OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
121937947 over 3 years ago

Hello,
Just checking that the deletion of Dromard Parish here was deliberate? It was relation/10727432/history and was previously https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1j1R .
Best Regards,
Andy

121740113 over 3 years ago

@MasonSellsFL Thanks for fixing these. Does anything else need doing?

121823126 over 3 years ago

Hello,
Is the new bridge the northern one or the southern one? Currently the Moray Coast Trail goes over both of them relation/1754599#map=16/57.7175/-3.2800 , although the northern one doesn't connect at the west end?
Best Regards,
Andy

121635148 over 3 years ago

There are too many people called Andy in this project :)
I'm not Andy Allan - I wouldn't know where to start with code contributions to the OSM website.
Obviously, if anyone from the Lithuanian community (in addition to Tomas) wants to explain the general interpretation here that would be most welcome.
However, with a DWG hat on, sometimes we need to adjudicate between different OSM communities (for example, what a region of a country thinks vs what the rest of the country thinks). We try and be reasonable, and try and make decisions based on common sense.
Many countries have some examples of anachronistic road classidication (the Oxford High Street in England is one example, another is a "lost" road in Russia that lead to a long forum thread, another was a similar example in the mountains of Ukraine last year).
I believe I've taken a common-sense approach to interpreting something that was written in 2010 - and also my edit extended the "asphalt" section to match the imagery (although I do appreciate that sometimes that might be out of date, after a harsh winter).

121740113 over 3 years ago

I teverted most of their other edits and can revert this too if you like (sometime later tonight)

121818923 over 3 years ago

Hello BC4FUN,
What was the source of the data that you added here, and how does it relate to node/796602147 ?
Best Regards,
Andy

121635148 over 3 years ago

See changeset/121819774 . I've followed both how things look from various imagery sources and followed a reasonable interpretation of osm.wiki/Lithuania#Roads_outside_of_cities .

121813114 over 3 years ago

Thanks - osm.org/user_blocks/6037 .

117256357 over 3 years ago

You've removed some very much still existent landscape features here!
I'm very familiar with the area here between Bootham Stray and Stamford Bridge, and the route of the old railway is still very much etched in the landscape.

119433499 over 3 years ago

Thanks

121615887 over 3 years ago

Hello,
Thanks for this. I've applied a temporary block osm.org/user_blocks/6033 and have reverting their other dubious edits in changeset/121778694 .
I'll rewrite the block message to something a bit less temporary when I've thought of something better to say...
Best Regards,
Andy (from the Data Working Group)

121764218 over 3 years ago

Hello infrastructure,
As I mentioned by email, the most recent of the comments on your changesets at http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=14005252 - please do reply there to understand what was the problem there. osm.org/user_blocks/6027 was revoked on the explicit understanding that you would do this.
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

121763406 over 3 years ago

This is a partial revert of some changes here, and unfortunately there are a couple of rough edges, such as around node/96112132 . This was partly because some of the changesets were a mixture of fantasy and genuine improvements.
I didn't revert changeset/121740113 here because the alignment changes looked broadly OK.

121635148 over 3 years ago

> We used our brains for higher level strategic decisions, not for pin-point local technical imaginary "problems".

Exactly - and anyone using their brain here would say that a bridge on a tertiary road clearly should be tertiary.

121635148 over 3 years ago

So you're saying that you're using the "highway=secondary" key to indicate "surface=paved"? That is simply wrong.
As written, osm.wiki/Lithuania#Roads_outside_of_cities isn't necessarily a problem provided that the person following that rule uses their brain - while tertiary roads outside cities may be generally unpaved, there will _always_ be exceptions and edge cases, apply that as a hard rule is just silly.
That line was introduced to the wiki in 2010: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Lithuania&direction=next&oldid=488532 . When things change (for example, more people will be mapping surface keys now) rules should reflect that.

121635148 over 3 years ago

> Your map does not work
Sorry - that was my fault, telling someone to look at something on a server and then doing some maintenance on that server :)
Try https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/136939797 , or even way/136939797/history , and compare with https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/377193119 .

121635148 over 3 years ago

@Tomas Straupis - https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/osm-deep-history/#/way/136939797 has been tertiary forever, but you seem to be insisting that this bridge is secondary. Can you explain why?
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.

121427903 over 3 years ago

Hello,
Can you explain what "Update max speed from 55 mph to 60 mph based on GPS data and more current data from other map providers" means?
Most map providers' data will be licence-incompatible with OpenStreetMap, so we'll probably need to revert and redact this change..
Best Regards,
Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group

121635998 over 3 years ago

Also 28/05 - 29/05

87147108 over 3 years ago

I know it was ages ago, but it looks like this cased a problem with the Morocco relation.
https://osm.mapki.com/history/relation/3630439 suggests that this re-added way/8692572 (Parsley Island) as an inner to relation/3630439 (Morocco).
There's a note on the Parsley Island way "Claimed by both Morocco and Spain. Neither claim recognized by other party. Since an armed conflict in 2002 between the parties, it remains unpopulated, and both sides agreed not to occupy it. Spain claims the island as part of the municipality of Ceuta."
Best Regards,
Andy