MxxCon's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 123385122 | over 3 years ago | Hello.
|
| 123334108 | over 3 years ago | As documented in osm.wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions the name tag should not be used as a description.
|
| 123289252 | over 3 years ago | You are doing great job figuring things out. ππ If you have Android phone, you could also install StreetComplete or Every Door apps to help fill in missing details while on-the-go. There's also Vespucci, which is more like iD for Android. iOS also has Every Door and Go Map!! is like iD.
|
| 123337025 | over 3 years ago | If you know other details like address, phone number, biz hours, website for this place, that would be useful. π
|
| 123334108 | over 3 years ago | Hello.
|
| 123297937 | over 3 years ago | Hello.
|
| 123296644 | over 3 years ago | Rather than deleting and re-drawing, it's generally best to modify/update existing feature. This way you are preserving history of that object if there's ever need to reference back to it. π
|
| 123289252 | over 3 years ago | These trees are already mapped as separate nodes. Mapping them also as a tree row way would be double-mapping and go against osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element |
| 123286538 | over 3 years ago | Should this be a park or perhaps place=square be more appropriate here? place=square
|
| 123283397 | over 3 years ago | You tagged both of these ways as having 8 lanes each(16 lanes total). On satellite imagery I counted 10 lanes. Map renderers that support displaying lanes will have this area showing a total mess. So either each lane needs to be mapped as a separate way or there should be only 1 way with the correct number for "lanes=" tag.
|
| 123283397 | over 3 years ago | You tagged both of these ways as having 8 lanes each(16 lanes total). On satellite imagery I counted 10 lanes. Map renderers that support displaying lanes will have this area showing a total mess. So either each lane needs to be mapped as a separate way or there should be only 1 way with the correct number for "lanes=" tag. |
| 123281159 | over 3 years ago | "url=" is an ambiguous tag with various meanings. Perhaps you meant "website=" tag? If so, then it's intended for official websites, not news paper articles.. I'll update it to https://www.zaqart.com/projects/reclining_liberty/reclining_liberty.html since that is the artist's website. π |
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | And no, not 3. All the ways that I listed above are either partially or completely DO NOT EXIST in the real world and do not belong in OSM |
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | 3 out of 30 that I looked at, out of 126 ways your changeset affected. 10% error rate in unacceptable in OSM. |
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | Having non-existing features in OSM purely so that you can have them in ORM is "tagging for a renderer" and that's wrong.
|
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | I wonder what's bigger vandalism and creates more damage to the map, removing disused and completely non-existing features or or creating fake features in the name of restoring deleted disused ones.π
|
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | For the 3rd time, you restored railroad tracks that have been completely removed with no traces left behind and new roads paved or buildings built over them. Why was that done? |
| 123215313 | over 3 years ago | Many that were deleted were completely removed with absolutely nothing left of them, with roads and buildings built on top since. Yet you restored them. |
| 123249235 | over 3 years ago | I updated it. You can see what I changed here https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=123281581 |
| 123249016 | over 3 years ago | If they alternate then perhaps delete the long way bench and map each one as separate node (not attached to the pathπ) and tag each one with appropriate material value. |