OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
144587941 about 2 years ago

Please don't add `=traffic_signals` to the point of intersection when it is already added to the stopping line. This is duplicated.

144587456 about 2 years ago

Please don't remove other valid names. Move them to `*_name=` as seen here.

144527363 about 2 years ago

How did you tell whether some of them are single? Regardless of that, and whether it is is preferred, you didn't replace them with `natural=tree` , and is thus removing data.
You broke a large `=multipolygon` here, and also deleted a `=bare_rock` later .

144573763 about 2 years ago

Please stop changing `=uncontrolled` to `=unmarked` when there is already `crossing:markings=no`

144572424 about 2 years ago

This is not what `company=` is used have. It duplicates info with the `=substation` .

144570771 about 2 years ago

Surely everyone refers to them as "Star Ferry" .

144534922 about 2 years ago

And you are notorious for accusing others without responding to them.

144554299 about 2 years ago

osm.wiki/Why_can't_I_delete_this_trail%3F

144554299 about 2 years ago

Hi, please read osm.wiki/Why_we_won't_delete_roads_on_private_property and osm.wiki/Why_can't_I_delete_this_trail? for issues. This is not preferred. The exact conditions should be recorded, not deleting because you want to do something based on good intentions.

144529446 about 2 years ago

You also removed other attributes.

144529446 about 2 years ago

Tags on a `=construction` or `proposed:highway=` reflects what it will be. Not what it is now.

144527363 about 2 years ago

You broke several tree areas here. Please don't touch them if you are not interested in editing them.

144308363 about 2 years ago

Please don't follow others blindly. This is the unpaid area only. The station box with the tracks and platforms are under Man Cheung St. Separate area should be created to distinguish them.

142167291 about 2 years ago

Please don't add estates and developments as `place=` . This causes inconsistency in both `landuse=` and `place=` .

144458833 about 2 years ago

Please don't move features wildly. Both are `=peak` on their own. When renaming, change the names only.

144437947 about 2 years ago

Please don't delete shops as they represent a shop space. This preserves the position, and avoids deleting any addresses accidentally. Remove the tags, change it to a plain "Point", or change to `was:*=` .

144429391 about 2 years ago

1. Please don't use `=permit` for "Except with permit" in HK. It means at most `=private` almost every time.
2. Please don't change `vehicle=` to `access=` . This means pedestrians are affected as well, without overriding.

144409729 about 2 years ago

Please don't change `=uncontrolled` to `=unmarked` . `crossing:markings=no` has already been used.

144388427 about 2 years ago

1. There is much consensus in Discourse. Plus applications eg Nominatm calling for this.
2. What does that mean? Lines are the equivalent for `route=ferry`
3. Why should the government be followed? They still don't resemble a name, more of a label that shouldn't be used. There are alternatives discussed. osm.wiki/User:Nadjita/Routes#New_tag_label=*
4. This is arbitrary. The naming on `=bus` doesn't follow Schedule of Routes exactly either for "Urban Route" etc. Preventing change doesn't hold, as further renaming is avoided for eg North Point via Kai Tak or Kwun Tong first. Both rerouting and change of management doesn't happen frequently anyway. This argument is not used on bus and trains either.
Coral Sea Ferry is the common name here. It shouldn't be obstructed by redundant info in `from=` and `to=` .

144388427 about 2 years ago

Please read osm.wiki/Proposal:Use_description_instead_of_name_for_route_relations and osm.wiki/Talk:Buses#Bus_Route_Naming . This should not be done.
Elsewhere eg London's River, they may even be unnamed. Staten Island Ferry doesn't need to say `=Whitehall - St George` either.