OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
121609483 over 3 years ago

1. Why is it not good? If the foliage does extend over the road, drawing across
2. Common misunderstanding there. `natural=wood` does not mean it is "natural" in origin. It means the trees part of nature, like `natural=water`. I have already added `managed=yes`, and `moved=yes` or `anthropogenic=yes` are possible theoretically, but not unless you know the actual history of these trees. If they are trees, they are woodland.

121609483 over 3 years ago

`=tree_row` is not a replacement for `=wood` areas. (rather it is widely considered the latter is preferred, which I don't take a position here)
You haven't replicated trees in the park, and foilage inside Tsing Yi Estate.

121609483 over 3 years ago

What do you mean by "not presented correctly"? Fix their shape. You deleting them straight out is very "rude" to other's effort as well.

121609483 over 3 years ago

This is not about `=shrubbery`, You are removing the `=wood` that actually exists there. `=hedge` and `=tree_row` are not relevant to this.

121568393 over 3 years ago

Not sure if a `place=farm` should get `tourism=zoo` simply because it raises animals.

121550877 over 3 years ago

Frontage road should not be `=service` simply because they are called "service roads".

121600680 over 3 years ago

Please don't delete tree areas.

120092258 over 3 years ago

No brackets as descriptor labels please. OSM is not a printed map. `name=` is for proper names only.

121502928 over 3 years ago

Please don't change `area:highway=footway` to `highway=pedestrian` + `area=yes` for the sake of making it displayed. They have different meaning. Tagging For Renderer is a bad practice.

121536717 over 3 years ago

No, this is not redundant. `leisure=garden` shows the area is a garden. It doesn't say when green coverage exists there. `natural=` adds the exact shape of the specific landscaping.

117427344 over 3 years ago

Please don't attach areas to roads.

121478834 over 3 years ago

Thx, but it's better to keep both together.

121358429 over 3 years ago

Please don't blindly upgrade tags. There were some nonsense case before eg `network:en=Hong Kong Metro` a clear mistake.

121358429 over 3 years ago

Can you please stop changing HK Tramway Ltd to RATP?

121307070 over 3 years ago

Please be careful not to change the entire building.

121302934 over 3 years ago

What is this trying to do?

121184935 over 3 years ago

Please split the tree area, not deleting the whole thing.

121173005 over 3 years ago

There is already a `motor_vehicle=permit` here though?

121123831 over 3 years ago

This is `route=railway`, not `route=tracks`. I meant MOL is included the ERL system alongside EAL. Though not sure how things are organized now. Conceptually the TML service can still be seen to run through West Rail and Ma On Shan Rail.

121044312 over 3 years ago

Some turn restriction you added duplicates existing ones.