OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
158545730 about 1 year ago

Please don't upload personal edits to a live public database. This is vandalism. I only see you mass deleting features that shouldn't be removed, and you should still change stores to a plain "point" when they change hands..

158546331 about 1 year ago

1. Or you can try to reply, instead of using upload comment as your personal announcements?
2. And why not use `=track` ?
3. `=pedestrian` has been used across HK. Given the lack of `=track` in HK (many existing are also misuse from the "single-track access road term, which should be `=unclassified` , `=residential` , and `=service` ) , it's unclear how it should be used. `=pedestrian` fit the mainly pedestrian use definition, connects between `=service` , and ties with actual park EVA.

158132742 about 1 year ago

Actually it's only the site branch. The office itself is still in the Goverment Office.

158132742 about 1 year ago

It depends on your definition. The magistracy may be only one of the tenants. SWD has a Probation and Community Service Order Office inside. They aren't always inside a court building either.
(Note a court building can also contain multiple different courts and tribunals)

158132742 about 1 year ago

Don't simply combine them. The building and site is really called Tuen Mun Law Court Building.

158122161 about 1 year ago

It was changed away from `=service` for good reasons. `=service` is an internal serving a facility. At most, it's better used for the specific road connecting a facility and the main road. `=pedestrian` means pedestrian is the main user, but `motor_vehicle=` can be allowed in limited capacity. You should only argue about using `=track` road.

158113582 about 1 year ago

A `=service` road has been deleted without even replacing it. Please don't upload incomplete edits.

158113368 about 1 year ago

1. Please don't delete & redraw. This makes tracking changes more difficult. Simply move them to the correct position.
2. You removed the concave part detail on the south side of blocks 2 to 5
3. `=living_street` means a signposted legally pedestrian priority road, not any road

158073852 about 1 year ago

1. You are adding `amenity=police` to the `building=` and `building:part=` ie creating `amenity=fire_station` in every `building=` `building:part=` inside again, not changing what `building=` they are
2. `building=` is a structural form, not only function. `=office` already adequately presents it. There is already a spatial relationship, where you can get all `building=` inside a `amenity=police` area to know they are police buildings. `building=fire_station` is unique and recognizable, with fire trucks below the quarters.
In any case, creating duplicate `amenity=police` station is absolutely wrong. It doesn't solve your problem.

158073852 about 1 year ago

3. Each unit doesn't occupy the entire `building=` or `building:part=` . They shouldn't be added to the entire area.

158044849 about 1 year ago

Please don't apply `building=` to land-only areas

158073852 about 1 year ago

1. Please don't add duplicate `amenity=police` . There should only be 1 for each police station. This is Tagging For Renderer, Application, or Editor.
2. Please don't change `building:part=` to `building=`

158074270 about 1 year ago

Please don't add duplicate `amenity=police`

157885753 about 1 year ago

The problem is they are basically only handling `operator=` now, not `owner=` . So the acceptance is uncertain. OSM is usually quite cautious and suspicious towards `owner=` .
Some people can argue HKHA is the direct `operator=` , with HD behind that should be interpreted from `*:wikidata=` etc if needed. It may also be argued the managing company contracted is the `operator=` . So it's not immediately obvious and straightforward.

157911485 about 1 year ago

Please don't delete things you don't understand yet. They need to be reformed into `building:part=` properly.

157885753 about 1 year ago

That seems to be a misunderstanding. At least in this case, it will only be suggested when the `operator=` contains it. So it's only being formatted.
Ultimately, it's only a suggestion. You are responsible for accepting it. When there's already something better, it should be rejected.

157885753 about 1 year ago

Please don't change Housing Department to HKHA. That's the actual agent, more accurate, and has been used by some.

157886142 about 1 year ago

As mentioned before, please don't blindly add HA as `operator=` of HOS. They are no longer owners after being sold, nor usually the management.

157991645 about 1 year ago

Please don't Edit For Application. It's the responsibility of apps to handle controls, categories, and discoverability.

157846456 about 1 year ago

A related issue is how `name:zh-Hans=`, and `name:zh-Hant=` , etc is often added. That's the amount of permutation/combination on the extra work, for `name:yue-Hant=` etc. So the effect of all these needs to be considered.