Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 175349626 | 18 days ago | This is not a net improvement, as `name:en=` is wrongly changed, breaking any application using it for English names to find and show bus stops. Presumably no apps are able to relate the `=bus_station` with `=bus_stop` directly and visibly.
|
| 175339959 | 19 days ago | I don't know what you are doing. But you should multi-select by holding [Shift] as usual. |
| 175339959 | 19 days ago | Please don't blindly merge different road sections. They are split to show different attributes. |
| 175195537 | 20 days ago | 2. As I said, whether this has been an estate would be covered by `abandoned:landuse=residential` |
| 175195537 | 20 days ago | 2. Eg if Wang Chi House returns, but the Court voted to rebuild, it's still `=residential` until they move out |
| 175195537 | 20 days ago | 1. The structure is independent of the use. If there's no one living there , it's not `=residential` now. Unless you are arguing it's a short-term closure.
|
| 175264666 | 20 days ago | That has the entire road blocked, and physically. You said there are sidewalks available here. |
| 175228401 | 20 days ago | Please don't remove `is_in:suburb=` here. Only unstructured `is_in=` is deprecated, not `is_in:*=` structured. There's no `boundary=administrative` to replace it. |
| 175264666 | 20 days ago | Some applications may not process `footway=sidewalk` in a simplified view. Snapping may snap to the roadway, causing them not to be used. |
| 175300460 | 20 days ago | Please don't change `name:zh=` to `name:yue-Hant=` , as the label of "Mandarin Chinese" is simply wrong or misapplied by default. It means unspecified Sinitic langauges. |
| 175264666 | 20 days ago | A congested or crowded road doesn't mean you are not allowed to walk on it. The presence of `footway=sidewalk` doesn't determine what its `highway=` road should be, which can be `=use_sidepath` if pedestrian are legally prohibited from the roadway. |
| 175195537 | 20 days ago | 1. What do you mean by there's "no actual changes to the estate itself"? `landuse=` is about the use. The use has changed from being uninhabited to inhabited.
|
| 175264666 | 21 days ago | `access=` is interpreted for all modes. Can pedestrians walk there? |
| 175195537 | 21 days ago | OSM is about the existing reality, and `landuse=` the existing use. `=brownfield` means it's not inhabited. |
| 175232142 | 22 days ago | Please don't create duplicates. Edit the existing ones. |
| 175220587 | 22 days ago | If you are doing this, you would need to correct the `start_date` |
| 175195537 | 22 days ago | You could argue the `ruin*:landuse=residential` , but it's not being lived in now. It's a `=brownfield` , not `=residential` |
| 175203713 | 22 days ago | `access=emergency` is not used, and `emegency=` doesn't show whether it's originally EVA-only. Emegency units using it should be treated as short-term closures functionally, not the same physical permanent damages. |
| 175156192 | 23 days ago | 1. Please use meaningful upload comment, not a single useless word
|
| 175137330 | 24 days ago | Notice the `=city` is `admin_centre` , and `=state` the `label` |