OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
144373262 about 2 years ago

Park warden may be translated as ranger as well. So at least in formalities, they are the equivalence.

144373262 about 2 years ago

Please don't use upload comments for public messaging or discussion.
They are originally `=farmyard` , while obviously unrelated to farms. This is also not an `office=` , because they don't really work there to provide services in the tertiary sector sense.
Country park management centers are stationed by wildfire crew. Park warden patrols, and take law enforcement on illegal activities eg hunting. The English of the related "護理科" department inside that can be headquartered at mangement centers is translated as "Ranger Service" and "Ranger Office".
The key point about `=ranger_station` from the US is they do policing. It was originally misusing `=police` . osm.wiki/Proposal:Tag:amenity=ranger_station
For public services, visitor permits are not applicable, But vehicles can be controlled by them
Visitor service can in fact be shown be `tourism=information` + `information=centre` . This was not fully considered.
If non-public facing is argued, following `police=` it might use eg `ranger=` similar to osm.wiki/Proposal:Fire_service for `=fire_station` . But it is also debatable whether the US definition of a `=ranger_station` should be applied worldwide.

144276379 about 2 years ago

Please don't blindly merge different sections. The sidewalk ends at the off-slip bridge.

144275782 about 2 years ago

It represents a shop space. It should be updated to what is now. Otherwise it is impossible to understand what refers to what if people create new objects imprecisely and without details. You are "lucky" this doesn't have an address

143600809 about 2 years ago

Please don't blindly do corrections. The area tags on a linear `outer` should be removed.

144110891 about 2 years ago

Turns out I forgot to remove these tags. And someone else wrongly fixed them.

144110891 about 2 years ago

This is invalid. You can't have touching rings.

144002478 about 2 years ago

1. `access=residents` is not widely supported. `=private` is understood to be this. It's not very needed to add `private=residents` , and it has a collision with `ownership=private` .
2. `barrier=door` should either be `door=` or `barrier=gate` .

143992693 about 2 years ago

`building:flats=` is for the entire building, not per floor.

143975581 about 2 years ago

Please don't add non-commonly used "English" names to `name=` and `name:en=` . Use `name:yue-Latn=` for Cantonese romanization.

143929706 about 2 years ago

It doesn't matter much because transit data are usually not updated frequently. Sometimes weekly, often monthly. Most apps in general only update daily, so you want to preload it before midnight. Again this doesn't matter much after the last trip of the day anyway.

143958872 about 2 years ago

Please don't add descriptor labels. `name=` is for proper names only.

143956862 about 2 years ago

Please don't add not yet opened features directly.

143913702 about 2 years ago

1. `access=private` includes `foot=private` and `bicycle=private` unless you override them.
2. `destination:country=` is documented.

143894104 about 2 years ago

Why are you removing some `turn:lanes=` ?

143732621 about 2 years ago

As I said, `man_made=bridge` is usually for a single bridge deck, especially as it is associated with `layer=` . `building=bridge` already says it can be used for skywalks etc associated with buildings, which is comparable to the situation here.

143751774 about 2 years ago

Do you have any suggestion for a locally-signposted name by the train station that's not used by the locals? It's not `official_name=` . I followed `local_ref=` .

143732621 about 2 years ago

Are there any problems with using `building=bridge` for spiral ramps? They are comparable with bridges. Also I believe the intention was to match with the `=service` + `bridge=` . These are indeed bridges attached to the podium structure.
For reference, `man_made=bridge` is for the bridge deck. Which is obviously stacked and ill-defined here.

143691131 about 2 years ago

Please don't blindly apply presets. The "look" left/right marking is defined as excluded , `crossing:markings=no` .

143680296 about 2 years ago

Please don't draw separate lines for cul-de-sac without raised center island.