OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
139681502 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, I see you deleted node/11065547287 in this changeset and it's not duplicated or mapped. This node is for Carrefour convenience store which is located inside the mall.
Can you check and undelete node/11065547287?
If you don't know how to undelete objects let me know please and I will be happy to restore it back.
Waiting for your answer.
Regards.

139680587 over 2 years ago

In top of that, you keep deleting "addr:postcode=44001" Which I told you many many times before to not delete but you ignore and keep delete, in this changeset you deleted it from: "way/607896551, node/4432459696, node/5861874986" please stop, as deleting valid postal code is vandalism.
Can you restore these ones and the ones you deleted previously?

139680587 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی,
I see you removed node/11065547253, that has an Arabic name in 'name' tag, and renamed way/887311316 which is the same market but mapped in Kurdish to another name in kurdish, and you moved the old name from way/887311316 and added it as "name:ar" while it's kurdish not Arabic, you should've added the correct Arabic name from the node you deleted, not a kurdish name. The tag name:ar means Name in Arabic, and it should have Arabic names in Arabic script not Kurdish, Can you please fix this issues and add the correct Arabic name from the supermarket node you removed to the supermarket way?
Regards.

139665486 over 2 years ago

Please do not map temporary tents/objects in the map that only be here 1 week a year.
Read: osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_temporary_events_and_temporary_features
This changeset has been reverted by changeset/139674333.
Regards.

139606876 over 2 years ago

Oh yeah thats the operator, no problem if you can’t find the name in any other official language you can copy it to main one too instead of leaving main name empty

139606876 over 2 years ago

The node above you moved the name to name:en in v2 and left the main name empty then added name:ckb in v3 in this changeset. Copy name:ckb and put it in name too.

139606876 over 2 years ago

Yes, the node/9052779397, please take a look, thanks.

139606876 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, in this changeset you deleted 'name' from node/9052779397 the college, can you please check and add it back?
Regards.

135202244 over 2 years ago

Hi, Why did you delete NODE: 9171225018? And also please use good changeset comment next time.

139577660 over 2 years ago

Hi, What is your source? and also please use good changeset comment so people can understand what you edited in the map. Regards.

139317960 over 2 years ago

Why did you change the names? You even changed the name:ar to Kurdish which is wrong! I will fix this, please do not remove Arabic names like this. Regards.

139494136 over 2 years ago

Thank you, my pleasure :)
Keep up the good work guys :D

139497443 over 2 years ago

Hello ahmad 69, And welcome to OSM!
May I ask what is the reason for deleting this node? node/9051643062/history
If it was by a mistake please let me know so I can undelete it.
Also, one more thing, please explain in the changeset comment what did you edit and why, so the mappers understand what your edit is about.
Best Regards.

139494136 over 2 years ago

Thank you, it's really my pleasure. :)

139494136 over 2 years ago

Thank you, my pleasure! glad to help :)

139495025 over 2 years ago

It's my duty, my pleasure,
Thank you for your edits here and keep up the great work of yours in this area and happy mapping! :)

139252965 over 2 years ago

@ChehrehBargi, Again,
1- If you add temporary objects, they will be removed, and yes, 1 week a year is considered temporary, read here: osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_map_temporary_events_and_temporary_features
2- If you add names in a language that are not on the ground in a sign it should be removed especially if it's not local and translated by 3rd party services.
3- If you map anything not on the ground in reality, like inscriptions, monuments, and others, and you assume is this fine, even with good faith, it will be removed as it's considered as fictional mapping.
Bye.

139252965 over 2 years ago

@ChehrehBargi The article I linked explains such things will lead to such events, and might get hundreds of people killed and tens of thousands injured. You added a grave of an Iranian general as a monument and said previously "they are brave like general xxx" and General xxx is on the international terrorist list in the US and EU! and fought against Iraq in the war and killed the protesters in the protest I linked above, and they burned their the general's photos. And even if we looked away from all of that chaos, you added such thing as a "monument" which is not, you added "inscription" which is not on the ground, and this considers as fictional mapping that we should always remove.
The same goes for the translated names you added for POI, if it's not there, it should not be up, and especially the names that are translated with 3rd party translators are forbidden entirely.
As I told you last year, you shall not add temporary objects period! Imaging I did not delete the temporary resting tents you added and someone used navigation apps that use OSM data to find some place to rest, he will go there and see nothing! just an empty road! this is not acceptable. And even let's say the objects you still want to add are not just tents, it's still and closed the whole year, and only open in one week in the year, So, it is temporary, and if it's a building, it should be mapped as building=yes only without the rest area tags as it's not for resting for the whole year due to it being closed for the whole year except 1 week.
Same scenario for the poles, let's say someone driving on the road and his car broke down in the desert, do you want him to give fake numbers on the navigation map he uses that were up as guide posts for the one-week event in the year or go to the pole and see the actual correct number on the plate cover to know how far he is in kilometers away from the city?
Regarding the grave you added as a monument in this changeset, you did not answer my questions, is it really a monument? Show us how different it is from the other 6 million graves in the cemetery.
Again, we map only what is on the ground, and should not use translated names not on the ground. And should not map temporary objects like festive season POIs.
I really hope you understand this.
Regards.

139252965 over 2 years ago

Also, something to add, @ChehrehBargi, in this changeset you added Way: 1193549241, which is this I believe: https://i.ibb.co/48xNMsZ/image.png is this really a "historic=monument"? And what's the difference between it and the other 6 millions in this cemetery?
Also you added "inscription" where is this inscription?
What you did is considered as fictional mapping.

139252965 over 2 years ago

@SomeoneElse, you said "but is any information to support any of what you've said available in public?
The protests: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932021_Iraqi_protests
The quotes from you: https://t.me/OpenStreetMapOrg
Andy reverted all of the changesets by problematic mappers in subject area: changeset/124425633
Sören Authorized OSM Iraq: https://t.me/OSM_Iraq/184
And, you blocked me for deleting this: https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/966067085 Which you should know it's not a local or on signs as we don't have such language in Iraq and the user said above it's translated. And you looked away from deleting the "religion" tag from https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/1097262196 which is definitely a vandal. DWG should always be neutral.
Regards.


@ChehrehBargi, You mentioned "electric light poles", yes I do remember you adding wrong numbers as electric light poles numbers and I and other mappers told you that Electrict light poles do not has the type of numbering that you added, and the numbering of the electric light poles outside the cities are made by the distance example "kilo 14" or "kilo 136" etc. which that mean it's 136 kilometers from the city gate. Keep in mind some of the electric light poles that are now inside the city still has these numbers as the city got bigger and these numbers are measured from the original city arch gates.
You added objects that were temporary for only 1 week a year and is not gurnteed to be at the same exact location the next year, like the resting tents in the streets, You know this very well and I gave you the osm wiki link that say we shall not add temp objects, but you kept arguing to have them in.
Again ChehrehBargi, please do not add names that are not local or on the ground.
You said "It is true that respected users from Iraq sent me messages. After talking with them, we decided not to discuss with you any more. And my work was not wrong." you are making this sound like Iraqis agreed with you on something, while infact they told you to not map like this, I believe Nawfal is the one you are referring to, while Nawfal just replied to my message few days ago and agreeing to remove your edits and told me good job after I reverted your edits and stated it in our Public OSM Iraq group which you can go and see.
Regards.