Rudolf Mayer's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 32411736 | over 8 years ago | for mini golf, please use leisure=miniature_golf (fixed for node/3634439340#map=19/49.76856) |
| 41786420 | over 8 years ago | You marked way/439786808 as a golf course / driving range; the provided website (http://www.golfjesenik.cz/) points to an online shoe shop, however.. can you clarify & correct the data? thanks! |
| 35805165 | over 8 years ago | You marked this as a golf course, can you please clarify the name & other details of it? |
| 48591956 | over 8 years ago | Are you sure that node/4847621164 is a mini golf course? Even if, mini golf has its own tag, not leisure=golf_course..
|
| 51785850 | over 8 years ago | Hallo! Ich würde das maximal als Wiese (landuse=grass) taggen, weil Golfplatz ist das nicht wirklich einer -
|
| 48052776 | over 8 years ago | Thanks for your edits; however, you added some duplicated ways to mark the bridges, instead of splitting the way and adding the bridge=yes part to the respective segments
|
| 48052945 | over 8 years ago | Thanks for your edits; however, you added some duplicated ways to mark the bridges, instead of splitting the way and adding the bridge=yes part to the respective segments
|
| 43440257 | almost 9 years ago | The name seems also very odd to me. If you give a specific name to this section, and call it "bypass", then it "Grafton bypass" would be the only logical name.
|
| 43041499 | about 9 years ago | Hier wurden einige Elemente der S36/Murtalschnellstrasse in Unzmarkt auf "construction" gesetzt; das ist aber noch nicht der Fall, daher wieder auf proposed gesetzt. |
| 38199225 | about 9 years ago | Ja, war vorher ein Minigolfplatz, mit deiner Änderung dann ein Golfplatz.. |
| 38593245 | about 9 years ago | I removed the golf_course tags that were introduced in this changeset to all holes of the course - the tags are supposed to be on the relation only |
| 38804696 | about 9 years ago | There was quite some mess created with this changeset, and e.g. changeset/38839575; many parts of the golf course were marked as separate golf courses, and many arbitrary and partially empty relations were created. fixed in changeset/43730904 et al. |
| 39692781 | about 9 years ago | I fixed your tagging of 17 additional golf courses within the Kremstal Golfresort; what you mapped are individual holes, not golf courses... |
| 38199225 | about 9 years ago | Ich habe den "Grünen Baum", der hier falsch geändert wurde, wieder korrekt als Minigolfkurs markiert, das ist kein Golfplatz :-) |
| 43064425 | about 9 years ago | Das ist in Österreich anders zu sehen, da es rechtlich keinen Unterschied zwischen Autobahnen und Schnellstraßen (mehr) gibt; Siehe z.B. http://www.asfinag.at/newsroom/wssarchiv/-/asset_publisher/3037242/content/autobahn-versus-autostra%C3%9Fe-%E2%80%93-der-feine-unterschied
Dazu auch osm.wiki/WikiProject_Austria/Schnellstra%C3%9Fen
Die S36 ist eigentlich durchgehend im Rang einer Autobahn, sollte daher auch als solches getagged werden. Werde ich korrigieren. |
| 43064425 | about 9 years ago | I saw you changed the classification of S36 in St. Georgen from motorway to trunk - can you explain why? This new part is built according to motorway standards, thus should be tagged as such; only Schnellstrassen that are marked as "Autostraße" should be marked as trunk road |
| 43086230 | about 9 years ago | In this changeset, you removed the toll= tag from e.g. way/287167110; can you explain why? This is normally used to indicate that the vignette/Go Box is required, and this is the case also for this piece of road, no? |
| 42004430 | about 9 years ago | With this edit, you deleted the Bom Sucesso golf club (ww.openstreetmap.org/way/312050200/history#map=16/39.3786/-9.2432), without any replacement; thus, now the golf course does not exist anymore in OSM...
|
| 42164943 | about 9 years ago | Did construction on the A7 really start? If so, you should also change the proposed=motorway into construction=motorway; if not, please revert. |
| 33099227 | over 9 years ago | way/363957647 in your changeset has no tags, and it is partially overlapping with existing roads; can you clarify what this is? a GPS track converted to a line? If so, this shouldn't be part of the map. Rather, you could use it as a base to map a path/track |