OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
122241419 over 3 years ago

Hello again @iriman, as you probably know, I'm local, I know this area, As a friendly reminder since I told you this weeks ago, please don't argue with local mappers in areas you're not familiar with, especially in another country like this case. :)
This is not your first to argue in subjects you know nothing about, don't take it negatively, but relax, grab a cold one, and see what is okay to map and what is not. Now let's get to your edits and what is wrong with them.
In the first link, you added a "monument", there is no monument. Then you added a POI named: "prophets Hood" (it should be spelled Hud btw), this location you marked as "prophets Hood" is just a regular place/building/masjid people use to pray when they visit the graves of loved ones in the area, people might call it that but it's incorrect. You can learn more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hud_(prophet)#Place_of_burial
In the 2nd link, you could've at least translated what the POI says... it's a maps(dot)me user added a "bank" with his grandpa's name, as a bookmark for the location of his grandpa's grave. If you're interested in his thing, you should've at least commented on his changeset and show him how to save the private points as a bookmark in his app not to upload it to OSM, also I believe you should probably read this: osm.wiki/MAPS.ME/Questionable_OSM_Edits
Regards.

122241419 over 3 years ago

Hello @iriman, as described in the changeset comment. Regards.

122193873 over 3 years ago

miroslavuzice87, Do not merge or delete roads without looking at road names or at least the sat images, you deleted the residential road 340-4 (way/4324083) and extended an unnamed road in its place, please don't delete road numbers, in Iraq the address is kinda different from the rest of the world as we use numbers as the name of residential streets, some streets might have a number for a half and a different number for the other half, this is normal cause this street may be in 2 districts and each district give the street its unique number for the street name, etc.
Also, why did you disconnect (Way: 768423530)? it's clearly showing a connected road in all aerial imagery available, please be careful next time.
I reverted part of this changeset in changeset/122205164.
Regards...
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/122193873

122140080 over 3 years ago

source=https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/القصبة_(الأحواز)

122137149 over 3 years ago

Wrong, deleting the name:ar is kinda vandalism because the name indeed reflects the correct name,
The Arabic name for the town is "القصبة" this is what the Arabs call it, Some Arabs call it "قصبة الفیحاء" like to glorify it, etc.
The northern part of the town is called "قصبة النصار", the southern part of the town is called "قصبة المعمرة" and all the town is called "القصبة" according to the local Arabs in this town and the Arabs in all Ahwaz region, also in nearby Iraq who speaks Arabic too.

This changeset was reverted in changeset/122139761 where the changeset comment is "revert changeset/122137149, restore the name:ar tag"
Regards.

121728912 over 3 years ago

This changeset had been reverted fully or in part in changeset/121786223 where the changeset comment was "Revert vandalism in changeset/121639845 restore the disputed areas in the Arabian Gulf region"

121639845 over 3 years ago

This changeset had been reverted fully or in part in changeset/121786223 where the changeset comment was "Revert vandalism in changeset/121639845 restore the disputed areas in the Arabian Gulf region"

121643546 over 3 years ago

Perfect! Thank you!

121470968 over 3 years ago

You welcome! and yes, the correct way to say the name in Arabic is with the letter "ص" not "س".
I'll give you few examples, search the page for "جزيرة صري" and you will see how they were written.
1-National Assembly: http://www.kna.kw/clt-html5/run.asp?id=726#:~:text=الوقت%20نفسه%20يطالب-,بجزيرة%20صري,-بالرغم%20من%20أن
2-Wikipedia: https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/جزيرة_أبو_موسى#:~:text=تفرط%20بعروبة%20جزيرة-,صري,-التابعة%20للشارقة%20والتي
3-Dr. Abdulla AlShammary: https://twitter.com/jalarb/status/977207875801055233
4-http://arabalsahel.com/vb/showthread.php?167-%C3%CD%E6%C7%E1-%CC%D2%ED%D1%C9-%D5%D1%F8%ED-%DE%C8%E1-100-%DA%C7%E3
Or you can just google it :)

121470968 over 3 years ago

Hello iriman, I added wikidata, wikipedia, added the English name and corrected the Arabic name. What do you need a source for exactly? or to be exact what is your complain?

121371902 over 3 years ago

Dear Rebeen, names should be in local language not English. English is not the local language of Iraq.

121056098 over 3 years ago

Village restored.

121056098 over 3 years ago

Najm Abbud village is an actual village in this area. Please if you're not familiar with this area or Iraq in general, don't remove things you are not familiar with. This is not your first deletion of stuff in Iraq, as you previously deleted all road numbers in Baghdad and said the exact same thing "there is no" etc.. and when the mappers provided sources and proven that you deleted valid data, you ignored and ghosted them and did not restore what you deleted when you've been asked. So please revert your actions, and don't delete stuff you're not familiar with. Thanks and take care.

121056098 over 3 years ago

Why did you delete the village of Najm Abbud?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/121056098

121077077 over 3 years ago

I guess you're talking about this: way/284426719 which was added in changeset changeset/22563278

121077077 over 3 years ago

I noticed that few years ago, I guess it’s underground abandoned track. Not sure. You can comment on his changeset when he added it and ask him about sources or infos.

120178712 over 3 years ago

Hello Msalmanq, you changed the road name to a wrong name, the street name is "شارع غازي" it is the current and official name.
Source: https://www.amanatbaghdad.gov.iq/admin/uploads/7545960384-6f1e86048ae5b44f30f6be5546120d35.jpg
From: https://amanatbaghdad.gov.iq/page.php?link=Rusafa%20municipality&lang=ar
No worries, I'll fix it.
Best regards.

120723210 over 3 years ago

Sorry wrong changeset comment,

changeset comment: clean up, revert and delete spam, low quality, duplicated nodes, private maps-me bookmarks, and fake names/not accurate edits.

120715186 over 3 years ago

I'm not arguing this or fix it again, anyway, you welcome.
Also consider editing with JOSM, it will show you the errors you make.
Also, osmbuildings.org
Best Regards.

120715186 over 3 years ago

Here you go: https://i.ibb.co/nsnjLDQ/JOSM-SCREENSHOT.png
I fixed those errors and warnings in changeset/120710442 , please fix your errors, thanks.