OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
140036828 over 2 years ago

I also see that you deleted lots of manholes before, for example in changeset/130013231:
node/6723137085/history
node/6721742185/history
node/6790254785/history
node/6721742086/history
node/6721742186/history
node/6721742287/history
node/6724487386/history
node/6721742289/history
node/6698971389/history
node/6721742096/history
node/6721742095/history
node/6721742097/history
node/6721742098/history
node/6721742099/history
etc..
And in changeset/6721742093:
node/6721742093/history
node/6779123786/history
node/6779131287/history
etc..
And in changeset/129971335:
node/6721742092/history
And node/6721742091/history
...
And many other changesets.
Can you please explain why you keep deleting them?

140036828 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, In this changeset you have deleted 15 manholes. example: node/6721742085/history, and node/6721742085/history Why did you remove them?
I also see you changed the name of a roundabout way/890768441, what is your source for this? as there was 2 nodes on that roundabout, node/10980156210 and node/6909958685 that stated the name in Arabic, Kurdish, and English and they are different from the one used when you made the roundabout a new Kurdish only name. If those names on the nodes are local names, then please do not remove them entirely, it should be in loc_name instead.
Regards.

140037499 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, In this changeset, you removed the names from a way/229481943 and moved them to node/8395186468, this is OK, but moving English and Kurdish names only without the name:ar is not OK, by this you have removed the name:ar of that neighborhood entirely from OSM. Can you please restore it?
I also see you have edited relation/6585775 in this changeset. You previously edited the name:ar from Arabic to kurdish then deleted the correct and vaild name:ar of that relation, can please restore it?
Also, the name and name:ckb you are adding for streets are not matching, please match them and the alternative one should be in alt_name.
Regards.

139677312 over 2 years ago

Hello, Thank you for providing a picture. Have you ring in and ask them if they still have an office in this building still or moved to Al-Sulaymaniyah? If not, I will give them a call to confirm and act accordingly. Regards.

139677312 over 2 years ago

Simply, I restored valid data you removed that can be verified by wiki. You deleted the data, you the one who should provide source. Example a picture of the building at least. Regards..

139740388 over 2 years ago

Dear friend, OSM is not a historic map, and if something not on the ground today, we can not map it.
If you meant like this area is known by this name because of that historical name, I believe a better tag would be place=city_block maybe
Regards.

139494136 over 2 years ago

Hi SomeoneElse, I will be glad to provide some "photographic evidence", here is some:

This way: way/4234602
and this picture is the sign from the highway turning right (north):
https://ultrairaq.ultrasawt.com/sites/default/files/2022-06/شارع%20بغداد%20مرور.jpg
And for the same street but from the other end: https://www.nasnews.com/news/09619acbb-94786-202209290319.jpg

Here is another example, way: way/4243139
Street sign of that way: https://i.ibb.co/2dKFVN2/image.png

And this way: way/407180933
pic: https://i.ibb.co/vZXhxwQ/image.png

For this way: way/870540494
Pic: https://www.nasnews.com/news/202208/6259d9903-27776-202208160142.jpg

You encouraged me to remove translated names previously, as you said translations do not belong in OSM, and I took your words for granted. All of the names I removed are translations that are not on the ground, and most of them were added by a foreign team called "Neshan".

Regards.

139830631 over 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted fully by changeset/139849926 and the changeset comment is: Revert a revert changeset when a user reverted my revert without local knowledge. This node is spam and there is no hotel here. Source=survey.

139771270 over 2 years ago

Thank you, I saw his other reverts and it’s very suspicious. New account and only reverts with revert ui.
Again, thank you so much dear. And keep up the good work!

139771270 over 2 years ago

Oh maybe that’s not your account and you’re warning me, if so, thank you so much! I appreciate it. I have commented on the changeset: changeset/139830631
Best Regards.

139830631 over 2 years ago

I removed this this because there is no hotel here, I have survived the location.
What is your source to revert my changeset?

139771270 over 2 years ago

Why did you revert it?

139740388 over 2 years ago

Hi, Can you describe what this thing is? Regards.

139646946 over 2 years ago

Hello, I previously asked you in changeset/139344195 to provide a street sign that shows the name you added in 'name' is the main one, you ignored my comment, or maybe did not read it? Anyway here I am asking again, can you please provide a source?
If not, we have to revert this. As far as I've seen the street signs in Kirkuk, most of them are just Arabic and English, and last year in January Kirkuk Municipality hang new street signs that only have 2 languages, Arabic and English then in August they start to hang new street signs in 4 languages (Arabic, English, Kurdish, And Turkmen) and the main bigger one at top is Arabic, and later the same month the same municipality agreed to add a 5th language wich is Syriac. If this road is no exception and has a street sign that is not different from the rest of the city then we have to revert this and use only the main name on the actual street sign. So please provide a street sign that shows how the name is written.
Regards.

139677312 over 2 years ago

Forgot to mention the changeset number, I fixed this issue in changeset/139717370.
Regards.

139677312 over 2 years ago

There were 2 nodes, mapped as "Islamic Kurdish League" you removed one and changed the other's name. Now by this, you removed the "Islamic Kurdish League" entirely now.
you said "Second it is not about deleting Arabic name from the first node, I added the correct Arabic name." No, you deleted it entirely in v2 here: node/6744963986/history and changed it only to kurdish while the name in the logo in Arabic is correct, see: https://www.kurdipedia.org/files/photos/2010/4679.JPG, this is just like the hundreds and thousands of nodes you changed and removed Arabic names entirely. This is not or discussion now, now I'm talking about removing such party entirely from OSM while it still under operation, and it did not change name as you stated.
Islamic Kurdish League or the Kurdish Islamic Union, whatever it's called, they established the Humanitarian Rabite Organization, which share the same address and office, therefore, you should have not deleted the union. You mentioned in the wiki it say "currently known as" but this doesn't mean they changed their name, it mean they are operate in the NGO name, and their original name is still regesterd in the goverment. Just like the United Nation and UNICEF for example.
Now, I have corrected this edit in changeset , I undeleted the node/6744963985 and added the "Islamic Kurdish League" wiki links to it, and changed the wiki tags in node/6744963986 from "Islamic Kurdish League" that you added to "Humanitarian League Organization" to match the ngo.
At least, you stated "And one thing before rating any changeset first wait to answer then rate it." I find this very ironic from you to say such thing giving the fact you did exactly this many times, like when I removed fake buildings and roads numbers and you know this very good that they are fake and you added the correct numbers after me, and still rated the changeset as bad, very ironic.

139681502 over 2 years ago

Hi, before removing you should've moved the Arabic name to the node that you say it's duplicate with, not remove the node entirely.
The name says "Carrefour tablue mall - Kirkuk Street" just take the name of the store and add it to the other one instead of deleting it. having "kirkuk street" in the name is not an excuse to not add it to the other one, you could've just take the name without the word "kirkuk street"
You sated "this type of edit must be deleted no matter what is the language." NO! it's valid data, and clear, and it should be improved and corrected not deleted!
Please in future if you see something for example a shop with "John's electronics in 143 main street" just remove the street from the name and keep the store name, do not delete it entirely...
I've checked with the store website and this place do exist in fact in this location and there website.
Also, please reply to the tens of comments I left you on your changesets here:
https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=4800812
Regards.

139653505 over 2 years ago

Edit: I meant that *has* 2 layers, not had as the bridge still 2 layers, but mistyped the word has as had.

139653505 over 2 years ago

Hi all, few notes to mention for clarification,

Names in Arabic and Kurdish are usually typed differently even for names, For example, in way/1025102184, Andy stated in a note "language is unclear as it is a person's name". It's very clear that the name is in Arabic, the name is "اسماعيل", and in Kurdish, it's "ئیسماعیلی" or sometimes "ئیسماعیل". example: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q123088

name:ar in way/1025102182 is Kurdish, I suggest removing the Kurdish word "پێشانگای" from "پێشانگای الكويت" and keeping it only "الكويت", as there is no need to describe what this thing is in the name, like if we map "Johnson Dealership" for example, we map it as "name:Johnson" and "shop=car", even if sometimes the word "Dealership" exist, it's not the name of the dealership, it only explains what this building is.

Andy stated, "which is clearly a different location!" in the comments here regarding the Kuwait company. I assume Andy stated that after seeing the street address on those links says "100m Road" and the dealership in OpenStreetMap is on "Peshawa Qazi Street". They are both the same street, "100-meter street" is the most common name by the people, and "Peshawa Qazi Street" is the official one but not the common way to mention that road in reality, example if you ask any Iraqi from the north to the south where is "100meter road" translate to "طريق 100 متر" he will say it's in Erbil, and if you ask where is "Peshawa Qazi Street"? they will say "Huh?" or "I don't know", So the company, of course, gonna use the most known name so people can find them easily and sell stuff.

About the "Pont Neuf" example, this usually does not apply in Iraq unfortunately. For example, in Baghdad, "الجسر ذو الطابقين" which is a bridge that had 2 layers each for a passive way, I've seen a street sign with my eyes in Al-Jadriyah that says "Two Stories Bridge" with a directional arrow instead of "Du Tabaqeen Bridge", same for "جسر الجمهورية" now for example if you search "جسر الجمهورية" on google search it will show you "Republic Bridge" not "Al Jumhuriya bridge".

I hope this will help.
Thank you and best regards.

139677312 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, In this changeset you edited 2 nodes,
node/6744963985, that had Arabic name
And node/6744963986 that had Kurdish name for the same organization.
You deleted the first node with the Arabic text, and edited the 2nd.
The organization name is that has Kurdish name, it was also in Arabic before but you removed it entirely in v2 though.
The problem is, in this changeset I'm making a comment on here, you renamed it from "Islamic Kurdish League" to "Humanitarian League Organization" and added the wikipedia as "Islamic Kurdish League" which is a conflict, What is going on?
Can you please explain?
Thank you and regards.