OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
148395472 almost 2 years ago

do you mean Carretera de Aledo a Bullas?

Yes, is has changed and I changed it from the Karteview image of the connection to roundabout and added a fixme.

I have now changed it again to be closer to the Stave heatmap.

133806167 almost 2 years ago

Tak, jeg har slettet den.

145839065 almost 2 years ago

Hi, James
I now after some traveling got to read your GB discussions. and they seem to cover a lot of the issues, I have been considering.

holiday_park seems fine.

And I am Danish.

76021809 almost 2 years ago

you are right. I fixed it

143272629 almost 2 years ago

Laguna Playa Closed
does not look like a real name.
Is it closed, then it should be deleted.

55275254 almost 2 years ago

Det må være en fejl. Har slettet navnet.

146394761 almost 2 years ago

There are 5 real pitches for motorhomes. But then on Carrer de la Cerdanya there are 3 markings for larger vehicles. These are also used by motorhomes. I am not sure that these are officially for motorhomes. But there are some stopovers where you allowed to use neighbouring parking lots when the caravan_site is full. So that is kind of the opposite of reserved. I am open to suggestions for a better tag.

141464360 almost 2 years ago

I have changed it back to a caravan_site because motorhome parking is not camping and this is a motorhome stopover, se note #3893084

146121630 almost 2 years ago

sorry I made a huge are upload here.

145682589 almost 2 years ago

I updated the wiki.

145407338 almost 2 years ago

thank you, fixed it

145682589 almost 2 years ago

I have changed the one "no" to "none". And edited the wiki to clarify that it should be "none". We use the same for e.g., maxspeed.

145312016 almost 2 years ago

I do not use it as a source for edits. This was just one of several sites mentioning this motorhome/parking space. But when reading the comments on the net it is clear that it is not at at all a motorhome site. Thank you for checking it.

145312016 almost 2 years ago

https://www.aireparkreservation.com/aires-camping-cars/nouvelle-aquitaine/deux-sevres/niort-la-roussille indicates a caravan_site with power_supply at this location but after studying mapillary images I agree that there are no services here. In fact there is a motorhome on Mapillary but there are no signs or markings indicating a caravan_site. I am not sure this should be marked as a caravan_site at all. But I updated it to reflect that there are no services.

140400598 about 2 years ago

For motorhome/camping car sites we use the tourism=caravan_site tag. When like here it is only for camping cars, it should be tagged with caravans=no. I have updated the site.

144962202 about 2 years ago

Kind of.
But low_emission_zone is only used on boundaries.

This is a motorhome_stopover site that informs potential users that it is outside any LEZ.

Of course this would not be necessary if all LEZ were tagged in OSM and apps knew to infer this when searching for stopovers.

144981048 about 2 years ago

No it is not a description, it is a descriptive name.
And many names are descriptive and there is nothing wrong in that.

The eastern station in Berlin is called "Berlin Ostbahnhof" which is also descriptive.

As are for example "Kita an der Hochschule für Technik und Wirtschaft Berlin"
node/6123173591

New York have a long beach which is named "Long Beach".

Stratford-upon-Avon is also descriptive.

Historically that is how most things are named.

Motorhome stopovers are just not that old. But they still have names.

As for the local community, the Luneburger Heide company is an umbrella organization for local cities/counties so I think we can assume that the names are locally known. Besides motorhome stopovers are used by non-local travelers, so we should also consider which names they use. It is comparable to e.g., marinas. If you ask the locals living next to Margreheholms Havn in Copenhagen, most would not know the name. But sailors do. And we also name small harbours on uninhabited islands. And we name uninhabited islands. And there did OSM get all those names from?

As for licence, I see no issue at double checking a dozen names with brochures from a tourist agency owned by official local administrations.

And it is not the only site using that name. If you search for "Wohnmobilstellplatz am Strandbad Dorfmark" you find other sites using the name or longer versions. I just mentioned Lüneburger Heide GmbH because it is the most official source.

144966238 about 2 years ago

I do not invent names. It is a name used by Lüneburger Heide GmbH and many others. Sources given.

It is associated with Strandbad Dorfmark which do have a beach: way/720186763

See https://www.strandbad-dorfmark.de/

144755057 about 2 years ago

Yes, the wikimedia tag was wrong, fixed

144468418 about 2 years ago

Thx for fixing what I did with my frozen fingers here.