 and node/11216175282

141697670 over 2 years ago

I've removed the fixme from relation/3318993 the Harcamlow Way that had said "no waymarks" since there _are_ now waymarks for at least part of this.

121852091 over 2 years ago

Thanks!

141566074 over 2 years ago

@GPSMAP67 You have now promised again (by OSM PM) not to edit way/1086252957. You did this previously on 30/05/2023 and then broken that promise just now.
To be clear, all that anyone is asking for is some evidence that this is, in OSM terms, a "path". Next time you're there, take a photo or three so that we can discuss with everyone else what the best tagging for it is.

141162853 over 2 years ago

Again, I'd suggest to both sides of this argument that a discussion at https://community.openstreetmap.org (with photos attached!) would be far more productive than tit for tat complaints to the DWG.

141400713 over 2 years ago

Also ts0196a and ts0197b, Beningbrough

141338929 over 2 years ago

Re "Apparently someone did the ground work and has visited the site" they clearly didn't notice that the POI was in the middle of the road :)
I'll delete it.

141263403 over 2 years ago

Hello Rockedf,
For the avoidance of doubt, OSM is NOT a business directory. Most "work from home" businesses will not be and should not be in OSM. The adder of this "business" was asked about it in changeset/137416757 and didn't reply; that's often a good indication that it's not a real bricks-and-mortar business.
Best Regards,
Andy

139498692 over 2 years ago

That sounds very much like an organised editing process. Can you please read https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Organised_Editing_Guidelines and make sure that you follow it?

141338929 over 2 years ago

Clearly the POI here is rubbish. The location is in the middle of the road!

It's clear that the business owner accepts bitcoin, at least according to her website https://w4lkies.com/ .

What is NOT clear is whether this is actual a physical business that is mappable in OSM at all.
OSM is not a business directory - work from home businesses wouldn't typically be added.

Have you actually visited this location and verified that there is a physical business location here?

141162853 over 2 years ago

Re "how come you keep blindly demanding explanations in my change sets" then the reason is because the DWG is getting continual complaints. I'm not in Luxemburg and can't judge how much merit they have or not; that's way it'd be great to have photo evidence of some of these (and thanks for providing that in the past).

140106715 over 2 years ago

Thanks!

140342133 over 2 years ago

Hallo,
Wat was de aanleiding voor de opmaak van het veld "naam" van Marokko hier?
Hartelijke groeten,
Andy

140342133 over 2 years ago

Hello,
What prompted the formatting of the "name" field of Morocco here?
Best Regards,
Andy

32502463 over 2 years ago

Re "someone should do a thorough review" you might want to mention it at community.osm.org or in OSM US' Slack so that more people are aware of it.
Best Regards,
Andy

141012502 over 2 years ago

I've hidden the spam link.

138964092 over 2 years ago

Changesets by this user are:

id
-----------
138962931
138962933
138962464
138962879
138962880
138962881
138962920
138963165
138963186
138963187
138963208
138963205
138963207
138963303
138963304
138963890
138962740
138962772
138962470
138962472
138962474
138962485
138962491
138962496
138962501
138962509
138962512
138962514
138962518
138962525
138962528
138962532
138962540
138962543
138962545
138962548
138962549
138962551
138962553
138962555
138962559
138962564
138962566
138962569
138962573
138962577
138962580
138962583
138962588
138962597
138962607
138962620
138962661
138962689
138962710
138962711
138962712
138962713
138962714
138962715
138962717
138962718
138962719
138962722
138962723
138962724
138962726
138962727
138962732
138962733
138962735
138962736
138962738
138962739
138962743
138962746
138962750
138962752
138962754
138962761
138962763
138962764
138962768
138962769
138962770
138962774
138962776
138962778
138962779
138962780
138962782
138962783
138962785
138962787
138962790
138962791
138962793
138962799
138962802
138962804
138962807
138962812
138962813
138962817
138962819
138962821
138962823
138962825
138962826
138962828
138962878
138962832
138962836
138962840
138962841
138962844
138962849
138962851
138962856
138962861
138962862
138962863
138962864
138962866
138962867
138962868
138962869
138962870
138962872
138962873
138962874
138962876
138962877
138962882
138962883
138962887
138962889
138962891
138962892
138962895
138962897
138962900
138962902
138962903
138962905
138962906
138962908
138962909
138962910
138962911
138962912
138962913
138962914
138962917
138962922
138962923
138962925
138962926
138962929
138962936
138962938
138962940
138962942
138962944
138962945
138962954
138963043
138963036
138963038
138963039
138963041
138963042
138963044
138963046
138963048
138963050
138963051
138963052
138963055
138963056
138963060
138963062
138963065
138963066
138963069
138963070
138963071
138963072
138963073
138963074
138963075
138963076
138963077
138963079
138963080
138963081
138963082
138963083
138963087
138963089
138963091
138963092
138963094
138963096
138963100
138963102
138963104
138963106
138963108
138963112
138963114
138963117
138963119
138963121
138963124
138963126
138963129
138963134
138963137
138963139
138963142
138963146
138963147
138963185
138963150
138963152
138963155
138963159
138963163
138963164
138963168
138963172
138963175
138963178
138963179
138963182
138963184
138963189
138963190
138963193
138963194
138963195
138963196
138963197
138963198
138963200
138963201
138963202
138963203
138963209
138963211
138963212
138963224
138963227
138963228
138963230
138963231
138963232
138963234
138963236
138963239
138963240
138963241
138963242
138963244
138963245
138963247
138963248
138963251
138963254
138963255
138963257
138963258
138963259
138963261
138963267
138963268
138963269
138963270
138963273
138963275
138963277
138963278
138963279
138963281
138963284
138963286
138963290
138963292
138963293
138963294
138963295
138963301
138963306
138963307
138963309
138963311
138963314
138963315
138963316
138963317
138963318
138963319
138963322
138963324
138963325
138963328
138963329
138963331
138963332
138963334
138963336
138963338
138963339
138963341
138963342
138963344
138963346
138963347
138963348
138963349
138963350
138963352
138963353
138963354
138963357
138963381
138963390
138963418
138963454
138963522
138963537
138963547
138963554
138963564
138963570
138963575
138963585
138963604
138963616
138963626
138963636
138963658
138963670
138963676
138963681
138963684
138963688
138963695
138963743
138963754
138963760
138963767
138963779
138963795
138963823
138963841
138963847
138963855
138963873
138963879
138963881
138963885
138963887
138963891
138963893
138963895
138963909
138963912
138963930
138963942
138963948
138963952
138963955
138963959
138963963
138963964
138963967
138963970
138963973
138963991
138963997
138963998
138964002
138964005
138964011
138964141
138964087
138964088
138962465
138964130
138964132
138964133
138964134
138964135
138964137
138964138
138964140
138963700
138963500
138963468
138963442
138963361
138963561
138964092
(405 rows)

138964092 over 2 years ago

The revert here was done via the perl revert scripts, which turned out to be not fast enough to deal with the issue, hence other methods being used for the problems through August (this was a very early case of that vandalism). If you look at https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/759814358 for example you can see that many different accounts subsequently vandalised the ways affected here.