Hi Tom.

In this changeset you created the AED node/13062335401 at this location: osm.org/?mlat=51.15897&mlon=-3.32834#map=14/51.15897/-3.32834

This location looks to be in the middle of nowhere, and not consistent with the description you left of "the cart house West Lyng TA3 5AP".

Could you check the location, and correct it if it is wrong?

Many thanks,
Robert.

In the case of "Pauls Social Club", my tool show's a Circuit registered AED located at the nearby playground (blue circle), but not one mapped in OSM on the club building (red circle): https://osm.mathmos.net/defib/progress/IP/#18/52.04612/1.13942

From the description in the Circuit (click on the blue circle on the map) it would appear that this is a separate location to the AED mapped in OSM.

But the Circuit entries are registered by someone looking after each AED, so they almost certainly exist somewhere on the ground, although the locations can be a bit off. So if there isn't a second AED at the play area, it's likely the Circuit entry is the one at "Pauls Social Club", and who-ever registered it accepted an auto-generated description without checking it was accurate.

The tool I've developed at https://osm.mathmos.net/defib/progress to compare the Circuit data with that in OSM, is possibly outside the terms of use for the Circuit Data at https://www.bhf.org.uk/defibdata , so I've checked explicitly with the people from The Circuit that they're ok with me doing it. I also got specific permission for OSM editors to add the Circuit UUIDs to OSM. (Unless data is already licenced under an OSM-compatiable licence such permission would be needed to add any third-party data to OSM because of copyright/database rights.)

The permission I've got covers any OSM mappers adding the UUIDs to OSM, either by using my tool or downloading the data themselves.

The Circuit provides a monthly data download, and I've got permission from them to add the refs to OSM. I've built a tool to compare and match between the two datasets at https://osm.mathmos.net/defib/progress/ .

Hi JDunlop,

In this changeset you added a defibrillator using the "AED Map" app:
node/12772176801

The location description you gave it says "AED located outside newtons off licence". But you actually placed the AED about 25m away in the middle of a grassy area on the other side of a postbox.

Do you remember exactly where the AED is located here? Is it on the wall of the shop for example? Would you be able to provide a more detailed location description and/or update the location?

Many thanks,
Robert.

Hi Fmed,

In this changeset you added a Defibrillator using the "AED Map" app:
node/12152153401

The location description you gave it was "Baldock train station", but you seem to have placed the AED inside a neighbouring building rather than somewhere at the station.

Do you remember where the AED at the station is? Can you provide a more detailed description and/or improve the location accuracy?

Oops. Thanks for spotting that. It looks like a paste error in JOSM. Now fixed. The addr:postcode tag was the correct one.

Hi Simon,

In this changset, you edited the post box node/29160634 on Martyrs Field Road. But the comment says "Update Zealand Road postbox".

So I'm wondering if you accidentally changed the wrong object in OSM. Perhaps you intended to edit node/29160767 instead?

It looks like you used an AED Map App (proabably connected with https://openaedmap.org/ ) to add the AED to OpenStreetMap. I don't know if that app has the functionality to move an AED once it's been added.

But in any case, it seems you've deleted it from the incorrect location. So you can presumably now just add it back in the right place.

If you want more editing functionality, then look at the place you're interested in on OpenStreetMap, e.g. osm.org/#map=18/51.613951/0.541720 . Login if you're not already, and then click on the "Edit" button near the top left of the screen.

Hi Callum! In this changeset you added an AED node/12927995103 with the location description "AED on 3G Football Pitch".

However, the current location of the node on the map is in a residential garden on Charters Court. Could you have a look at repositioning it to be in the current location (presumably somewhere by the 3G pitch at Beauchamps High School. It would also be good if you could improve the description to provide details of exactly where it is relative to the pitch (inside/outside the fence, and maybe near a particular entrance).

Many thanks,
Robert.

I think I was intending to tag it as a shop selling office equipment. Is there a better tag for that?

Hi FeeHaw,

In this changeset you mapped this node node/11332743487 as a bank, with the name "Premiere ATM".

This seems odd. Is there really a bank with that name here? Or is it perhaps a "Premier" convenience store with an ATM outside it?

It's part of a JOSM workflow I use when editing *.osm files manually. JOSM will only upload objects it thinks has changed, and one was to mark the objects as changed is to make a change in JOSM. So I add "rjw:update" tags to the objects I want to edit, save the file as *.osm, manually edit it, reload it in JOSM, remove the "rjw:update" tags and then upload to OSM. I forgot to remove the tags this time.

Thanks for spotting it; I've now removed them all.

If you want any more tips nearby, then you might be interested in my tool at https://osm.mathmos.net/survey/#14/51.7528/-1.2853

Hi,

You added indoor=yes to the AED at node/8788255692 in this changeset.

Could you check if this was what you intended? The node contains the location description "On exterior wall of building..." which would suggest it's not indoors (or wasn't at the time it was mapped). If it is now indoors, then the description should be updated too.

Many thanks.

Ok, thanks. We can't use Google Maps or StreetView when contributing to OpenStreetMap, but the location in your link above, would put the AED on the church at way/1035602385 .

However your node as about 80m away next to a different building way/1035602358 .

Are you able to correct the location of node/12800322535 (without using Google StreetView)?

Now fixed, thanks. (It should have been amenity=veterinary.)

Hi Krewlex,

Could you check the location of the AED/Defib you added at node/12800322535 ?

You tagged it with defibrillator:location="Side-wall of church, next to notice board" but the actual location looks (from aerial imagery) to be next to a house, not a church.

Should the AED actually be located somewhere around here: osm.org/?mlat=51.358254&mlon=1.151161#map=19/51.358253/1.151161 ?

In this changeset you added an AED at node/12777792401 with the location description "on the wall bell inn pub Anslow". There's a "Bell Inn" pub mapped in the village at node/266229314 , but this is almost 1km SW from where you placed the AED. Are you sure you put the AED in the right location?

I know it was a while ago, but I'm a bit confused by the tagging changes that you applied to way/507336768 in this changeset. Do you remember what information you were trying to capture about the current use of the building?