OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
142294977 about 2 years ago

Renas, Please do not change the boundaries again to boundaries in Iraq that are not official and approved by the Iraqi government.
You here included parts of Nineveh Governorate to be parts of the Kurdish region which is wrong, for example, Faidah is not part of the Kurdish region, and it is officially part of Nineveh Governorate, read here: https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/فايدة
The last elections in 2017 it was part of the Nineveh Governorate elections, search here for "فايدة" and see: https://ihec.iq/constituencies/ and https://ihec.iq/13743-2/
The source you included here is not correct, it is not "administrative boundaries" as the link says, administrative means it is under administrative control, and those parts are not. For example, the biggest district on the map that is wrong is Makhmur, in your map it's part of the Kurdish region, but it's not under the administrative control of the Kurdish region since 2017, as you know in October 2017 the Iraqi government linked Makhmur as part of Nineveh Governorate and it's under the control and the administration of Nineveh Governorate since that date.
If you want to map disputed boundaries between the governorates you can map them as disputed only.
If you want to discuss this, please discuss it with the Iraqi community here there is 160 Iraqi mapper to discuss it with: https://t.me/OSM_Iraq
Regards.

142304522 about 2 years ago

The other node I delete was on a street that already has a name.

142294977 about 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted by changeset/142302684 and the changeset comment is: Revert changeset/142295047 and 142294977 when a user fiddle with the boundaries in Iraq and change them to an unofficial/wrong boundaries that are not official by the Iraqi government. Please do not change official boundaries by the Iraqi government to disputed ones that is not official or approved by the gov.

142276199 about 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted by changeset/142288353 and the changeset comment is: Revert changeset/142276664, 142276356 and 142276199 when a user fiddle with the boundaries in Iraq and change them to an unofficial/wrong boundaries that are not official by the Iraqi government.

142276356 about 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted by changeset/142288353 and the changeset comment is: Revert changeset/142276664, 142276356 and 142276199 when a user fiddle with the boundaries in Iraq and change them to an unofficial/wrong boundaries that are not official by the Iraqi government.

142276664 about 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted by changeset/142288353 and the changeset comment is: Revert changeset/142276664, 142276356 and 142276199 when a user fiddle with the boundaries in Iraq and change them to an unofficial/wrong boundaries that are not official by the Iraqi government.

142166691 about 2 years ago

Can you specify the source please? Like survey you saw it? Or someone on some social media app? Please provide the source for name changes so we know if this is ok or not ok to use..
regards.

142166691 about 2 years ago

Hello again ,
I see you changed the name of node/4486255700 here, but the name you changed it into is not on the hotel, see: http://bot.gov.krd/sites/default/files/accuImages/725.jpg
What is your source for this change?
Regards.

142163829 about 2 years ago

Hi ڕاستی, I see you deleted name:fr here in this changeset and said that's because it's not on street sign, and yes it's correct because the language on the street signs in Erbil is Kurdish, Arabic and English, so that would be name:ckb, name:ar and name:en, but why you add name:ku and name:sdh while it's not on the street signs? You just did that in changeset/142163972
You also added those two tags name:ku and name:sdh in top of name:ckb to some of Baghdad Streets that don't have these languages.
What do you suggest? Remove all names in languages that is not on the street signs in Iraq?
Regards.

141996224 about 2 years ago

It’s the name on the sign, the branch address and details should be in addr and description tag.
The name on the sign should be the name on ‘name’ tag.
What’s about my question that I asked above? What about the pharmacy?
If you can’t provide a source for the name or specify your source for the name change I will restore the old ‘name’ that you changed.
Regards.

141996224 about 2 years ago

Thank you, but the link you share for the ice cream shop do not match the name you put as 'name'
You used
name=شیرینەمەنی و ساردەمەنی مەڵتی فروتی ٦
And that doesn't match the shop sign shown in the video, the name should be
name=گروپی مەڵتی فروتی
to match name on the store sign.
Please, don't translate names like that, and use the actual names on the sign instead.

Also, what was the source for the pharmacy name change?
node/6419370285/history
is it this one?
https://i.ibb.co/B3SpjFb/erbilph-1281.jpg
Or do you have a different pic?

Regards.

141996224 about 2 years ago

I asked you 2 questions, the reason, and the source.
What was your source for the change? did you actually survey and saw the name?
I'm asking this because you previously changed names of business and even some changeset have "survey" in the source but the name you change into do not match the name on the sign and the previous one was the correct, example: changeset/139192329
So please, what is your sources for the name change here? did you actually survey it? or did you just translate the name?
Regards.

141934037 about 2 years ago

Ok I just changed the 'name' back to match the name on the sign in changeset/142156445. I gave you a chance to revert your edit yourself.
And please reply to the tens of comments I have left on your changesets, see: https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=4800812
Regards.

142134837 about 2 years ago

Hello little_maper, Why did you split the way 315-23 into two? it's one way but with a block in the middle so it should not be split, it should be linked as one with a block node where the block is.
What do you think?
Regards.

141934037 about 2 years ago

Did you saw the pictures I shared in my first comment in this changeset?
You can’t change ‘name’ tag from the one in the sign to one that is not on the sign. ‘name’ should always be the one on the sign doesn’t matter what language it is, and you can’t change it to one that is not on the sign.
Regards.

141934037 about 2 years ago

No, 'name' tag should be the one on the sign, as is. Doesn't matter what language it is. If it has 2 language, we take the local one yes, but if it's only in English, 'name' should be in English.
Please don't translate names like that, use the names on the ground as the "name" tag.
Would you please revert your edit and bring back the original 'name' to match the name on the sign?
Regards.

141996224 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی,

I see you edited node/5318704122 in this changeset, and this node had an Arabic name that you removed previously in v3. since it's a valid name, Can you restore it?
node/5318704122/history

Also, what is the source for the name change in node/6419370285?
node/6419370285/history

Regards.

141871937 over 2 years ago

@Lamassu I have reverted some of his changeset in changeset/141948656 to restore the correct admin boundaries and relations.
Regards.

141939776 over 2 years ago

Source for the name change? we know this street by the name AlMutaz street and it is the official name on government signs and paperwork..

141361896 over 2 years ago

I shopped from multiple Teammart before, not only a specific one.
Did you actually survey on the ground and asked Teammart?