OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
137487357 over 2 years ago

Please don't add non-existent settlements.

137723422 over 2 years ago

Please don't add these. Use OpenHistoricalMap.

137723781 over 2 years ago

Please don't add these. Use OpenHistoricalMap.

137888206 over 2 years ago

2. Please don't add romanizations if they aren't commonly used. They belong to `name:yue-Latn=` .

137888206 over 2 years ago

Please don't remove `=grassland` if this is what this area is. `place=` should not be used on areas in general.

137910744 over 2 years ago

Please stop adding English names to `name=` and `name:en=` when they are only romanizations. This is unneccessary. `name=` must be in common use.

137726981 over 2 years ago

Please don't change `*:yue-Latn=` to `*:en=`. English name used must be common. Otherwise it can only be accepted as romanization.

137739964 over 2 years ago

Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=`. It is for proper names only. Use the final completed title of this feature.

137645274 over 2 years ago

Let me do it. But thanks for spotting this first.

137645274 over 2 years ago

This is an obvious mistake for "Shop 13" which should be corrected accordingly...

137492903 over 2 years ago

4. Please stop adding names to `=coastline`

137492903 over 2 years ago

3. Please don't blindly romanize names into `name:en=` when it is not commonly used yet. Use `name:yue-Latn`.

137492903 over 2 years ago

Please notice this is a `man_made=beacon` not something else. `name=` is also the common name in public use now.

137481770 over 2 years ago

There is nothing about `turning_loop=` in the wiki either. And now I justify myself by adding my own documentation. osm.wiki/Proposal:Roundabout_details#Turning_circles_and_loops

137481802 over 2 years ago

So unless you can provide an alternative to show this explicitly, this is not a productive edit.

137481802 over 2 years ago

Also you are destroying information as although these `=turning_loop` are separately drawn now, they aren't shown to be one.

137481770 over 2 years ago

Look, I'm one of those who started using `turning_cricle=` for the shape. So you can ask before your edits. Never edit something because wiki says so. It is not the iron rule. In the initial development, only shapes are documented to be used. This doesn't mean there is a clear wrong or unspecified usage.

119306802 over 2 years ago

@os-emmer Please take a closer look as wiki only stipulates its usage with `highway=turning_loop`. There is nothing wrong about using it when it is separately drawn.
I feel `usage=` is a better solution for `=unclassified` and `=residential` not having a `_link`=*. It may also be used for frontage roads and other types of roadways.

137056579 over 2 years ago

Please notice that `=permit` means it is always granted, not a "permit" in UK sense.

137019847 over 2 years ago

2. Please understand that `name=` is the most commonly name currently in public use. They have already been added in `alt_name=`.
3. Please add Cantonese romanzation in `name:yue-Latn=` only. Don't use `name:en=` unless it is commonly used in English.