Hi can you please discuss this? This is to be consistent with the Kowloon `=city` , and the HKI `admin_level=5`
There's already `place=state` node/24330691
Otherwise Kowloon should be changed to eg `=region` (if "twin city" is not literal)

`building:material=` is defined as the cladding/facade/exterior / external surfacing, not the internal structures (although this may be the same if only painted)

The surrounding area should have been be unrelated to not create an invalid shape way/1136869272/

Please don't duplicate the entire site on all parts, and removing `proposed:landuse=` relation/19258555

`addr:housename=` has been used for the estate (to be broadly at the same level as the `addr:housenumber=` ), and `addr:unit=` for buildings (the other wiki definition, for Tower 1A sub-buildings, and above podiums)

No, these are rough works needed for routing. You should detail the internal layout, not delete it entirely.

1. Please don't delete `=footway` across buildings
2. Please don't delete shops directly, as they still represent store spaces. This makes tracking and updating more difficult. It should be changed to existing tenant, or "Vacant".

I don't know how iD produced this. Waterloo Rd needs to be split.

Please don't draw a new line when there's no physical separation. This should use `bus:lanes=`

6. Baby Care Center is not a `shop=baby_goods`

0. Please use accurate upload comment, not a signature with today's date
1. The `man_made=tower` is already enclosed by the `attraction=` way/795214584
2. Why is a popcorn cart `=cafe` ?
3. Are the deleted points torn down? At least some of the `=tree` doesn't seem to be.
4. Please don't use descriptive labels in `name=` which is proper names only. `description=` is already used.
5. You can add `healthcare=yes` , but don't remove `emergency=healthcare`

1. Canton Rd `=tertiary` is for Tong Mi Rd left-turn to MK Rd
2. Frontage roadways should not use `*_link` (common problem worldwide)

Please don't delete the island, which represents what's under the `=tree`

`=locality` is for unspecified, uninhabited, and non-addressing locations. Ta Kwu Ling is obviously used to refer to the estates commonly.

These are not villages, but rural areas. The actual villages are Au Tau, and Ta Ku Ling San Tsuen.

Another consideration is necessity of addresses as `=suburb`

Don't take wiki literally, as it's not guaranteed to be complete. There's problem with the "urban" and `=town` definition. `=suburb` is still used in rural, which may be considered to be in "township" surrounding a `=town` , eg Sha Tau Kok, Sai Kung, Yuen Long. HK further has some distinguishing between the concept of villages and the area they are in, due to compactness or land, and administration or politics.
But this can be `=quarter` to `=neighbourhood`
It was reported to be reinhabited in recent years. However, that can be `was:place=hamlet` + `=isolated_dwelling` too.

There are clear gaps between some. It should not be an aim to fill it fully in a simplistic method. https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/707104213 way/707104214

The smaller `natural=wood` you deleted may be distinct, and surrounded by other land covers https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/707104216 https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/707104218
Please avoid merging them into a larger one, as this would be reducing the detailedness and precision way/707104219
It's a hint you have to redraw after deleting https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/707104217 way/1450268325

1.1. At least we can consider whether classification should change when it intersects roads of the same, or higher class (ie `=primary` Nathan Rd). But this is considering Argyle St routing, not MK Rd alone.
1.2. Tai Kok Tsui (also currently `=tertiary` )doesn't justify `=primary` at the western end. Tong Mi Rd would be from WKC, or LCKR, which should route via Nathan Rd.
2. This is not the same situation, as Argyle St eastbound doesn't continue from west of Nathan Rd. Starting the `=primary` on Argyle St (Sai Yee St; or Sai Yeung Choi St S), or Sai Yee St (MK Rd intersection) doesn't explain it. Therefore it needs to start at Nathan Rd.